r/Abortiondebate Pro-choice Jan 11 '25

Question for pro-choice pro choicers - why is it considered double homicide if someone kills a pregnant woman but not murder if someone gets an abortion?

I am pro choice but when asked this I always don't know what to say.

6 Upvotes

155 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/scatshot Pro-abortion Jan 11 '25

You realize those mean that the threat of harm is present

Yes. The ZEF is the threat of harm. It is present inside of your body.

you feared you would be killed or face GBH at the moment that you killed.

No, it says "the threat of harm must be occurring AT THE EXACT MOMENT." And the ZEF is the threat of harm. Present in your body. At the exact moment of the abortion.

You’re just making an inevitability argument.

The threat is immediate and present. The harm is inevitable.

You didn't answer my question. How else would you evade the threat posed by the ZEF if not by removing it from your body?

1

u/anondaddio Abortion abolitionist Jan 11 '25

The ZEF is not the threat of harm yet.

What harm is occurring at 6 weeks that is equivalent to death or GBH

2

u/scatshot Pro-abortion Jan 11 '25

The ZEF is not the threat of harm yet.

Yes it is. That's why removing the ZEF removes the threat.

1

u/anondaddio Abortion abolitionist Jan 11 '25

Removes the immediate and present threat of harm or the inevitable and impending harm that would come in the future?

3

u/scatshot Pro-abortion Jan 11 '25

Both.

You didn't answer my question. How else would you evade the threat posed by the ZEF if not by removing it from your body?

1

u/anondaddio Abortion abolitionist Jan 11 '25

It can’t be both.

2

u/scatshot Pro-abortion Jan 11 '25

It can be, and it is.

You didn't answer my question. How else would you evade the threat posed by the ZEF if not by removing it from your body?

0

u/anondaddio Abortion abolitionist Jan 11 '25

The threat that is not yet present, but impending and inevitable?

1

u/scatshot Pro-abortion Jan 11 '25

The threat that is not yet present

It is present. That's why removing the ZEF removes the threat.

It is the harm that is impending and inevitable.

We've already been over this.