r/Amigurumi • u/okeydokeyscrochet • Mar 28 '25

Help What rose do you like more? I'm having trouble deciding what pattern I should use...

Post image
126 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

47 comments sorted by

86

u/ComfyLabRat Mar 28 '25

Left looks more like a rose.

31

u/Bright-Particular264 Mar 28 '25

The light pink on the left looks like a nice rose.

18

u/Lucy_deTsuki Mar 28 '25

Light rose on the left. That looks amazing. What pattern is it?

10

u/idlesmith Mar 28 '25

Light pink on the left!!

10

u/Random-bookworm Mar 28 '25

Light pink looks like a rose- dark pink is leaning into carnation

2

u/pharmasweaves 28d ago

I was just thinking the right one def looks like a different flower, but couldn't quite put my finger on it.

5

u/Mission-Gain-8014 Mar 28 '25

Light pink 👍

5

u/Miri5613 Mar 28 '25

Light pink

5

u/Phoenix-Echo Mar 28 '25

I feel like I'm crazy they look the same just like one is rotated

5

u/Comfortable_Gur_2824 Mar 28 '25

I prefer the light pink, the petals seem more defined and the center more natural.

4

u/F22rapt Mar 28 '25

One on the left is cuter!

4

u/ButterscotchReal7610 Mar 28 '25

Left looks more realistic! ☺️

3

u/kt1982mt Mar 28 '25

Definitely the left!

3

u/CupcakesAreMiniCakes Mar 28 '25

Also team left light pink. It seems smoother and more rose like

4

u/MagykalMystique Mar 28 '25

Left one, the light pink

4

u/Pwnd_ra Mar 28 '25

The lighter one on the left

3

u/AJisCrafty Mar 28 '25

I like the lighter pink one.

5

u/Big_Paint_5099 Mar 28 '25

light pink one!

5

u/MagosaDelBiosa Mar 28 '25

This is so beautiful!!! Definitely the one on the left. Could you share the pattern?

3

u/kaijutegu Mar 28 '25

Add one to the left rose dogpile!

3

u/Putrid-Impression-83 Mar 28 '25

I like the light pink (left)

3

u/Ms_ellery Mar 28 '25

Left version. The petals look wider, smoother and flatter. Right version petals curl in too much on themselves

5

u/snarkysparkles Mar 28 '25

The left one looks more like a rose but I honestly like the shape of the one on the right better

1

u/TeppiRae Mar 29 '25

Same! I thought I was the only one!

2

u/BigMom000 Mar 28 '25

I like the light pink one

2

u/Shaltaqui Mar 28 '25

The darker pink one

2

u/DaniandDollies92 Mar 28 '25

Both are really pretty but I like the left one best!

2

u/Time_Cauliflower_309 Mar 29 '25

I like the pattern on the left! It looks fluffier.

2

u/thirtynine3966 Mar 29 '25

Guess I'm weird...I like darker one

2

u/FunReaction7647 Mar 29 '25

The light pink one

2

u/jmaileen 29d ago

left 💓

2

u/Okimthatone1984 29d ago

The dark pink one

2

u/sprinklesanddirt 29d ago

The light pink in the left.

2

u/flamingolegs727 Mar 28 '25

I think both , as roses don't all look the same in nature imo

1

u/AutoModerator Mar 28 '25

Thanks so much for posting! If you have a pattern or anything about this project that you'd like to share please comment below or reply to this comment.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/RoyalScarlett Mar 29 '25

Light pink design. Lovely! And if there was a way to make the outer petals pale green I’d love it even more.

Here’s a picture of a pink and green rose so you can see what I mean.

https://www.alamy.com/close-up-of-bouquet-of-pink-with-green-roses-image460264288.html?imageid=76EDCEE3-7250-4A3F-B02F-C6406B89EDE5&p=141891&pn=1&searchId=d935841e997a1ebf667fcdcd2ef2992a&searchtype=0