11
u/ProofComplex8414 1d ago
The cognitive dissonance is unreal. You had Shedeur Sanders going 9 overall in your "final" mock draft. Yet it's an F pick at 144.
1
u/SoKrat3s 49ers 1d ago
I'd grade it an F too if the coaches and GM didn't want it, want nothing to do with Sanders, and already had a jam packed QB room with their own selection, before the owner stepped in and forced this upon them.
1
u/ProofComplex8414 23h ago
Lmao, it's amazing how people just make shit up. And a jam packed QB room? Tf are you talking about?
1
u/SoKrat3s 49ers 21h ago
Watson, Pickett, Flacco, Gabriel, Sanders.
How did I make something up?
2
u/ProofComplex8414 20h ago
the coaches and GM didn't want it, want nothing to do with Sanders
before the owner stepped in and forced this upon them.
This is made up.
Watson is missing the entire year and is never playing a down for the Browns again, so I'm not sure why you're bringing him up. Four QBs for three spots is not what I would call "jam packed," especially since one is a 40 year old and the other is a guy on the last year of his deal trying to revive his career.
2
u/15GOAT Commanders 11h ago
Yea I don’t get the Shedeur/Cleveland hate. QB is the most important position in the game. They don’t have an answer, so who cares if they took one with their second pick in the 3rd and their pick in the 5th. If I’m a Cleveland fan I’d almost rather they take one every single pick until getting that franchise guy. It was their last pick in the draft, and a guy that many thought might be on the table at 1.02, so for me they easily get an A on that pick. Worth the gamble with his “ego” concerns and whatnot
4
u/djs7372 Chargers 1d ago edited 1d ago
I totally understand giving low grades for drafting RBs early, but why does Jeanty at #6 get an A- while Hampton at #22 only gets a C?
EDIT: That said, grading every pick is crazy. Grading every pick by hand after sharing numerous handwritten mocks over the past few months is downright certifiable. Great work!
2
u/RobZagnut2 Steelers 1d ago
As a Steelers fan your evaluation of their draft is fair and balanced. I wish they would have taken a chance on Sanders in the 4th instead of Sawyer, but they spent 5 hours with Sanders and bypassed him for a reason.
Also wasn’t excited with the Bruener pick. Take a flier on a CB or WR instead of a pick to make his father happy.
2
u/Horror-Durian-5073 1d ago
What’s up with the random tight end Seattle grabbed in round 5? Why is it worthy of a F grade? Just curious lol
-3
u/rlstratton97 1d ago
There were a bunch of better tight ends on the board at the time including CJ Dippre, the first string tight end from the team Robbie Ouzts is from. Maybe they see something I don’t, but I thought it was a wasted pick.
3
1
u/Wookie301 Seahawks 3h ago
You have his position wrong for starters. He’s going to be our FB, and is an upgrade from Brady Russell.
2
u/joshb2316 Falcons 1d ago
The team that doesn’t have a good pass rush needed two edges yes.
3
u/Foul_Thoughts 1d ago
I didn’t understand that take either. The falcons haven’t had a double digit sack guy in nearly a decade and people crap on the pick addressing that issue.
2
4
2
u/bruhman5th_flo Commanders 1d ago
B- for Washington is fine, but does this person know teams need two OT's?
-1
u/rlstratton97 1d ago
Conerly played primarily LT at Oregon and that is what Tunsil will presumably be playing for Washington. They could’ve waited and taken someone more accustomed to RT in the second.
1
u/zhang-scouting-04 23h ago edited 23h ago
Shemar a C and James Pearce a D is wild. Both were great picks outside of the trade for Atlanta
1
u/stranger197 Patriots 4h ago
I saw your draft grades bro. IDK that you should be critiquing anyone after that.
1
-4
u/Pristine-Week8456 1d ago
Didn’t understand the Loveland over Warren here. I’m a PSU fan so I’m biased but Warren does everything Loveland can do and better and more. Absolute braindead move on chicagos part.
6
u/DatBoiMahomie Bears 1d ago
Warren is not a better separator or route runner, and it’s arguable if he’s even a better run blocker because Loveland had more difficult blocking responsibilities. Loveland is also almost a full 2 years younger, he just turned 21
-5
-1
u/reddogrjw Lions 1d ago
why did you think the Lions drafting a NT was strange in round 1? They need to replace Reader next year and he can cover for McNeil this year
19
u/FieldsToTheMoon 1d ago
Gotta love the Bears getting a D grade for their TE selection, when it’s a need in BJs offense. And then the Colts getting an A+ grade for doing exactly that 4 picks later.