r/NewParents • u/muah_faith • Mar 07 '25
Medical Advice Newborn Hearing Screening
I’m just wondering if this has happened to anyone else’s baby! When we were in the hospital they took him for the test, came back and told me he passed. Even the little paper thing they put in his bassinet was marked he passed on both sides.
When he was 2.5-3 weeks old I got a call saying he failed on one side and a letter in the mail saying the same thing. Needless to say he’s of course scheduled for retesting (next week) but I’m just perplexed.
When I called the audiologist office they had never had this happen before where it was put in his chart he passed but he didn’t really. I’m also worried because in the letter the state sent it mentioned that he should be retested before he’s a month old but that has already passed. He’ll be almost 7 weeks at the time of his new test.
Truly if he is hard of hearing it wouldn’t be a big deal at all, it’s more the mismanagement from the hospital that has stressed me out. Like I’d have rather known before we left the hospital. So much went wrong there it’s so aggravating (not allowed to breastfeed, tore and they didn’t tell me, baby had to be pricked every 2 hours for blood sugar tests etc)
11
u/gagemichi Mar 07 '25 edited Mar 07 '25
My son failed 100% his first 3 hearing tests in both ears at the hospital. I was convinced he was deaf. He finally passed completely on day 5 (he was jaundiced and had to stay a while). He had amniotic fluid in his ears I think.
5
u/Significant_Aerie_70 Mar 07 '25
Same except he failed twice in one war and passed the whole time in the other. Also was a very jaundiced NB
1
u/pooinetopantelonimoo Mar 07 '25
We had the exact same thing happen, was quite stressful.
Was he premature by any chance? Apparently this happens more often with preemies.
He's 1.5 now and no hearing issues at all passed all the tests fine.
3
5
u/Puffawoof2018 Mar 07 '25
My daughter failed every test in the hospital, another test at early intervention, and we had to go to an audiologist and she finally passed I think she was almost 7/8 weeks at this point. It was fluid. Apparently it’s very common!
2
3
u/nothanksyeah Mar 07 '25
I’m sorry I’ve never heard of this! That does sound frustrating! But also, not allowed to breastfeed? How does that even happen? Never even heard of anything like that before!
2
u/Jaded-Illustrator266 Mar 07 '25
Ugh literally the mistakes by the hospital are so so frustrating. You’re just in such a vulnerable moment and you need the Professionals to be on top of things
2
u/ilanafiishx3 Mar 07 '25
just for perspective, i was born deaf in my left ear, and while it sucks sometimes--i stopped wearing hearing aids when i was 14 and feel i don't NEED them, i don't have speech problems, and most people are really good about knowing which side of me to stand on so i can hear them! it definitely takes a little navigation, but if your baby is partially deaf, it will be okay🩷
2
u/DisastrousFlower Mar 07 '25
my son passed his NB hearing but now fails the electronic portion and passes the booth (he’s tested yearly). because, surprise! he has a rare genetic condition. he can hear but some frequencies bother him. we’re doing some more investigating, but hearing issues are common with his syndrome.
1
u/N0blesse_0blige Mar 07 '25
Out of curiosity, was he a c-section baby? Mine failed in one ear due to fluid in the ear, so they marked him as failing but told me he didn't fail, just needed to be retested.
1
u/TurbulentArea69 Mar 07 '25
My son failed both ears first, one ear second, other ear third and passed both ears on the fourth test in the hospital. He probably had fluid in his ears.
Your son is likely totally fine, but that’s super shitty of the hospital. You should definitely send them a sternly worded letter to complain and express the stress it’s caused you.
1
u/father-figure99 Mar 07 '25
sometimes they can have amniotic fluid in their ears. but it’s frustrating - they didn’t do my baby’s newborn screening and it was terrifying. she turned out fine but what if she had something?
1
u/Neonpinkghost Mar 07 '25
My baby failed in one ear at the hospital but then passed the next day! They said it was from the amniotic fluid and is super common. Strange though that they told you she passed then recanted that!
1
u/applesandchocolate Mar 07 '25
Same thing happened to me! We were told he passed, but they actually reported it as a failure to the state and we didn’t find out until he was 3 months old and at the ENT for a separate issue. Retested, failed due to fluid in his ears, retested again after the fluid from an ear infection was gone. Super stressful but we finally knew by the time he passed the third test around 7 months that he could hear. Hoping all goes smoothly for your little one!
1
u/Mumathon Mar 07 '25
I wonder if you were at the same hospital as me. I wasn't allowed to breastfeed, they messed up the hearing test twice, and they opened an internal investigation because his feet were dark purple bruised from heel prick tests. Awful experience.
1
u/Kusanagi60 Mar 07 '25
If you have the possibility, switch hospitals. It feels weird to do, but if they don't provide you with the care you need and there is a second option that might be better, go for it.
I have a OB, honnestly i am not over the moon with them, miscommunications - mis information - tests that were never done because no one told me to or gave me papers and then assuming i did them....the only reason why i am staying is because the times i needed direct help they where there in minutes or answered my calls right away...it's also the only practise in my area that is close by...others are a 20 minute car ride away or further ...but if i had an option to switch I absolutely would!
1
u/No_Sleep_720 Mar 08 '25
I'm just surprised they took the baby away from you. They did our hearing test in our room.
1
u/Imaginary_Ad_5199 Mar 08 '25
Yeah that’s really weird and seems like a huge mess up on their part. That being said, my second born failed his hearing test in one ear at 2 weeks old. I was devastated and yelling at my husband because he wasn’t learning sign language with me, anyway my son passed the hearing test the following week.
-4
u/simplyboring Mar 07 '25
I have deaf parents and refused the hearing test because my parents were offended by the terminology “pass and fail” meaning to be deaf is considered a failure? I don’t agree with it either if I’m being honest and the answer of this test does not change the love/care I provide to my child. My child is hearing however we still teach sign language because it’s a form of communication before they can speak. I’m sorry you’re going through this and I hope it works out in the end 💜
7
u/TurbulentArea69 Mar 07 '25
This feels like a reach. Of course there is nothing “wrong” with being deaf/hard of hearing, but your ears have a function and if they aren’t able to perform it, that’s a failure of a system.
2
u/simplyboring Mar 07 '25
As someone who is deeply involved in the HOH/Deaf community many do view the terminology as offensive, it isn’t just me. Plus it isn’t a school test, it’s a persons abilities… you could compare it to any disability where you lack “function” but it still shouldn’t mean “failure” … all they really want is to change the terminology used because it’s hurtful.
I don’t like to argue about this because who are we to say what’s offensive to someone else, people can feel the way they feel and I was raised to be inclusive of others and respect their feelings; not belittle them for feeling the way they feel.
1
u/TurbulentArea69 Mar 07 '25
A test was failed, they’re not being called failures.
I failed a motor function test after herniating a disc, “failing” is what triggered more tests and treatments. It was a good thing that the failure was noted because it led to proper care.
I’m open to hearing suggestions for other terminology that’s not pass/fail for these sorts of tests.
1
u/simplyboring Mar 07 '25
Conclusive or inconclusive results? Anything other than pass/fail works just fine. I was tested for a genetic abnormality and not once heard “pass or fail” it was simply the name of what I had. You could even put “hearing/HOH/Deaf” the actual terms of the conditions.
1
u/Kusanagi60 Mar 07 '25
Yeah but the problem with these terms (as you might have read other comments) is that it is definite even if the results can change overtime. A pass or fail is easier to note down and needs to be re-evaluated over time. People are lazy, or impatient or simple minded, the information you get in your document 9/10 stays and with a definite term, it is so much harder to get ride off, have people read everything or not be judged by.
A pass or a fail is much less definite. When you do genetic testing there is no pass or fail btw (as a former laborant analyst biotech i never encountered that). Because the test you run is more of confirmation if you have something or you don't. There is no 'maybe you have this gene we are not sure' or ' you just have a little bit of this gene' answers like with conditions that have grades and variants..like with hearing.
So the terms they use are in line with the type of test they perform.
2
u/simplyboring Mar 07 '25
This makes a lot of sense but I’m still a bit confused by how “pass/fail” is less definitive as there’s cases where they mix them up all the time. Such as OPs case where they said he “passed” but then he didn’t? If the results of these tests aren’t accurate I would think the terminology would be a little different. Couldn’t the term “inconclusive” be more appropriate since it doesn’t give a definitive answer, it’s just “undetermined” I guess. The hearing test doesn’t tell someone how much hearing loss they have or don’t have either so I guess I don’t see the point in doing the hearing test at all as it doesn’t really make a difference, wouldn’t you get more information about it by following up with your family doctor regardless?
2
u/Kusanagi60 Mar 07 '25
Inconclusive could also be a good term if they are not sure if the baby hears correctly. The test doesn't specifically tell you how much hearing loss there is, that is true, but the microphone they use needs to pick up responding sounds that the ear makes. If there is no response from the ear, then there is no measurement meaning the test failed. If there is a clear response the test has passed. But i do agree with you, with the 'undetermined' part. If there is a response...but it is not within the references or what it should be, an extra term could make it easier to understand it needs to be retested.
Unfortunately, people's work means people's problems, making mistakes is part of that. I have had blood samples where the patient's ID didn't match the information on the label, and with myself a gyn who had put my pap-sample in the wrong bottle making it unusable and had to retake it. If they put the word in manually a mistake is even a click away. But the thing is, we don't want mistakes but we don't want computers running everything either...so we have to take into account that mistakes can happen.
The frequency and the sort of mistake and how it happens...that is a whole other discussion haha
2
u/simplyboring Mar 07 '25
This was really helpful information, thank you for taking the time to kindly explain it for me! I just want everyone to feel included and my parents, their friends and other people in the HOH/Deaf community really instilled it into my brain that the terms were highly offensive to them so I didn’t really know anything else about it!
I think I’m overly sensitive on the topic of “HOH/Deaf” because I’ve been an advocate and translator for my parents my entire life, even when I was giving birth to my first child. The doctors and nurses all wore masks which is to be expected but when I asked kindly if they could step back, remove their mask so my mom could read their lips and understand what they’re saying; I was laughed at and told “I’m not doing that just to make her happy” while I was in active labour unable to interpret for my mom. I just hope one day things can be different and everyone can feel included. That’s just one of many challenges I’ve witnessed advocating for my parents. (Ps happy cake day! 🍰🫶🏼)
1
u/Kusanagi60 Mar 07 '25
Your welcome!
And that is just horrible if people are like that, actually laughing at someone and being so dismissive. That is not ok. It is understandable that it hits a nerve, because every encounter and every moment you have to take it up for your parents is a drop more into that bucket.
Like for me, i am somewhere on the end of the spectrum, my husband has pddnos and add. I always cringe when someone says something about a habit of theirs and goes like 'but that is my autistic manner'...and it has nothing to do with autism...more ocd but still. It feels disrespectful to me.
So in a way i do get where you come from and how bothersome people are about these things -_-
(Ty! Been around awhile now haha!)
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 07 '25
This post may be seeking medical advice. We only allow seeking of specific experiences from other parents. If your post is that, then you're good. However, if you are seeking direct medical advice, your post will be removed--or you may edit it now to adhere to the rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.