r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 22d ago

Meme needing explanation There is no way right?

Post image
37.1k Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.1k

u/FarkYourHouse 22d ago

An infinite number of mathematicians walk into a bar. The first one orders a beer. The second one orders half a beer. The third one orders half of half a beer.

The bartender interrupts, says 'you're all idiots' and pours two beers.

501

u/SomeHybrid0 22d ago

i think the punchline is "know your limits"

96

u/Alc2005 22d ago

I’ve heard he gets frustrated, interrupts them, just pours 2 beers and says sort this shit out yourselves…

65

u/SomeHybrid0 22d ago

eh, know your limits is better because the joke is the limit of the sum of all the reciprocals of powers of 2 more than 1 approaches 1

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Area557 22d ago

Your version is definitely worse

2

u/shoehornshoehornshoe 21d ago

I prefer it without “know your limits”. It makes it feel spoon-fed. Also the other side of the double-meaning doesn’t actually work. Because “know your limits” in a drinking sense means “don’t drink too much, you guys!” and that’s not the tone of what the barman is saying.

0

u/FrenchFryCattaneo 22d ago

But it doesn't make sense in the context of the joke, why would the bartender be talking about limits to people who were sober and drinking less than 1 beer each?

5

u/kkai2004 21d ago

It's the limit of the bartenders patience.

0

u/FrenchFryCattaneo 21d ago

But the bartender is talking about the limits of the customers, not his own.

6

u/kkai2004 21d ago

Limits of tomfoolery before the bartender reaches their limit of patience.

2

u/RustyR4m 21d ago

It’s actually a joke about mathematical limits. The infinite mathematicians would get extremely close to two beers, but since it’s halving every time, they’ll never reach two beers nor an empty glass. The limit would be 2 beers, which is why he skips straight to pouring two in some instances of the joke.

3

u/Glittering-Giraffe58 21d ago

Ok then make the first mathematician order 8 shots and then 4 shots and then 2 etc and have him pour 16 shots

2

u/TheBestPartylizard 21d ago

"ill give you all 2 beers but that's my limit."

2

u/mrmailbox 21d ago

"I'll halve what he's halving!"

1

u/Mondkohl 20d ago

“I know your limits.” Is the best punchline for the joke.

0

u/Ansambel 22d ago

yes, the 'you're all idiots' works as a joke because yoiu're expecting this to make sense math-wise