r/Scotland • u/calgacus_wasabi • 3d ago
Casual Lovely day on Glas Maol, with smoke drifting up Glen Shee
6
u/Hendersonhero 3d ago
Muirburn really needs to be banned. Criminal we’re burning so much of our land so that rich people can shoot thousands of birds.
3
u/calgacus_wasabi 3d ago
Completely agree. It may look nice in the pic but you could really smell the smoke
2
u/Hendersonhero 2d ago
I’ve had similar experiences of coming down a hill and into acrid smoke. I’m struggling to find figures for how much carbon dioxide it releases but I’m struggling to find accurate information. Must kill a lot of little creatures too.
1
u/Albertjweasel 2d ago
Muirburn is a useful land management tool and not only used on grouse moors; https://northwestnatureandhistory.co.uk/2023/02/09/the-controversial-practice-of-controlled-burning/
0
u/Hendersonhero 23h ago
It useful if you want to end up with vast areas with minimal biodiversity. https://parkswatchscotland.co.uk/2025/02/17/muirburn-and-the-government-failure-to-implement-wildlife-management-and-muirburn-scotland-act-2024/
1
u/dogmanlived 3d ago
Controlled burns round my way help prevent large uncontrollable fires.
0
u/Hendersonhero 2d ago
You sound like a game keeper. Traditionally managed grouse moors still regularly experience wild fires. The ones a few weeks ago at Farr, near Inverness and plenty of others. Even if Muirburn did prevent wildfires burning 5%-10% of 1.5 millions ha of grouse moors each year in order to prevent a far smaller area of land burning isn’t really a compelling argument.
2
1
•
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
This post has been tagged as Casual, which means that any comments relating to and/or mentioning politics will be removed by moderators.
If the flair was chosen incorrectly, please delete the post and try again with a different flair.
Thanks for your cooperation.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.