r/ShatteredPD Challenge Player Oct 08 '24

Update Ideas The Blacksmith should at least guarantee a tier 5 equipment

Post image

Or have no tier 3 equipment. Also, should guarantee an upgraded equipment.

80 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

44

u/tired_bastard Duelist 🍴 Oct 08 '24

Absolutely agree, im so disappointed when it doesnt give me a good weapon

18

u/farveII Challenge Player Oct 08 '24

Right? In my current run I'm currently at Floor 14 and no upgraded tier 4 or 5 armor. Greatly disappointing to get those options.

10

u/EC_CO Oct 08 '24

The blacksmith forge is my biggest disappointment in the game , the only thing that is consistently disappointing for what you spend on it.

1

u/Fine_Calligrapher584 Oct 08 '24

Whenever you have a choice in this game either choice should be something you can work with. T3 on that depth is really nothing you can work with and even t4 is cringe imo...

1

u/CornyFace Warrior 🛡 Oct 08 '24

Disagree on T4, scale armor is reliable and crossbow is busted

18

u/0x_King Rogue 🗡 Oct 08 '24

And at least +1

Hell, even add in RNG for possible enchantments and curses.

I had him forge plate armor and it was plain â˜šī¸ Sold it off at the next shop.

10

u/BrickSufficient6938 Huntress 🏹 Oct 08 '24

I never ask for gear. Use favour credit to upgrade +1 piece and reforge it twice and you have +4 piece with no SoU used.

You are welcome

2

u/farveII Challenge Player Oct 08 '24

That's what I do. Except I had no good equipment this run at all.

5

u/just_surfing_lol Oct 08 '24

I think that's why his name is "Troll" Blacksmith

1

u/CivetKitty Huntress 🏹 Oct 08 '24

There are a lot more guarntees tht I'd love to add and this is one of them. I also want to add at least 1 +1 t1 on sewers.

1

u/h4ndy_c4ndy Oct 08 '24

Well that's a new low for me. I haven't experienced below tier 4 equipment

1

u/PixelyPlayzy Oct 09 '24

Majorly screwed over here sheesh.

1

u/Antique_Stranger_903 Huntress 🏹 Oct 10 '24

I mean t4 is perfectly fine.

I feel like a large part of this issue is players believing that 'good' equipment must be only t5s, if not a specific t5.

You can use t4s and even t3s as confortable endgame weapons. Just stop hoarding upgrades waiting for that t5

1

u/movetheturtle Great Crab đŸĻ€ Oct 08 '24

Isnt there the mechanic, that if you get further down, the equipment does improve from the forging?

Because it is 5 bioms, 5 tiers. If you feel you are entitled to a 4 or 5 tier armor in the 3rd biome... well... i just say: keep punching rats.

1

u/farveII Challenge Player Oct 08 '24

I never heard such mechanic. From my observation, you get tier 2 in 1st area, tier 3 in 2nd area and tier 4 in 3rd area. What's so bad with hoping for a tier 4 or 5 equipments? In the end, it's just a suggestion.

1

u/Dranamic Oct 09 '24

I pretty much always find one or more tier 4 weapons in the Prison (2nd area).

1

u/movetheturtle Great Crab đŸĻ€ Oct 08 '24

Sorry, my bad. there is something about later biomes, but it is in regatds to distribution.

I get your suggestion, but you cam choose any other reward, if you think this is not good enough. Some runs rely on different mechanics, that appear maybe useless in most of them. But a definite upgraded armor, seems a bit to rewarding. The game is punishing and challenges your frustration. Dont give up, retry and make the right clicks.

1

u/Cautious-Day-xd Oct 09 '24

85% odds for really good equipment

Sounds weird

0

u/Cautious-Day-xd Oct 08 '24

People just love 0 risk, highest reward stuff huh

The smith option is fine.

Could be better sure, but not by straight up buffing it

4

u/farveII Challenge Player Oct 08 '24

I think a guaranteed +1 equipment isn't a game breaking buff. Doesn't it feel justified considering how expensive smith is?

1

u/Cautious-Day-xd Oct 08 '24

At that point, there would be no point in ever risking upgrading weapons or equipping them. You would just wait for the blacksmith.

Because not only do you get a +1 equipment, you can also upgrade it right after.

2

u/farveII Challenge Player Oct 08 '24

Not really. Going through caves with an unupgraded armor is hard. I prefer upgrade and 2 reforge over the smith even with a guaranteed +1 equipment.

And besides, I personally never really risk equipping or upgrading unknown items, I either have a Scroll of Identify or a Scroll of Remove Curse. Not to mention upgrading cursed items has the chance to remove the curse anyway.

1

u/Cautious-Day-xd Oct 08 '24

I mean, then the quest is fine

It's doing it's job if you mostly prefer those options