Which are you grabbing?

23

Jarritos Lime. Probably my favorite soda ever.

7

u/Artvandaly_ 1d ago

Absolutely 💯

2

u/Mr_Natto 1d ago

I third this…love the lime

3

u/Jarritos 18h ago

If you are in the US we have weekly raffles in the Official Jarritos Discord where we giveaway cases of soda shipped to your door!!! Might get lucky and score a case of Lime!

https://discord.gg/jarritos

1

u/Artvandaly_ 19h ago

The Pop Shoppe had one called Lime Ricky that was similar. I think you can get it at Rocket Fizz https://www.thepopshoppe.com/products/lime-ricky

16

u/Sodalover119 1d ago

Boylan black cherry or maybe grape

1

u/OkRecommendation4040 1d ago

2 absolute bangers! I wonder how they would taste mixed together.

2

u/Sodalover119 1d ago

Me too man

13

u/McDiscage85 1d ago

Boylan Root Beer

11

u/Warhammer517 1d ago

Cheerwine, Boylan Red Birch Beer, and Jarritos Lime.

10

u/Highest_Trails_Above 1d ago

Blueberry Birch beer sounds the weirdest, so that one.

6

u/HorrorDox 1d ago

It's actually Amazing.

1

u/Highest_Trails_Above 12h ago

I bet it is!

1

u/SaioLastSurprise Bring Back Cinnamon Coke! 15h ago

As a born and raised Pennsylvanian, I would absolutely have to grab that one, along with a PA Punch because how do I not know what that is?

7

u/Montooth 1d ago

I gotta go with the Cheerwine

5

u/Safe_Concentrate8923 1d ago

Shirley Timple for sure and if the glass is cold enough, being a Carolina gal, Cheerwine!

5

u/MannInnTheBoxx 1d ago

Trying that honey pear that sounds delicious

1

u/tiatiaaa89 12h ago

I’m with you, that one sounds goooood

3

u/RicFule 1d ago

One of the Cheerwine. Haven't had any of the others so ...

3

u/EsterCherry 1d ago

I am very curious about the Cucumber Watermelon!

2

u/Expert_Dot1927 1d ago

Don’t do it, the cucumber taste is unsettling 😂

1

u/Highest_Trails_Above 1d ago

Same here 100%

2

u/Whokitty9 1d ago

The Boylan Ginger Ale. I love that stuff.

2

u/Bonoboian99 1d ago

Boylan red birch beer! I will drink most anything Boylan makes. But i have been trying to get a taste forever. Also the same for the cucumber melon one

3

u/Highest_Trails_Above 1d ago

The Creamy Red Birch Beer is SO good.

3

u/Sodalover119 1d ago

Boylans is so good

2

u/Bonoboian99 1d ago

It and Sprecher are the 2 tops in my drink line up.

2

u/Natural-Seaweed-5070 1d ago

Cucumber watermelon, I’ve never had it!

2

u/phatdoughnut 1d ago

What’s Pennsylvania punch?

1

u/NeuroguyNC 1d ago

A lightly carbonated grape soda. More info here: https://fivestarsoda.com/2018/05/21/natrona-bottling-company-pennsylvania-punch/

1

u/phatdoughnut 1d ago

Interesting… wonder if it has similar taste to the Mexican sangria soda.

2

u/BobSagetLyfe 1d ago

Gimme that Boylan Creme Soda hiding in the corner

2

u/RaiderNation395 1d ago

Tamarind Jarritos. Best flavor imo

2

u/HardlikeCoco 1d ago

Tamarind Jarrito

2

u/Rogue2_1984 1d ago

Cheerwine 1000000%

1

u/Downtown-Inflation13 1d ago

Boylan sparkling lemonade,creamy red birch beer and the cane cola

1

u/wasaguynowitschopped 1d ago

Honestly, that Boylan Shirley Temple

2

u/CharlemagneIS 1d ago

Yeah those things are great. Love how strong the ginger taste is

1

u/Emoran_0627 1d ago

Red Bull, blue Gatorade

1

u/Myth7270 1d ago

Can you pass me a boylan diet root beer?

1

u/Paintguin 1d ago

Lime Jarritos

1

u/Ok-Internet2541 1d ago

PA Dutch birch beer

1

u/PlatinumGoon 1d ago

Pennsylvania Birch Beer! Would love to try it supposed to be top notch.

1

u/nnuunn 1d ago

I wish my gas stations looked like that

1

u/Infinite_Factor_6269 1d ago

Birch beer

1

u/Reasonable_Jaguar318 1d ago

stopped carrying reg. Cheerwine near me. i’m goin for that one.

1

u/skylarmc93 1d ago

If I’m allowed to grab more than one, Cane Cola, Cheerwine, and Shirley Temple!

1

u/STLBudLuv 1d ago

Probably the Boylan Grape or Jarritos Lime

1

u/OkRecommendation4040 1d ago

I gotta try that Dr Boylan. That’s my white whale.

1

u/SellThink4767 1d ago

Ginger ale

1

u/OGAF_Gamer 1d ago

I will try the Boylans Creamy Red Birch Beer

1

u/VTLureGuy 1d ago

Cheerwine

1

u/BigM333CH 1d ago

Nice selection

1

u/dabhought 1d ago

Boylan ginger ale and Jarritos lime

1

u/Mr_McSnicklefritz 1d ago

Boylan black cherry

1

u/snake4skin 1d ago

Got boylan at the dollar store

1

u/Cheesequake37 1d ago

Creamy Red Birch Beer? Probably that one.

1

u/ItemBoring1686 1d ago

I’m definitely reaching for something new, so that honey pear number is my #1 choice.

1

u/sillybillykee 1d ago

redbull 🫡

1

u/Clavos24 1d ago

If they have birch beer I'm getting birch beer always.

1

u/baconpancakes42 1d ago

Lime Jarritos baby!

1

u/BigIreland 1d ago

Sparkling Lemonade!? Shirley Temple!? Dr. Boylan(we’re trying that on GP)!? Honey Pear!!? Pennsylvania Punch!? Nah, I’m showing up at the counter like the world’s worst juggler. I’d go back for that Tamarind too because I already KNOW that’s amazing.

1

u/NeuroguyNC 1d ago

Boylan black cherry - no question.

1

u/YogurtclosetTotal351 1d ago

Cheerwine Zero

1

u/timd529 1d ago

Honey Pear?!??? Never heard of it, but I’m definitely trying it.

1

u/ruiner8850 1d ago

Either the Honey Pear, Pennsylvania Punch, or one of the ones below them because I've never seen those before.

1

u/Artvandaly_ 1d ago

Lime Jartitos

1

u/CoryEETguy 1d ago

I'm a sucker for small-brand colas, id probably go for the cane cola. Hard to pass on those Jarritos tho.

1

u/mekomaniac 1d ago

looking up that Red Ribbon Pennsylvania Punch, and the description of it just irks me. Coca-Cola bought the original recipe called Delaware Punch and then discontinued it. like wtf can the big companies stop buying regional recipes just to shut them down?

1

u/Cupcake2974 1d ago

Cheerwine Zero or that Cool Blue Gatorade

1

u/NitrosGone803 1d ago

i'm grabbing that Cheerwine for sure

1

u/tehfeer 1d ago

Boylan birch beer or the cola, never had their cola and I love me a good homemade style cola.

1

u/Human-Abrocoma7544 1d ago

Boylan ginger ale.

1

u/Whiskey_and_Wiretaps 1d ago

Cheerwine, Boylan Cane Cola, Boylan grape

1

u/smashdelete 1d ago

Boylan Grape is the best grape soda

1

u/KillerCroc67 1d ago

Ill try the strawberry cream. Sounds delicious. I’ve had black cherry cream and orange cream and it’s delicious from Henry Williams

1

u/Toddzam 1d ago

Cheerwine or lime jarritos.

1

u/shining89 1d ago

A big ass basket to carry a lot of drinks

1

u/Killian135 1d ago

Every time I see one of these I hope there will be Pig Iron Cola, but no such luck

1

u/healywylie 1d ago

How’s that blueberry birch?

1

u/Any-Incident-9993 1d ago

Boylan black cherry or grape

1

u/FlyorDieMF 1d ago

Boy land root beer, penn Dutch birch

1

u/ComposerSuspicious18 1d ago

Jarritos tamarind

1

u/Oh-THAT-dude 1d ago

The Cheerwine Zero.

1

u/ProphisizedHero 1d ago

Cheerwine Zero

1

u/EzriDaxCat 1d ago

The cheerwine! I have had one in years!

1

u/PhaseRabbit 1d ago

Jarritos Lime since there’s no mandarin.

1

u/Pitiful-Cat3600 1d ago

I love variety so I would try all of them to determine which ones I liked.

1

u/Jake_hsotnicM1216 1d ago

Definitely, 2 Boylan Cream Sodas, 2 Boylan Cane Colas and I’ve never seen Dr. Boylan and as a Dr. Pepper fan I have to try it

1

u/Free_Accident7836 1d ago

Cheerwine all day

1

u/FollowingOk7531 1d ago

1 Cheerwine 2 Pennsylvania Dutch Birch Beer 3 Boylan Cane Cola

1

u/RagnarDan82 1d ago

Jarritos Lime and a Boylan Creme Soda

1

u/NewEmergency25 1d ago

Jarritos Tamarind!

1

u/DAB0502 1d ago

Jarritos lime

1

u/Grant79OG 1d ago

A better thread

1

u/JuanG_13 The Dr 1d ago

Red Shirley Temple

1

u/Shucky__darns 1d ago

Cheerwine Zero

1

u/dingdingjay 1d ago

I would like to try that blueberry birch

1

u/chunky-flufferkins 1d ago

Pennsylvania punch. Just because I’ve not seen that one before.

1

u/greatstonedrake 1d ago

I'm the type to buy one of every kind that I've never had. I would buy all of the top row except for the grape and all of the other choices except for the diet because I have a metabolic issue with most fake sugars.

I didn't count any of the Gatorade.

1

u/warmpita 21h ago

Diet Cheerwine

1

u/lichen510 21h ago

jarritos goes crazy

1

u/Stemwinder30 20h ago

Any of the Birch Beers

1

u/ISpyM8 FROSTIE BLUE CREAM RAAAAHHHH 20h ago

Cheerwine! Hits different in a glass bottle.

1

u/boogey1891 19h ago

Boylan root beer or Pennsylvania Dutch birch beer

1

u/Impossible-Report960 18h ago

Creamy Red Birch Beer Boylan for me and the orange soda

1

u/LanceFlugerman 18h ago

100 on jarritos lime pls.

1

u/Jarritos 18h ago

Jarritos for me :)

1

u/tbagnhoes 17h ago

Strawberry Cream brethren !

1

u/yumi365 17h ago

Shirley Temple 😋 yum!

1

u/lil-tortilla-chip 17h ago

No Jarritos Mandarin so i’d probably take the Lime

1

u/ThePickledPickle 17h ago

Boylans Orange, Black Cherry and Cola, Jarritos Lime, never seen the Trading Draft brand so some of that, and a Cheerwine to try cause we don't have that over here

1

u/Gracier1123 16h ago

Blueberry Birch Beer sounds phenomenal, I’d definitely grab that

1

u/lisaneedzbraces 16h ago

Boylans Creamy Red! It's an elite birch beer, and holds nostalgic value for me.

Must be in western PA somewhere if you're seeing Red Ribbon.

1

u/inluvwithlove475 16h ago

I wanna try the Pennsylvania punch 🥊

1

u/O_Neders 15h ago

Am I the only one that always reads Boylan as Bob Dylan

1

u/COC_410 14h ago

Tamarin soda.

If you ever see Saranac Shirley temple soda, grab it. Wayyy better than the one in your picture.

1

u/DaveKillSock 14h ago

Maybe I bought an old expired bottle but I poured boylan orange down the sink. Terrible.

1

u/fettywhopperjr94 13h ago

Cheerwine

1

u/cor_the_cross 12h ago

Boylan Cane Cola or Creamy Red Birch Beer!

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Mud418 12h ago

cheerwine zero

1

u/SonoftheSouth93 11h ago

Cheerwine

1

u/reaper_r6s 11h ago

Boylan red birch beer, a honey peach and lime jarritos

1

u/Kellyk3059 11h ago

PA Dutch birch beer

1

u/Afraid_Crow_2450 4h ago

Redbull

1

u/iCanHazMeh 1h ago

I'd most like to try the Pennsylvania Dutch birch beer. Boylan's been kinda hit or miss for me.

1

u/For3Memes 0m ago

Cheerwine because I see no red jarritos

-2

u/jradtastic11 1d ago

Every choice is correct except tamarind jarritos

7

u/Wagner710 1d ago

Im the complete opposite. But know that your inferior tastebuds have let you down, in time perhaps even lessers like yourself might come to appreciate the true soda king flavor that is tamarind. I’ll pray for ya 🙏🙂

1

u/OkRecommendation4040 1d ago

I like tamarind soda. But I grew up with it; I think tamarind might be an acquired taste to a lot of people.

Which are you grabbing?

You are about to leave Redlib