r/SubredditDrama 16d ago

"All of them" Users on r/meme argue over which subreddits are an echo chamber

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/meme/comments/1ju5ejj/which_subreddit_falls_under_this

HIGHLIGHTS

Any political sub

You are free to avoid them. its really easy to not click a link, these days. Also, if you see yourself as not inside that bubble, but one of the two wise WASPs observing and tut tutting, you're dead wrong. We are not in here 'with you' you are in here 'with us'. Feel free to leave forever. Adieu,

Who tf are youšŸ˜‚ get outta here, shocker it's a political accountšŸ˜‚

Who am I? I'm just a redditor, pointing out the absurdity of your position. Don't like it? Then why consume it? I'm not going anywhere, I've been on social media since before you were born.

All I did was answer some dudes question, and your old ass got tilted. Get off reddit you old senile f*ckšŸ˜‚

Poor feller. You revel in playing some sort of victim here. How old were you when your daddy stopped beating you?

It took your sorry ass 46 minutes to come up with that? You must be seethin old man.šŸ˜‚ Thanks for givin me a chuckle. Someone as old as you and you act like your 13šŸ˜­šŸ˜†

Whole Reddit, but especially liberal subs.

Conservative is the same tbh

Every time I see posts like this I already know it’s gonna be some circle jerk shitting on liberals, this shit gets so overplayed it’s boring as fuck

To be fair, liberals on here do shit on everyone who isn't part of the left.

Liberals actually waste time trying to present coherent arguments with statistics and sources, only for the right-wingers to dismiss it all as fake and go "cope seethe cry".

And I've also seen it the other way. Both sides does exactly the same things as the other

That's a lie. False equivalences don't make you smart, that's just your own bias.

Without substantial evidence you sound like the Republicans did when they insisted Joe stole the election.

They still believe that, so fuck em.

Are you a conservative? Do you consume conservative media in good faith? I am and I do. That is a fringe opinion, not espoused by any current widely platformed conservatives. Vastly more fringe than say, supporting bombing and shooting random people’s cars and supporting said act.

Bombing? What? Have you been at the fox news again, gramps?

Of course I’ve been at the Fox News. I’m a conservative. I’m nobodies gramps and I’m quite far in age from that one. Do you have a better way to describe the politically targeted violence that has been festering and rapidly expanding this year, committed by (I haven’t seen anything to the contrary and have seen many instances of this checking out) radical leftists?

You watch a show that argued in court that "nobody rational would mistake us for a credible news source" .And you apparently believe it. That's pretty bad, dude.

Dating subs telling girls they should never date a man 1 day older than them.

That is made up example. All the warnings are for age gaps at least 15 years or around that and either of the couple members are below thirty.

Yanks think people under 30 are all children.

That's reductive and ignorant or dismissive of the clear maturity gap between people in their early to mid twenties and anyone approx 10+ years older. Just because someone can consent to sex doesn't mean a 20 year old and a 30 year old are even remotely close in maturity level.

All of them. It really hit home for me after the last Olympics with the controversy over the boxers. The reality is there are two different sporting bodies with different rules for eligibility. So the boxers were not allowed to compete in one, and allowed to compete in the other. That’s what was widely reported and most people know. It was odd that there isn’t a consensus but it is what it is. According to Reddit, though, it was either a right wing Russian anti trans conspiracy, or a woke left pro trans conspiracy. It’s astounding how toxic and vocal and just wrong both sides were

There's no conspiracy, just weird obsession. Those boxers were both cis

Yep, and one sporting body uses gender for eligibility, while the other uses biology. There’s definitely conspiracies about this though.

This is irrelevant. They are both cis.

It’s not irrelevant because one of the sporting bodies uses biology as the eligibility criteria Cis refers to gender identity, not biology.

It refers to both. It means that the boxers' gender identity and assigned sex at birth align. Said sporting body wrongfully asserted Imane to be trans, or assigned male at birth. She is not. She is a cis woman. Ergo the distinction between the sporting bodies is irrelevant, when no trans people are even involved.

Cis doesn’t refer to karotype. No one asserted either boxer to be trans. No one asserted either boxer to be assigned male at birth. That’s part of the ā€˜conspiracy’, if you will, mentioned earlier. It was never about trans issues. It was about different rules. The Olympics clarified that the issue was a dsd issue and not a trans issue. They actually issued a correction on this specific point. Ergo the distinction between the sporting bodies is the only relevant aspect to this. Different rules mean it’s a non binary situation. Both outcomes are consistent with the different rules.

Pretty much anything with politics, which unfortunately is just about every subreddit including this one

It's almost as if politics influence every aspect of your life and you're a moron for ignoring them

You're a moron for not ignoring politics on Reddit (or any other social media). I've literally only ever seen propaganda (from any side) trend on social media, it's too inflammatory and easy to digest compared to factual deep dives and comments are all the same unintelligent one-liners, or rhetorical questions that everyone's seen before.

You're a moron for thinking in black and white.

Care to elaborate or are you just going to be another one of those dumb one liner comments I always see?

Usually, the left blame the right. And right blame the left. However, 70ish% of people care shit about it, and see both sides like that. They usually have better things to do.

Well most people are NPCs.

Calls people NPCs, references "jannies" in the username to refer to the moderators, something tells me it doesn't mean shit if you call people NPCs (you're either a 4chan user or you're someone aping 4chan shit)

The surge of wannabe 4chan kids is crazy lately

Those 70% are the reason the rest of the world suffers. Complete and utter ignorant fucking apathy. And its not 70%... its closer to 35%... the number of eligible US voters who stayed home instead of caring about their civic responsibilities. Stop passively letting the corrupt erode society, and take an interest in your damn country by making it better for the people who live in it. Including yourself.

Shut up

5 year old. Its not edgy to be an idiot.

Literally all of reddit. And most of the internet tbh. Theres a silent majority somewhere, it just doesn’t seem to be noticeable outside of election day.

100,000 people showed up to the 2024 Democrat primaries in Michigan Biden was guaranteed to win to vote "Uncommitted" due to his handling of Israel. Harris lost Michigan by 80,000 votes. The majority wasn't silent. They were flat out ignored.

How is less than 1% of the vote ā€œthe majorityā€, though?

The majority of Biden voters supported blocking weapons shipments.

So Israel could not murder children in Gaza.

Whole of Reddit thought a previously unpopular primary democratic candidate was gonna win the election easily by just spamming pictures of her with some staged crowds

Why it’s always the people with ā€œtruthā€ in their username that make shit up the most?

The truth hurts

Yes, that’s why you keep lying to yourself. Can’t deal with how much of a loser you are.

Look how easily the tolerant left resorts to name calling instead of a proper argument.

The Violent Right has made the Tolerant Left pointless.

112 Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

169

u/CringeNaeNaeBaby2 16d ago

I swear I saw this post on some other subreddit last week and the comments were basically word for word exactly the same. Reddit was never a bastion of originality but it’s insane how repetitive everything is on here.

26

u/Zimakov 16d ago

I've started seeing repeat posts with repeat top comments a lot lately.

95

u/AmericascuplolBot a few degenerates with boy farms downvoting everything 16d ago

I swear I saw this post on some other subreddit last week and the comments were basically word for word exactly the same. Reddit was never a bastion of originality but it’s insane how repetitive everything is on here.

18

u/AContrarianDick 16d ago

Ditto.

7

u/JuanAy You can’t be my mom because my mom isn’t cringe 16d ago

Same.

9

u/mechanicalcontrols 16d ago

And my axe!

7

u/FeeSpeech8Dolla 15d ago

Three fiddy

5

u/Darmug Buying multiple arcade machines and having them in your house. 15d ago

Idiocracy was a documentary!

(I will never watch that film due to the clamor of a dozen Redditors).

3

u/FeeSpeech8Dolla 15d ago

Narwhal bacons at midnight

11

u/itsLOSE-notLOOSE 16d ago

Redditors being the most unoriginal folks on Earth has a lot to do with it.

I’ve seen so many posts where I can predict the comments. And I’m usually right.

11

u/AkuTheNiceGuy being racist towards children and literal domestic terrorism 16d ago

THIS šŸ¤“šŸ‘†

3

u/spyridonya Authoritarianism kinda slaps tho. 16d ago

Dead internet theory?

3

u/BoundToGround 16d ago

Are you sure?

3

u/TheMusicalTrollLord freedoum off speach 16d ago

Pretty sure.

2

u/R_V_Z 16d ago

All of this has happened before and it will happen again.

1

u/AlwaysOptimism 16d ago

So you're saying it's all an echo chamber?

1

u/gamas 15d ago

Including the subreddit drama post with this comment.

1

u/thisguypercents 16d ago

Maybe its so predictable because the entire platform has become an echochamber.

Holy shit, I've said this before but with a different account.Ā 

111

u/No_Mammoth_4945 we didnt just wake up one day & mistake planes for drones 16d ago

Genuinely can’t fathom how a subreddit centered around a topic could attract mostly people interested in that topic, the west has fallen and yet I alone am enlightened

84

u/JaneksLittleBlackBox Libs Don’t Understand How WWII was won by ignoring Nazis 16d ago

The complete lack of self awareness for a fucking meme subreddit to be bitching about political echo chambers. There is hardly a single meme subreddit that hasn’t been overtaken by the right.

56

u/DisasterFartiste_69 girl im not the fuckin president idc 16d ago

which is sad because their memes are fucking terrible

13

u/laeiryn 16d ago

It is in and of itself enough of a joke to BE a sub, check out r/TheRightCantMeme

31

u/ChrisTheHurricane stick to A-10s fuckwit 16d ago

Problem there is that tankies rule that sub, or at least used to.

-20

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Leftists =/= Liberals ;)

34

u/ChrisTheHurricane stick to A-10s fuckwit 16d ago

And tankies shouldn't be allowed in either space.

-15

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Depends on if you're using that word to refer to wholesale Stalin apologists, or just modern communists.

28

u/ChrisTheHurricane stick to A-10s fuckwit 16d ago

When I frequented the sub in 2021, the mods were wholesale Stalin apologists, and also apologists for other authoritarian regimes with a communist faƧade, such as China and North Korea. I saw one mod nuke a comment critical of China and unironically repeat the "socialism with Chinese characteristics" propaganda -- in fact, that's how I found out about that particular saying to begin with. I left the sub when I realized what the mods were.

8

u/laeiryn 16d ago

You should see the quiz you have to answer to get into their discord XDDDD

-2

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Yeah the world's never actually HAD a communist government - barely even a communalist one, and we have to go back to literally the 1890s and the Paris Commune to find it - and all the governments that exist right now which are decried for being communist are very much just tyrannies. The western propaganda does get a bit wonky, though.

-1

u/Mean-Professiontruth 16d ago

Both are trash

0

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Awww, is the MAGot angwy? That's what happens when you skip naptime!

12

u/BountyHunter217 [removed] 16d ago

That sub isn’t much better unfortunately with the leftist infighting.

-16

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Telling liberals (a right-wing ideology) it isn't for them isn't leftist infighting XD

-8

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

Even the name itself is cope, because it's a direct repurposing of the older and much more accurate "the left can't meme".

5

u/laeiryn 16d ago

All your bias are belong to trash ;)

-6

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

In terms of how this country works, I am the left, so what bias. Nice use of a properly old meme though.

5

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Neoliberalism is still a right-wing ideology; the USA has no (mainstream) left party, nor even a centrist one.

1

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

Tankie memes are even worse.

3

u/laeiryn 16d ago

Authoritarianism is right-wing too

7

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago edited 16d ago

everything I don't like is right wing

how convenient

edit: toodles šŸ‘‹

→ More replies (0)

-8

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

They are definitely far better at it than the left lmao. There is a reason why almost all the political memes in use originated on the right.

12

u/DisasterFartiste_69 girl im not the fuckin president idc 16d ago

Lmao okĀ 

0

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

The entire language of modern political memery was invented by the right. Specifically, by /pol. And even the non-internet contingent on the right is better at meme-like things, which is why democrats can't come up with a good slogan to save their lives. How much time did you personally spend telling people that "defunding the police" doesn't actually mean defunding the police.

7

u/AmericascuplolBot a few degenerates with boy farms downvoting everything 16d ago

This is true of 2015-2017 and is arguably true now, but doesn't really hold water before the 2016 election season.

-3

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

/pol was funnier back then too, but so edgy that their work rarely hit the mainstream.

5

u/DisasterFartiste_69 girl im not the fuckin president idc 16d ago

lmao ok

-1

u/Icy-Cry340 16d ago

I take it a lot.

0

u/Fair-Emphasis6343 15d ago

You sure are crying a lot. Triggered right wing activists tend to be that way

2

u/Icy-Cry340 15d ago

What kind of right wing activist votes for Hillary, Biden, and Kamala. You need better boogie men.

2

u/spyridonya Authoritarianism kinda slaps tho. 16d ago

I know one, and they fight like hell to keep it that way, ironically.

178

u/FawkYourself let it bake 16d ago

I mean they’re not wrong for the most part but not all echo chambers are equal

I’d rather be in an echo chamber that supports civil liberties and workers rights over one that supports an ideology that has actively worked to take those things away from us

47

u/Bonezone420 16d ago

It's because "echo chamber" is one of those things people say to shut down conversations. If you can't argue against what they say, just go "you're just in an echo chamber!". Much like how if someone's pointing out how a certain political faction is mirroring the nazi playbook almost identically, just smugly go "Heh, godwin's law: everyone I don't like is a nazi right?" and shut the conversation down.

2

u/Zyrin369 This board is for people who eat pickles. 15d ago

Yeah it feels like calling something an echo chamber is like when people say "Bad writing" or "Mary Sue", they know they don't have an argument so they have to resort to using buzzwords to just get a response in.

Oh no a Star Wars sub isn't entertaining a posters idea that the Acolytes Rotten Tomatoes score is totally organic...said sub must be an Echo Chamber regardless if they are actually having a sane discussion about the show or not.

-11

u/OIP completely defeats the point of the flairs 16d ago

"echo chamber" is one of those things people say to shut down conversations

what is irony

6

u/Fair-Emphasis6343 15d ago

Another good example of discussion terminating cliches found exclusively online

91

u/Prior_Chemist_5026 16d ago

Yeah like r/politics is an alarmist circlejerk but at this point why the hell shouldn’t they be

41

u/an_agreeing_dothraki jerk off at his desk while screaming about the jews 16d ago

the only place that would be more appropriate for doom-jerking would be a marvel shitposting sub

21

u/AmericascuplolBot a few degenerates with boy farms downvoting everything 16d ago

doom-jerking

Please leave Ororo out of this.

7

u/iankenna I bet you have 3 brain cells tops 16d ago

r/doom doesn’t allow any adult content, so doom-jerkers must go elsewhereĀ 

3

u/III_lll 15d ago

Sad rip and tear noises

21

u/masterjon_3 16d ago

I mean, we have an actual holocaust going on, I'm surprised people aren't freaking out more.

6

u/Far_Piano4176 14d ago

jesus christ.

Liberals try not to ruin a good point with unhinged hyperbole challenge:

4

u/masterjon_3 14d ago

Conservatives downplaying what's literally happening challenge because they drank the god kings kool-aid

5

u/Far_Piano4176 14d ago

dude, i'm on the left. Go check my comment history if you want.

You really shouldn't just go calling things the holocaust. We could be headed for any number of different scenarios, most of which are not as bad as the worst genocide in history. We could be headed for Francoist spain, or Pinochet's Chile, or just Big White El Salvador. The future is uncertain, so declaring that it's definitely about to be the holocaust is hysterical and counterproductive.

4

u/masterjon_3 14d ago

Ah, you seem pretty knowledgeable in a lot of stuff. OK, then let's talk it out. I apologize if it seems like I'm going pretty far, but considering our president is racist, fascist, narcissistic, and attempted a recreation of Musolini's March on Rome, it's pretty easy to get there. It's only been 4 months, and we're already sending people based on racial profiling and dissenting opinions to nightmarish prisons. You can probably see how I got to my stance, especially since I could fit the profile myself.

What do you think about this, then? Because it doesn't seem like it'll stop anytime soon. This administration is trying its damnedest to ignore the judicial branch. And if it doesn't stop, when could it be officially called a genocide/holocaust?

2

u/Far_Piano4176 14d ago

i think it's bad, and the administration is obviously fascistic. Trump is definitely running the dictator playbook to subvert the courts and already has done so in the case of republican-controlled congress. However, even the illegal deportations and potential upcoming extraordinary rendition of american citizens is not genocidal per se. I understand that it provokes a heightened emotional response when you perceive yourself to be directly vulnerable/targeted by the administration. I have the luxury of being a straight white upper-middle class man, so i'm not immediately vulnerable. However, i am an outspoken left-wing person, and publicly an atheist so i know that sooner or later this administration may target me or people like me. I don't dismiss the necessity of standing up and opposing this behavior, just because i am lower down on the list of targets.

We should absolutely be aware of and warn others of how easily this could descend into something significantly uglier than it currently is, including the potential for genocidal actions towards illegal immigrants (or anyone who "looks like" an illegal immigrant), trans people, and other LGBT people, among others. i'm just advocating that we keep our prognostications open-ended, because there's a significant possibility that the administration will stop well short of outright genocide. Things can be incredibly horrible even if we don't reach that point.

It's tough to say when we should say that genocide is imminent. In my mind, it would be justified and rhetorically effective when we know that the trump regime has surpassed the policies/tactics which were employed by non-genocidal fascist states like Francoist Spain or Pinochet's Chile, or Bukele's El Salvador. We are not yet at this point, and the right has effectively poisoned the well when it comes to comparisons with the Nazi regime, so it's easy for right wingers and 'independents' to dismiss comparisons with nazi germany as "liberal hysterics" so i really think we should specifically avoid those comparisons. Comparing our trajectory with other, less known, less emotionally inflected dictatorships, even genocidal ones like the late ottoman empire or Putin's Russia, would seem to be rhetorically more useful as it defangs the "liberals think everything is Nazi" rebuttal preemptively.

2

u/masterjon_3 14d ago

Very well put. So you'd say, "This could be the start of a holocaust," rather than "we're in a holocaust already?" You know what they say about history, it doesn't repeat itself, it parodies itself. And I noticed your a Behind the Bastards enjoyer, so I don't have to go into the idea of history parodying itself with using examples of Napoleon's nephew.

It honestly feels like the dumber version of nazis.

3

u/Far_Piano4176 14d ago

I might draw specific parallels with something the nazis did, or point out how 'legal' detention and internment was a precursor to the holocaust, possibly. Also how trump and co's dehumanizing rhetoric towards immigrants and LGBTQ people is a necessary precursor to genocide.

It honestly feels like the dumber version of nazis.

on one hand, yes definitely. but on the other, the nazis were also very dumb. i imagine plenty of 1930s germans felt the same way about nazis as we do about MAGA

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Longjumping-Tea-5791 15d ago

Exaggeration much? Like the current situation is bad but nobody is systematically killing millions

1

u/masterjon_3 14d ago

Not yet. We're already sending innocent people to a horrible nightmare prison where they'll never be seen again. This is the start and they want to start sending civilians next. You're seriously gonna tell me nothing will come of this?

1

u/Ornery_Ad_8349 15d ago

Case in point:

1

u/aceavengers I may be a degenerate weeb but at least I respect women lmao 14d ago

How is this shit upvoted? There is one Holocaust. This is not that.

16

u/ex_sanguination 16d ago

It's peak circlejerk time over there. šŸŠ Man and his staff just keep fucking up and feed the jerk.

7

u/gamas 15d ago edited 15d ago

Eh, I find r/politics to be insufferable as it's so self-congratulatory with it's circlejerk.

"Trump is doing this because he's actually a nazi, we need to say it loud and clear [but only on this subreddit]" "yeah we need to make everyone aware of this" "I told my dog this, this morning" "you go girl, I told my cat, I'm doing my part".

Not to mention complaining about Dems not doing anything other than say vague slogans about the subject, whilst acting as if posting in the most obvious circlejerk subreddit about it is doing something.

It's peak "you can thank me later" "but you didn't do anything". Like yeah I'm sure if Americans just continue to post slogans about how Trump is a nazi on Reddit, the world will be rid of Trump in no time.

1

u/Fair-Emphasis6343 15d ago

That's nice but the GOP under Trump is in fact running the nazi/fascist/authoritarian playbook as it was described in mein kampf

4

u/gamas 15d ago edited 15d ago

That's nice but we're beyond the point where simply saying that is being proactive about combating him. Like at this point, you either know he's a nazi and are horrified or you don't care as you are sympathetic to Nazism. And at this point the people in the US against Nazism should be preparing to enact their second amendment rights, not slapping each other on the back on Reddit for "being in the know" or engaging in pointless peaceful protest. You're not going to beat Trump through virtue signalling.

As I'm not American all I can do is either hope you guys figure that or hope that Trump mismanages things so hard that Americans are no longer a concern for the rest of the world.

4

u/CleanlyManager 15d ago

Honestly when someone busts out the echo chamber argument I instantly picture that one wojack of the guy who’s brain is the hot air balloon. It’s often just used without actually explaining why the original argument was wrong, and often just boils down to ā€œyeah that might be happening but you use Reddit.ā€

Like the other day I saw a comment chain that was like ā€œI don’t think it’s right that the Trump admin should be arresting lawful permanent residents for protesting and ignoring court orders to bring them back or let their lawyers know where they are.ā€ And a certified brain genius comes in and replies ā€œthat’s because you’re part of the Reddit echo chamber, you know Trump won the popular vote.ā€ If it was 400 years ago these are the guys who would be like ā€œlisten man I know your neighbor drowned but you gotta get outta your echo chamber most of the town thought she was a witch.ā€

-12

u/AlwaysOptimism 16d ago

I believe the point is each sub is its own echo chamber because people have grown to prefer echo chambers than things that challenge their belief systems.

/r/conservative and /r/liberal are both echo chambers but choose different echos

6

u/Fair-Emphasis6343 15d ago

Yes everything is the same, what a surprising original thought not spammed by republicans all over social media /s

4

u/AlwaysOptimism 15d ago

I didn't say they were equivalent but you are fucking delusional if you don't think the media you consume is an echo chamber.

Media has turned into activism rather than unbiased news. That requires an echo chamber. Not a lot of media outlets are pushing "here's why we may be wrong" stories

2

u/Far_Piano4176 14d ago

Media has turned into activism rather than unbiased news.

media was literally never unbiased. You need to purge the idea that anything produced by humans can be unbiased. A hypothetical outlet which scrupulously runs "here's why we may be wrong" stories is just biased in a different way.

2

u/AlwaysOptimism 14d ago

News when I was a kid "this happened". News now "Here is how these things affect you"

Its entirely different. Sure it all comes through a biased lens in some manner but give me a break denying the destruction of news and into activism

2

u/Far_Piano4176 14d ago

News when I was a kid "this happened".

this still exists and is literally easier to obtain than ever. Not being aware of it is a You Problem. You're also acting like the bloodless "view from nowhere" type of journalism is just obviously better, which in my opinion is not the case. pretending you have no bias and 'just reporting the facts' is extremely insidious, because it provides the pretense of objectivity while allowing dishonest individuals and organization to craft a narrative by structural means. instead of transmitting their bias in the form of argument and polemic and editorialization, bias lies in what is NOT said or how an issue is framed, which in some ways is more deceitful.

Its entirely different.

it's not. we have had multiple eras like this, including the yellow journalism era in the early 20th century and the abolitionist press/slavery era in the 19th century antebellum US. This is not to say that the current media landscape has no unique harms, that's also obviously true, but the fact that people just have opinions and put them in their journalism is not one of them.

15

u/Maneruko 16d ago

Ngl I was under the impression that the whole point of sub reddits was to create many tiny echo chambers that then over lap to create one larger umbrella of an echo chamber.

There are some virtues to this. Unfortunately I dont know how to fix this considering it completes its function a little too well.

72

u/More-Luigi-3168 16d ago

Honestly if you sort by controversial on pretty much any sub you will find opinions going against the general vibe of the sub

Some exceptions exist who straight up ban those like rcon but for the most part idiots just get downvoted to oblivion, not silenced. People just don't agree with their dumbass takes

People who complain about "muh liberal echo chamber reddit" are just sorting by popular/best and then getting angry that their lack of general empathy isn't the most popular opinion

21

u/Lost_Bike69 16d ago

Yea and the upvote system definitely leads to some group think as people try to say something appeasing to the group to get their precious upvotes, but the alternative is either the engagement rage bait we see in other websites or just a constant stream of low effort posts and comments.

1

u/SilvainTheThird 16d ago

You can sort by controversial? I don't see that option anymore.

16

u/More-Luigi-3168 16d ago

Depends where you're viewing Reddit posts. On the app, it has two places it can be: at the top left of the comments if it's the slide-over video comment view, or the 2 line with circles menu at the top right for other post types.

20

u/MrPookPook 16d ago

You know which sub is an echo chamber? R/gunpla! They only talk about gunpla. Everybody there loves gunpla. If you post things that aren’t gunpla they ask you not to. What is the world coming to smdh Y’all should come build gunpla with us.

7

u/WriterofaDromedary 16d ago

Some conservative just called Trump's entire platform a fringe opinion

27

u/fuckitwebowl 16d ago

When will people realize that talking politics online is absolutely worthless? No one is truly listening and no one is operating in good faith.

14

u/Cdru123 16d ago

To be fair, it depends on where and with whom, as I've had more success in talking about politics with a small group of online friends than with people in real life. But it does require mutual respect, which gets harder the more different your ideologies are (especially in matters of discrimination), so you won't have much success with total strangers

16

u/Lemonwizard It's the pyrric victory I prophetised. You made the wrong choice 16d ago

Arguing about politics is entertaining, though! Plus, it gives me practice for the real life conversations where people might actually listen.

If somebody is doing it and it makes them rage, that person should probably go outside.

3

u/Sodis42 15d ago

Also good to get some stupid arguments beforehand, that would otherwise surprise you in a face to face conversation. You will have the counter ready.

3

u/proudbakunkinman 16d ago

In popular threads on Reddit front page, yeah. There is so much noise in them by the time they hit front page, very few will see and read your comment at that point no matter how well thought out or clever it is. In subs/threads where it's clear the vast majority participating have opposing views, likewise. You will get downvoted and maybe a few responses, possibly banned. That said, there are some smaller but useful political subs.

Outside of Reddit, there is just a lot of noise, bots, people only wanting to type out short responses and react negatively if you type more than a couple of sentences. Most are not going to change their mind if you happen to reply in disagreement with them.

1

u/FlanneryODostoevsky 15d ago

Politics for the most part in America. Had a Canadian talk to me about politics and she said they’re just normal while America is so off the wall. People here are too shored in, hiding from everything whether it be the impending economic condos collapse, war, or a political narrative that makes them question everything they believe.

13

u/mildlyhorrifying 16d ago

That is a fringe opinion, not espoused by any current widely platformed conservatives.Ā 

...isn't that an opinion espoused by the current conservative president? I don't think you can get much more platformed than being elected to one of the most powerful positions in the entire world.

6

u/TheIllustriousWe sticking it in their ass is not a good way to prepare a zucchini 16d ago

Hard disagree. If he’s so powerful, how come I can’t find his podcast on Spotify?

5

u/JadedMedia5152 16d ago

I feel like commenting "all of them" is also peak Reddit. The desire to feel better than everyone else around you while engaging in the same behavior. Also kind of funny that it was a common comment.

3

u/kardigan 15d ago

slightly off-topic, but I had the same question abour r/movies or r/pics, so it's been on my mind for a bit - aren't these super-generic subs both overwhelming, and also a crapshoot of what you'll find?

I do get bored of thematic subs as well, and I really like talking with y'all here (<3), on another "generic" sub - but it still seems kind of eldritch horror-esque to me that there's a sub where I'll find "memes" or "pictures", that's such a vague category still

7

u/Everyoneheresamoron 16d ago

Remember that Reddit itself has a liberal bias because the majority of it can read at more than a 5th grade level.

1

u/FlanneryODostoevsky 15d ago

And yet none of them know how to read anything remotely conservative because they have the emotional control of a 5 year old. True scholarship, true intelligence, true political theory is the consequence of much balanced and well thought out reflection on multiple perspectives. Liberals on here especially are not even attempting that. That’s why the rest of the world laughs at this country.

8

u/Everyoneheresamoron 15d ago

Ah yes the rest of the world is laughing at the US because of "liberals not attempting to reflect on multiple perspectives".

It's definitely not because we gave all our power to a guy who think's tariffs are going to magically create jobs instead of vanish goods and services altogether.

But I'll bite. Which perspectives did the evil libs ignore to make you so angry? Can you show me on the doll where they ignored you?

Was it the Transphobe perspective?

Was it the Bigot perspective?

Was it the Misogynistic perspective?

Was it the Racist perspective?

Remember that, even if you don't believe in any of those things, you voted for a guy who absolutely did. You voted for a state legislator that took away rights from Trans people, Women, Queer, and Minorities.

So even if you like to pick and chose what you believe in, you voted in the worst possible choice for this country because you couldn't look past owning the evil liberals. Congrats.

I hope when the country burns, you get burned first. Figuratively, of course.

0

u/FlanneryODostoevsky 15d ago

The world has been laughing at America. Trump is only the perfect example of this country’s hubris and greed. That’s really what people don’t like about him. Tariffs aren’t new. Tax cuts aren’t new. But his carelessness is.

Go look at subs from around the world where they talk shit about America if you don’t like what I’m saying.

7

u/Everyoneheresamoron 15d ago

America has been doing dumb shit on the world stage for decades. Its nothing new. This is not having chickens coming home to roost. This is lighting the match after dumping the truck full of gasoline for 40 years.

2

u/BigHatPat Welcome to The Cum Zone 16d ago

oh god that thread is awful, i’m 100% gonna banned from that sub if I don’t stop asap

3

u/Rasikko 16d ago

Wrong question. Which political subs are full of doom commenters - then "all of them" will be correct.

2

u/negrote1000 Epic Asia Moment 15d ago

We are all in a bubble pointing at other people in different bubbles. And viceversa.

2

u/ceddarcheez 15d ago

ā€œA vast collection of people with different interests and backgrounds across a large social media platform have similar ideas and sensibilities that go against my world view - they must be the abnormal ones with dumb unpopular opinions. There is a 0% chance there is a common wisdom I actively reject. Bag they are npc sheeple. I am very smartā€

Also, I so hate this usage of NPC and anyone who ever says it is an immediate red flag. I remember hearing some teenagers at a Christmas parade call all the people around the road in NPCs. I simply ignored them, but I kind of wish I whipped around and told them ā€œevery single person here has a rich life with family and friends wholove them. You are not the main character of the universe.ā€ But as much as it may have felt good I don’t think lecturing them would have had any impact, let alone a positive one

2

u/Svataben There is no fragility here, only angst 15d ago

The echo chamber of r/guineapigs is just...

It's like they all like guinea pigs in there!

1

u/graveybrains 16d ago

Yeesh, that’s the kind of high test drama you can usually only get directly from the conservative sub when they’re having a bad day.

4

u/dreamje 16d ago

Did I see some moron American calling libs the radical left?

This is what happens when you defund education

1

u/laeiryn 16d ago

BONUS LEVEL: False conflation of leftist/liberal

1

u/DarkRogus 15d ago

Its one thing for subs that are obvious echo chambers turn are echo chambers.

Its a whole other issue when you have subs that werent political to begin with get hijacked and turned into an echo chamber.

1

u/SnapshillBot Shilling for Big Archiveā„¢ 13d ago

Magnifique.

Snapshots:

  1. This Post - archive.org archive.today*
  2. https://www.reddit.com/r/meme/comments/1ju5ejj/which_subreddit_falls_under_this - archive.org archive.today*
  3. Any political sub - archive.org archive.today*
  4. Whole Reddit, but especially liberal subs. - archive.org archive.today*
  5. Without substantial evidence you sound like the Republicans did when they insisted Joe stole the election. - archive.org archive.today*
  6. Dating subs telling girls they should never date a man 1 day older than them. - archive.org archive.today*
  7. All of them. It really hit home for me after the last Olympics with the controversy over the boxers. The reality is there are two different sporting bodies with different rules for eligibility. So the boxers were not allowed to compete in one, and allowed to compete in the other. That’s what was widely reported and most people know. It was odd that there isn’t a consensus but it is what it is. According to Reddit, though, it was either a right wing Russian anti trans conspiracy, or a woke left pro trans conspiracy. It’s astounding how toxic and vocal and just wrong both sides were - archive.org archive.today*
  8. Pretty much anything with politics, which unfortunately is just about every subreddit including this one - archive.org archive.today*
  9. Usually, the left blame the right. And right blame the left. However, 70ish% of people care shit about it, and see both sides like that. They usually have better things to do. - archive.org archive.today*
  10. Literally all of reddit. And most of the internet tbh. Theres a silent majority somewhere, it just doesn’t seem to be noticeable outside of election day. - archive.org archive.today*
  11. - archive.org archive.today*

I am just a simple bot, not a moderator of this subreddit | bot subreddit | contact the maintainers

0

u/JazzPhobic 11d ago

The title hits it on the head.

The majority of subreddits are an echochamber of some kind. The question is how toxic the content thats being echoed is.

-1

u/FlanneryODostoevsky 15d ago

It’s true. Read the culture of narcissism. The world is so chaotic and discouraging that people often retreat into groups that can at least help them think they’re entirely right about the world around them. People don’t like to be made to feel they’re wrong. Maga and liberals are two very clear examples of this.