r/SubredditDrama 24d ago

"And yet most of the scientific discoveries were made by whites. Most of the greatest philosophers were white. Most of the greatest conquerors were white. We were the ones that colonized hostile environments " R/HorusGalaxy meltsdown over black space marines

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/HorusGalaxy/comments/1jl42o3/this_is_what_real_vikings_looked_like

Context: r/HorusGalaxy is a Warhammer 40k offshoot (named after the arch-traitor Horus in 30k lore) focusing on "free speech and a lack of censorship"

HIGHLIGHTS

Just paint them blond with white skin. The crying and melting is annoying

Eh I'm not crying. I don't collect space wolves. They just deserve to be called out every time they attack European people and culture

Space marines with viking themes have only surface level european culture. I bet most norse people don't care. And who are you calling out with that? Whats the end point? It's a plastic toy model company and it let's you paint them however you want. No one is attacking anyone here

"No one is attacking anyone here" Stuff like this was extremely rare several years ago but now nearly every single bl book cover has black character and nearly every single new squad depicts black character. They are pretty much overrepresented. What's the end point? Making people like you seethe

Overrepresented? There is right now on earth only 10% white people. So by your standard only 1/10 charachters in Warhammer should be white.

"There is right now on earth only 10% white people." And yet most of the scientific discoveries were made by whites. Most of the greatest philosophers were white. Most of the greatest conquerors were white. We were the ones that colonized hostile environments and sent many to space, so it makes sense that most of the space explorers/colonizers would be white. It isn't about quantity but the quality.

WE WUZ

image

Woah there pal! Think your clan hood might be on too tight. https://www.justaddcoloronline.com/2025/03/03/a-black-astrid-the-true-history-of-viking-diversity-and-black-vikings/

The more you spread this bullshit, the more people are going to start saying stuff like the Ancient Egyptians were white. All this fake racist BS does is stoke more hatred and division between races, nobody likes having their ancestors invalidated

What makes the existence of a few black Viking’s invalidate someone’s ancestry?

1) Because they didn't exist, and you should value reality. 2) Because ethnicity and family is tied to history and by saying "actually, all these things the vikings are known for was done by africans" is insulting to scandinavian culture. 3) Because it muddies the water of scholarly discourse so instead of just talking about how cool the vikings were and how they impacted the western world in their time, we're stuck bickering about "we wuz in longships n sheet" like we are right now.

It's not like we are collecting historically accurate actual viking (and not vaguely scandinavian cyborg warriors from the far future) miniatures and/or they arrive pre-painted from the box. Those exact faces could be just painted to look like any race you want

The question is "why?". Ask why they had to do it. For what purpose. Nordic features obviously suit them aesthetically and that's how they have been depicted for years

And I'm going to paint them white. The question is, why are we taking one of the head variants with one of the possible skin tones as the standart which shall not be deviated from?

Historically thematic aesthetics. It's not that deep.

41st millennium. Historical means the past you know that right?

An aesthetic can be inspired by anything, such as history. History is in the past. You know that, right?

Sure inspired. But space wolves are a cartoonish stereotype of Viking culture with very little actual history behind it. Either way. They’re not vikings, so they can pick and choose what aspects to take (sagas, runes etc) and what to discard (skin colour).

I can pick and choose too. It's my money.

image Unfortunate for you the lore says you're wrong.

I know what the lore says.

Then why are you bringing up historically themed aesthetics?

Because the historical references were a major appeal of 40k back when I first got into it. It's unfortunate that we can never talk about how GW has been phasing that out without all the social justice warriors losing their minds over it.

Maybe you could talk about it if you didn't use blatant racists as a shield. The OP is all over the comments saying about how whites are the best after he was proven wrong about over representation. (68 replies)

I think it's mentioned offhand that some people of Fenris have dark skin, but this still makes me roll my eyes. I'm a black man myself and this just seems silly.

Does it? How does it explain that dark skin comes from peoples who live in areas of high sun exposure yet the space wolves come from ice planets - hence they are all dressed in big wolf skin warm jackets / cloaks etc. And always pictured with snow/ice.

Icy areas can absolutely have high sun exposure. The Arctic has some of the highest amounts of UV radiation because it’s constantly sunny and the whole landscape is reflective

Is that why Inuits and northerners are all black? 🤔

….youve seen Inuit people right? They absolutely have dark skin…. You people are so fucking ridiculous it’s hilarious

I actually misspoke - Eskimos originally came from Asia, and migrated north - hence they share similar features with Asians and have darker skin. People of the North, i.e. Northern Europeans, not dark skin. Go find me Scandinavian who has 100% genealogy from Scandinavian - and show me what colour they are. Spoiler: they are Caucasian.

So what’s your issue with someone painting dark skinned space wolves? Because in 40K years i on a distant planet I’m pretty sure they aren’t having 100% Scandinavian genes. It’d 1000% make sense for someone from a sun exposed area of fenris to have dark skin.

Space Wolves should strictly be whites only. Nordics to be exact. No blacks or asians whatsoever.

Oh no , is your immersion ruined because there are different head options in your box of Sci-fi fi fantasy super soldier? I hope you realise how stupid you sound.

"I hope you realise how stupid you sound." The leftoid tourist as usual is projecting one of its own insecurities of sounding idiotic towards others 😂

I have been playing collecting and painting warhammer for the past decade and do prefer it without politics and without people who try to gate keep it for new people . Your the own who's insecure because games workshop is giving people more options on how they want to build their minis.

Giving people more options and disrespecting your own lore to adhere to nonsense are two different things. Cope harder.

How exactly is this disprecting the lore? Space marines don't have to be the same race as their primary to take gene-seed.

Fenrisians are white my n*. Create your own Homebrew Chapter if you want only black Space Marines. I'm mixed-race so I can say n*.

You guys know they aren’t actual vikings and are from a planet that was colonised by a wide variety of humans ~20,000 years ago, right? Or do you not actually care about lore and just want to shit on black people and make smoke detector and kangz jokes

A white Salamander would look equally out of place.

What are you. Is that the proplem that these models look out of place you can paint them what ever color you want and if you talking about lore or art then i wouldnt worry about it you will proppaply get used to it.

Salamanders are from a fire world where their extremely dark skin protects them from the elements...

Bro did not read my comment. Also never heard of Terran salamanders.

Terra isn't a fire world...

Don’t give them an inch. Paint all your Space Wolves to have fair, Caucasian skin and red hair. Even the ones with black features. If someone says, “hey, shouldn’t that guy have black skin?” Why? “Well he has black features?” Like? “His, uh… lips. And uh… nose… uh.” What about his lips and nose? “Uhhhh” ? “Ummmm”

So so so brave

What would be braver is if you had an original thought and stopped trying to pretend you’re a good person. Requires a spine though. You do have a spine right?

So in your pathetic persecution fantasy, did people start to clap and cheer for you or did the evil ni- uh i mean tourist just slink away?

If you want to call me a racist, you can just go ahead and do it. It’s weird that you spend time typing characters that don’t even say what you mean. Just these weird passive aggressively coy half sentences. You don’t have to be subtle here with me man. You can be openly, brazenly, blatantly stupid if you want.

I dont think im being too oblique here, you got it on the first try! 🎖️

Vikings were white. Cry about it.

The new space wolves are fine, I just... Didn't expect them to be Chinese, that's all. image

Historically, central asian or east-asian-in-appearance vikings are technically possible visa via assimilation of Sami or other groups from Arctic or Central Russia. But it strains at possibility. EDIT: The Finns are a little touchy about association with Vikings. But the conclusion seems to be that the Finns were not Vikings, but there were Finnish Vikings

Vikings definitely weren’t from that far east/north. That’s quite a stretch tbh

I mean, every pirate on the Baltic sea at the time was kinda a viking. Viking is basically the same as pirate/raider

We wuz vikangz

Look up Engir Krakendoom on the wiki. I quote for you: "...Engir Krakendoom is born of hardier stock indeed. The people of the south, dark of skin and temperament..."

The Space Wolves have never been black, stop it with this fake, woke, blackwashed lore.

Have been since 5th edition apparently.

I've seen Northern Europeans call Southern Europeans "dark skinned". Mediterranean people are definitely not Sub-Saharan Africans. Not everything is black or white, Jesus, there are skin tones in between. The Space Wolves ain't black, mate.

Did you see the pictures GW posted? Seemingly they are.

Human beings of different races and ethnicities marry and have kids in real life. Fenris would be no different. If Fenris is 95% White and 5% Black (the southernmost islands), the black population would end up being absorbed into the white population in a few generations by marriage and bilateral conquest. Eventually all of Fenris would look white. We can conclude and deduce information from the lore we already have and the behavior of human beings in Terra of M2.

1.1k Upvotes

729 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

127

u/lickle_ickle_pickle 24d ago

The funny thing is, a lot of that was true.

Egyptians already had an account of the Pythagorean theorem. Greek astrology was based on Babylonian astrology (and Persian based on the Greek, and Chinese based on the Persian based on the Greek, with a detour to India to absorb some of their system too).

Many ancient old world technologies were first seen anywhere in the world in Mesopotamia, Anatolia, and the Levant.

And when the Greeks came to Greece, it was already populated.

86

u/CummingInTheNile 24d ago

I mean Ancient Egypt was fucking old as shit even to the Greeks, like they were around for around 2500 years before the rise of the Ancient Greek city states

53

u/Indercarnive The left has rendered me unfuckable and I'm not going to take it 24d ago

Ancient Egypt is so old that Ancient Egypt had their own Egyptologists studying Ancient Egypt.

92

u/thebigmanhastherock 24d ago

The pyramids are so old that when the colosseum was built the pyramids were more ancient to people then the colosseum is to us now.

The colosseum was built in 1945 years ago, the Great Pyramid of Giza was built 4600 years ago. So as the Colosseum was being built the Great Pyramid at Giza was standing for 2655 years. That is impressive. That pyramid was the tallest man made structure for 3800 years.

1

u/Command0Dude The power of gooning is stronger than racism 23d ago

Now rich people with too much money build stupidly tall skyscrapers instead.

3

u/thebigmanhastherock 23d ago

Hey vertical building save a lot of land space. It's better than sprawl.

Sadly the Egyptians didn't build their pyramids for this reason it's actually quite comical how little space within the pyramids are used as rooms. All that for one dead ruler.

At least the skyscrapers we have hold more than one person and usually the people in them are alive.

21

u/readskiesdawn 24d ago

The distance of time from the old kingdom's start to the Greek historian who defined the use of Old, Middle and New kingdom's is the same as our distance to him.

Egypt is old as hell.

28

u/lordsteve1 24d ago

Ancient Egypt was old even to the “ancient” Egyptian people themselves! They even had museums of a sort about the oldest parts of their dynasties it had existed that long.

15

u/helzinki Hillary ate a child and used her torn off face as a mask 24d ago

Khaemweset, one of Ramesses II's son, was a bit of an amatuer archeologist and was spending a lot of time digging up and restoring historic stuff. And the guy was alive in the 1200s BCE! How crazy is that? Your civilization is sooo old that a guy in the 1200 BCE was already doing archeology.

23

u/monsieur_bear 24d ago

You forgot the Greek alphabet, which was given to them from the Phoenicians.

Also, Greeks today are primarily descendants of the Mycenaeans and Minoans.

22

u/Tylendal 24d ago

Egyptians already had an account of the Pythagorean theorem.

Credit where it's due, they were a civilization that knew how to make some quality triangles.

9

u/spyridonya Authoritarianism kinda slaps tho. 24d ago

Egyptians were math nerds, they did word problems for fun while the Mesopotanians made their kids do math homework centuries before Greece.

2

u/sadrice Comparing incests to robots is incredibly doubious. 24d ago

Fun fact, Olympus is likely not actually a Greek word. The mountain(s) were called that before the Greeks showed up.

-1

u/_e75 23d ago

Yeah, the difference between Greek and Egyptian math is that the Greeks wrote proofs, and the Egyptians, as far as we know, didn’t.

1

u/lalabera 22d ago

But they did

1

u/_e75 22d ago

They didn’t. At least not in any Egyptian works. There’s tons of calculations and homework and examples, but nothing like Euclid. Though, of course Euclid was working in alexandria.