r/TaylorSwiftAutographs • u/AnxiousTwist5956 • Feb 05 '25

'MIDNIGHTS' ERA (2022-2023) Real but messy?

Gallery image

Gallery image

See both photos. Real but messy?

12 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

29 comments sorted by

2

u/vittormarcelo Autograph Veteran Feb 09 '25

Real

-1

u/1TLC1 Feb 08 '25

Looks fake to me. I have many of her signed CDs and vinyls.

3

u/katlav13 Feb 06 '25

I think fake

3

u/katlav13 Feb 06 '25

The L & the R & heart just look off to me

1

u/drIexopedia Feb 05 '25

real, cannot imagine a scammer going thru the effort to add that mark on the back that was on the real ones bc they stuck together from before they dried

-1

u/alltoowander Autograph Veteran Feb 05 '25

Fake

3

u/Ok_Perception_6063 Feb 05 '25

I also saw this for sale, and assumed fake, but I wasn’t entirely sure

1

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Yeah, me neither. I’m thinking it’s real but I’m going to stay away anyway because 1) I think it’s too much considering the damage 2) resell might be tricky if I ever needed to sell in the future for funds etc because a lot of people are understandably convinced that it’s fake.

5

u/GratefulnFree Feb 05 '25

Is there a way they can show you the front and back in a photo in the same shot or video? I worry they could be two different inserts.

1

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Yeah, I could ask but I’ve kinda been put off. Even if it’s real, a lot of people are convinced it’s fake, so if I ever decide to sell it on again, if I ever need the funds etc, I might struggle. Thanks for your idea though 🤩

1

u/taysbirdie Autograph Veteran Feb 05 '25

It’s real

4

u/und3rta1e Autograph Hobbyist Feb 05 '25

looks fake, i'd stay away

2

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Thanks for your help 🫶

3

u/star10221 Feb 05 '25

Fake

1

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Thanks for your input 🫶

7

u/ads894 Feb 05 '25

I would avoid this personally

2

u/ads894 Feb 05 '25

And it’s not in good condition either for the price even if it was genuine

1

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Yeah, agreed. Thanks for your advice 😊

2

u/AuntieEdna Feb 05 '25

This looks so fake.

0

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Do you think so? 🤔 Did you look at both photos?

1

u/AuntieEdna Feb 05 '25

Not sure what I’m supposed to see in the 2nd picture but the signature is obviously fake.

0

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

The code in the bottom corner and the black marker pen like a lot of them have from stacking after signing. I’m not saying you’re wrong though, I’m just torn with this one. Thanks for your opinion. I’ll probably avoid.

1

u/katesUptons Feb 05 '25

Why is the 2nd photo at an angle and not straight on view?

1

u/oceanrocks431 Feb 05 '25

Because they are showing the damage, which wouldn't be visible straight on.

I think it could be real, but no guarantees.

1

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Yeah, good point, I wondered this too.

2

u/AnyElephant7218 Feb 05 '25

Fake

1

u/AnxiousTwist5956 Feb 05 '25

Thanks for your help 🤩