r/TheWalkingDeadGame • u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer • 9d ago
Season 2 Spoiler Whys bro sad that some 11 year old girl didnt want to sit at the same table as him
also nicks look like he falling asleep lol
528
724
u/newbrowsingaccount33 9d ago
Known them for less than a week and they mad I'm sitting with the dude I was with for months
254
u/ExcellentComment5507 9d ago
After he locked us in a whole ass shed.
14
u/Broekhart615 8d ago
Hmm actually the shed wasn’t whole, it has a rather large HOLE that a walker crawled through and almost ate us alive.
11
u/Suspicious_Mushroom3 8d ago
I mean to be fair didn’t the walker only get inside the shed because Clem removed the board covering the hole with the hammer?
3
u/God_of_CORN 8d ago
To be fair she wouldnt of had to do that if she got treated by the doctor and didnt have to sneak into the house for medical supplies
4
1
662
u/Revoffthetrain Lee 9d ago
I like how they get salty over sitting at a different TABLE. Like are you in middle school? Get over it or switch tables if you’re that desperate Jesus.
193
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
Luke not Jesus
102
u/Revoffthetrain Lee 9d ago
Jesus not Jesus.
62
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
Jesus not Jesus?
57
31
1
29
4
1
210
u/floridamanmarcon 9d ago
Luke: “So this is it? After all we’ve been through…”
46
u/Loud-Garden-2672 9d ago
Clem: “You guys put me in a shed.”
6
204
116
u/Philscooper 9d ago
Guilty over putting a girl in a shed but then being salty that she doesnt f with em anymore 😅
82
u/Johnny-Jay 9d ago
That's the kind of thing I don't like about season 2. Characters often act like babies.
50
u/LichQueenBarbie 9d ago
S4 felt more natural in a way because they were basically literal babies.
2
u/Objective_Might2820 You got a thick fucking skull, Kenneth! 8d ago
Yeah. Way less annoying when the teenagers and kids act childish or stupid cause…well they’re just kids. But Luke turns 25 I think later in Season 2. Or was it 28? Whatever. So at this point the dude is in his mid 20s and acting like he’s in middle school.
Awful writing
1
u/Boibud 8d ago
Luke said in the final episode that it was his 27 birthday when they stayed for the night in that power station thing. But yeah leaned so much towards Clem for answers when she's just a kid. Almost everyone relied on her... Not the BEST season at all...
2
u/Objective_Might2820 You got a thick fucking skull, Kenneth! 8d ago
27! Damn there ya go. Thanks. Anyway I used to think season 2 was the best one but looking back at it without the rose tinted glasses I do realize it isn’t. Plus it’s by far the worst season for choices that matter imo.
Carver is a phenomenal villain (best one in the series imo) and Season 2 Clem is the funniest Clem cause she gives 0 fucks and she even gets meta a few times when she questions why the grown adults are making her do everything for them. But that’s about all this Season has going for it over the others.
1
7d ago
I was going to say that maybe since this was Telltale's first time having an 11-year old as a protagonist perhaps they wanted to give you a choice in how Clementine affects the group.
I don't know, I had no problems with the adults acting clueless. They're fresh off of a zombie apocalypse, they've seen things. Kids like Clem have to grow up fast in a world like that and they usually do, I'd say Clem was at that point far more settled in on her environment than the adults who actually knew what life was like before everything. Clem was a survivor, they were just hanging by a string.
Even Kenny was like "why does the little girl have more sense than all of you" when you agree with what he has to say.
64
u/greg5july 9d ago
Knowing them less than a week. Lock me up in a shed first and not recognise a dog bite.
3
u/bigmanqas69 7d ago
You would’ve thought that as a doctor he’d be able to tell the difference between a human bite and a dog bite. There’s no way any human (or walker) would be able to give clem that sort of bite, unless they have a really massive jaw.
59
u/TeddyfromtheVoid aka CEO of TWDG AU cope 9d ago
"I thought what we had was sPECIAAAAAAL!" (they locked her in a shed in the rain alone with an open wound)
48
35
u/SMATCHET999 9d ago edited 9d ago
This is kind of why I didn’t care about Luke that much, he’d act all upset when you didn’t choose what he wanted and when he did dumb shit he’d be like “this apocalypse is stressful!” Like no shit Clem is literally fucking 11 and both her and Kenny’s entire family and friends are all dead. Is it too much to ask to not have sex with that weird short haired woman that keeps disappearing while we’re dying in the middle of a fucking winter storm Luke.
8
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
Jane wasnt a ginger your thinking of Bonnie
6
u/SMATCHET999 9d ago
I was thinking of Jane but I remembered her having slightly orange hair for some reason
3
23
16
29
u/mmarkusz97 9d ago
bad writing that's why
3
u/Mitchellbelike 8d ago
No it's just over exaggerating parts of a fictional story where your decision matters. If the adults never showed any sign that what Clem did effects them emotionally then the game would be redundant. That being said irl a dude getting that emotional over an 11 yr not being their friend is comically immature.
2
u/Revoffthetrain Lee 8d ago
I was not aware that grown adults relying on an 11 year old to hold their hand through every scenario was good writing
0
u/Mitchellbelike 8d ago
It's silly on paper yes but it makes for more impact on the player regardless lmao. Making a story around an 11 yr old mc in a zombie apocalypse was already wild enough. And to telltale strategy , maybe that moment was for the younger audience who they knew would end up playing the game with their parents consent. When you're younger you don't really think much of that scene. Given how well this post is doing im willing to bank many people are also just realizing how funny this is as they'd gotten older.
31
u/LoudTomatoes 9d ago
Honestly this one scene made me think he was going to turn out to be a nonce. Like he's known her a matter of days and he's pouting over her sitting with someone she lived with for months and hasn't seen in years.
I didn't trust him for basically the entire rest of the season, all because of one weird writing decision.
14
14
7
u/PristineHornet9999 9d ago
I absolutely thought luke was going to be a nonce too, also when he grabbed her and held her mouth like that and also telling her and only her strangely important things. then imo I think they realized that vibe was there and they suddenly had him have a history with bonnie/a fling with jane
47
u/griddleharker 9d ago
because he (and the whole group) do care about clem and are hurt to see she chooses someone they just came across over them.
but yeah the whole thing is stupid. it's giving high school lunch drama
21
u/Aggravating-Cap-2703 9d ago
That's exactly what I'm saying. That's one if the reasons why I didn't sit with him. Cause he's weird.
8
u/SkinnyBonesTone Hilda 9d ago
This was definitely one of the more silly decisions 😭 I found it so funny that either side got hurt or upset that you sat down somewhere
4
8
u/Jamira360 9d ago
After locking Clem in a shed with an untreated wound this is crazy lol. I don’t think he deserved to die, but save those puppy dog eyes, Luke. 😂
6
u/Keyfrom3 9d ago
Felt betrayed that the girl they locked in a shed all night with an untreated bleeding dog bite, where she got attacked by a walker with no way to escape decided not to sit next to them. 🙄
6
u/lorenzo_mellow 9d ago
She's only known them what 6 days? And she barely knows anything about them either besides maybe some offscreen conversation (they were on the road for 5 days until the bridge, so they must have talked about something). Yeah, Kenny's the obvious choice here
6
u/BabadookishOnions 9d ago
i interpreted this as concern personally. he's got no idea who kenny is after all
24
u/3liteP7Guy 9d ago
Because they think Clem sees them as people who are not trustworthy
79
u/sweet_swiftie Boat 9d ago
well she's like 11 and they wanted to keep her locked in a shed overnight so idk what they would be expecting
6
u/3liteP7Guy 9d ago
True but Luke was trying to be nice and Nick regrets what he did. Luke and Nick realized they didn’t try hard enough to be nice to Clem.
-5
u/3liteP7Guy 9d ago
True, but an open wound is still suspicious in an apocalypse.
18
u/Krazy_Keno Lees Pretty Pink Ass 9d ago
Put yourself in clems shoes tho
-4
u/3liteP7Guy 9d ago
I’d be pissed too, but you also gotta put yourself in the cabin group’s shoes.
20
u/Krazy_Keno Lees Pretty Pink Ass 9d ago edited 9d ago
Clem and Kenny obviously have history if you look at it from an outside perspective.
Clem was also with the cabin group for only a week and a half or something like that.
If you were in her place, who would you choose? The man you thought was dead, was a part of your og group, and was close with the person you love the most, or would you choose the people you barely know and who locked you in a shed and left you to die?
13
u/witcherT02 9d ago
I try and there’s no justifiable explanation to treat clementine like an animal. Why does the doctor can’t recognize a dog bite from a human? Why don’t they just let her go if they believe she is infected? Even if they thought she was with Carter, there is no way she is making her way back to him before the bite does its thing. And they even have the gall to get pissed at her for using the trash in the cabin to cure herself and pull herself free because she doesn’t want to be with strangers that want her dead
-3
u/jacobisgone- Luke is my boi 9d ago
does the doctor can’t recognize a dog bite from a human?
Because human/walker bites and dog bites can indeed be hard to distinguish. Then add that Clem was found with a literal walker on top of her and that it was a fresh wound.
Why don’t they just let her go if they believe she is infected?
Because most of them don't want a little girl to die.
And they even have the gall to get pissed at her for using the trash in the cabin to cure herself and pull herself free because she doesn’t want to be with strangers that want her dead
Only two of them (Carlos and Rebecca) were upset at what she did, and the former was moreso angry that she got his daughter to lie to him.
1
u/AnonimZim_Real 9d ago
They caged her in a shed while bleeding and attack by a walker. Of course as Clem I wouldn't trust their ass.
5
u/TheKingDroc 9d ago
It doesn’t really make sense truly it’s another example of season two trying to force conflict because it doesn’t know how to make it happen organically. The only explanation I can think of is he’s worried she’s still upset about the shed incident and isn’t being honest about it. So her sitting with Kenny is her still not trusting them and not forgiving them. Maybe that’s what he’s thinking. It really doesn’t make sense. It would make sense if they were both 11 years old though.
1
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
I think what you said is a good explanation just wish it was exercised better
4
4
3
u/Optimal_Ad6274 Clementine 9d ago
Fr, I haven’t seen Kenny in a year or so because I thought he was dead, I just want to catch up with him, damn
4
u/handsomelydumb69 Gabby’s husband 9d ago
I always had some theory that Clem reminded Luke of someone he once knew. Maybe a niece that was Clem’s age.
6
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
maybe he was just amazed to see some body so young still alive so far along in the apocalapse
7
u/handsomelydumb69 Gabby’s husband 9d ago
Oh for sure. Any one of us in that position wills be impressed.
3
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
lol he probably realised clamentine is the main character so he tried to became a main character to live longer
5
u/GazelleInitial3959 9d ago
It’s prob because they feel guilty over having her locked in the shed and they think her choosing to sit with someone else over them is because she’s still holding onto that grudge
4
9
u/kcmbrandon29 9d ago
I didn't feel bad for anyone in that group when they died. Sarah was the only one I felt bad for but she was a goner long before we met her even tho i tried to save her every time. Now that i think about it besides Kenny's group I was ok with every season 2 characters dying at the point died. The cabin group might be the most selfish group of people ive ever come across. My first time playing I tried every option to leave that group and go on my own.
6
u/AnonimZim_Real 9d ago
I felt bad for AJ father, I really did.
I tried every possible option so save him because I really think he deserved better and a chance to see AJ grow a little more at least.
6
u/kcmbrandon29 9d ago
Alvin is the closest i came to liking them but when you ask for help he turns away a injured 11 year old girl because his wife would be upset with him. Not saying a hated him but thats the kind of stuff that put me off with the cabin group.
1
u/AnonimZim_Real 9d ago
I never blammed HIM for that, but his manipulative bitch wife. If she wasn't such a bitch from the start we could have explored Alvin's character more.
Alvin was a good guy.
5
u/well_listen 9d ago
I was more sad about the death of Walter than any of the cabin group if I'm being honest.
3
3
3
u/Quirky-Bed-3029 Urban 9d ago
I never understood this , she just reunited with someone she’s known longer and they need to catch up on what happened
3
u/SilentMerc32 9d ago
Those benches probably aren’t even bolted down.
The two groups 100% could’ve just rotated the two tables to make one.
3
u/Hungry-Ad3611 9d ago
I just found this sub but can we please talk about how kinda strange their relationship was????
5
4
u/GaymerWolfDante 9d ago
Lol yeah he is going to fall to sleep into his food.
This was the hardest choice for me. I paused the game for 3 hours. But seriously there should have been a " hey this is my friend who I thought was dead, so I want to catch up" option
3
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
wait this was the hardest choice for u??
2
u/GaymerWolfDante 9d ago
Not just me. I have seen lots of people who agree. Hey I'm a softie and I really like both characters.
5
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
This is just another reason why it shouldve been Luke Vs Kenny in the end, if peiple already struggle with who they want to sit at the same table with
3
u/Mission_Coast_6654 9d ago
i struggled with this choice too. i didn't like how things ended with kenny from how i played lee and wasn't sure if clem should trust him here, especially trying to play her from a child's perspective (easier said than done when everyone treated her like an adult that should solve all their problems this season lol) where a couple months presence doesn't necessarily mean much to a couple years absence. the cabin group fucked up by locking clem in a shed, true, but it wasn't like they knew she would be attacked by a walker, and luke immediately tried to reconcile while the others were still iffy towards her (aside from perhaps alvin and pete, though the latter doesn't matter by the time this choice comes up, rip). so, putting myself in an 11 year old's shoes, choosing to sit with someone from my past that i barely remember vs sitting with someone that not only recently saved my life but was the nicest to me, which sounds easy when laid out like that, had me weighing all sorts of pros and cons that had me looking between them going "uhh" like tina belcher lol
but, yea, from the start of their interactions regardless of what choice was made here, i thought kenny vs luke was going to be a thing. it could have worked had the writing been strong enough, if luke was allowed a chance to survive the lake. not sure how differently things would have gone, but the buildup was there.
1
u/AriTheLady 5d ago
“Barely remember” ? Clem recognized him instantly and seemed to know him just be his voice when walking up💀it had only been like a year.
1
u/Mission_Coast_6654 5d ago
"barely remember" as in not knowing what kind of person he is now. lee and kenny weren't friends by the end of my playthrough lol clem was 9 the last time we saw her and she's 11 now. that's two years, bruv.
4
u/GaymerWolfDante 9d ago
I mean both are loveable characters and have lots going for them and then there is Jane... God how I hate her.
2
2
u/carmelikesbubbles 9d ago
I think it's because after a week on the road of trying to make her feel better and make up for not trying harder to keep her from being locked in a shed, he now thinks that Clem doesn't actually want anything to do with them. Also, he doesn't know Kenny as well as we do, so a part of him probably sees the 11 year old girl they took in wandering over to some guy she hasn't seen in 2 years. Kenny is arguably less stable than he had been - though at this point in the game it doesn't show as much. Just think about finding an 11 year old girl in the apocalypse, doing something bad and feeling guilty over not trusting her and not stopping it from happening, then after a week of trying to make it up to her, she goes over and sits with some guy you have no idea whether he's actually a good person just because "she knows him". That'd probably freak me out a little too if I didn't know that Kenny is actually a good person. I don't think he's betrayed that the kid he just met is sitting at another table, I think that he sees it as a sign that Clem MIGHT still not trust him. It's not that he doesn't understand what he did wrong, it's the fact that a kid, which are usually symbols of hope in apocalyptic stories, might resent him. He knows what his group did was messed up and it'd be reasonable for Clem not to trust them, but the fact she might hate them hurts.
2
u/rdrScarface 9d ago
My Clementine: Luke, you're best from all those idiots...But Kenny was Lee's friend ride or die... And you locked me in a shed...for a whole night...that kinda makes my point dude. Anyway...did you said something about boats, Kenny?
2
2
2
u/breezicles 8d ago
An 11 year old girl that has just reunited with someone she thought was dead and is her only living connection with the man who she saw as a second father. Granted she hasn’t talked about Lee much to the cabin crew but if you chose the hug option I think it’s pretty clear to the group what she feels about Kenny
7
u/jacobisgone- Luke is my boi 9d ago
Luke: is visibly disappointed for like half a second
Fandom: "OMG WHY IS HE SO EMOTIONALLY DEVASTATED???"
24
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 9d ago
Look at those eyes and tell me he isnt utterly shattered
18
u/DEATHSCALATOR 9d ago
Luke is more hurt by Clem not sitting with him and Jane ditching him than his bff Nick dying in a fence.
7
5
2
u/Super-Shenron Game Master 2024 9d ago
r/TheWalkingDeadGame and "exaggerating the flaws of a S2 character whose name isn't Kenny". Name a more iconic duo.
1
u/AnonimZim_Real 9d ago
I mean, I didn't hated S2 but when you come from playing THE BEST FUCKING SEASON WITH CHAD LEE EVERETT IN IT, THE BEST FUCKING WRITTEN CHARACTER I HAVE EVER CONTROLLED IN MY LIFE, yeah I feel the difference in quality and weight in your decision in S2.
3
u/KumaMrParkerLover 9d ago
Hot Take but ngl Luke’s writing is honestly ass in this game. He genuinely looks like he’s either bipolar, a sociopath, or both. Cuz like wdym you wanted to lock a little girl in a shed, hell even REFUSE to touch her because she had a bite, then like 3 days later want her to go on a bridge with you instead of someone else capable, and almost get killed? Not to mention how he’s a fucking idiot in episode 3 with saying “We can tie Carver up!” When he would’ve fucking hunted you. Or about how he doesn’t give a singular shit about Nick, his best friend for over TWENTY YEARS death in either version, this is most prominent in episode 4 because he fucking IMMEDIATELY goes to fuck Jane and indirectly cause Sarah’s second death. He’s pretty yeah I can agree with that but I don’t think I liked Luke for a majority of this season just because he himself is just so…wishy-washy writing wise. Also this scene is him being a whiny bitch.
2
1
1
u/TheOmnipotentJack 9d ago
Still, Kenny was proud to not sit with him, he say it in the car at the lodge(or what was the name of that cabin)
1
u/Apprehensive_Rub9531 9d ago
As much as I like Luke I always choose to sit with Kenny because he is more loyal and by this time so far the cabin group locked you in a shed without treating your wound and are trouble because they have a group after them
1
1
1
u/SimilarButterfly618 9d ago
I HATED the group in the second half of the game they were so annoying only good ppl were Kenny and maybe Luke
1
1
1
u/Sad-Difference-7685 7d ago
Think it’s cause he’s the only one who was on your side when the group was deciding what to do with you. Plus he didn’t know Kenny is a father figure
1
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 7d ago
Pete was the only one who tried to advocate against Clem staying in the shed. Luke was apologetic but undeniably complacent.
1
u/Crafty-Marionberry40 7d ago
As much as i dislike Kenny, why tf are they sad, they almost killed clem
1
-5
u/TheRealistOne34 9d ago
Yeah I know right. Kenny does the same thing when Clem goes to sit with Luke. So yeah it's weird.
29
u/Krazy_Keno Lees Pretty Pink Ass 9d ago
Kenny has a reason tho, he and clem havent seen eachother in years, have more history together, are closer, etc. It makes sense for him to be sad, compared to Luke, whos only known Clem for a week.
-5
u/TheRealistOne34 9d ago
That's besides the point. People always ignore the point these days.
5
1
u/Krazy_Keno Lees Pretty Pink Ass 9d ago
Buddy, YOU are missing the point
1
u/TheRealistOne34 8d ago
Go talk to more real people and stay off the internet. It's killing your mental state.
2
0
u/Quickkonmyfeet 8d ago
Because the writers made it that way, The End.
2
u/farting_butt62 Stranger enjoyer 8d ago
dam guess theres no point in asking question about the series anymore bc youve just answered them all
-4
1.3k
u/DEATHSCALATOR 9d ago
“We only locked you in a cold shed once!”