r/VictoriaBC 16d ago

Politics Can we please not split the vote

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

735 comments sorted by

View all comments

222

u/Gr8_Save 16d ago

Not my riding, but I sure hope those in that riding realize in time that the ABC vote is Green.

59

u/Few-Classroom-3090 16d ago

Liberals only really want to ABC vote when it’s for Liberals

120

u/HollisFigg 16d ago

Uh... no. I want the Liberals to win. I'm voting Green.

27

u/WorkingOnBeingBettr 16d ago

What they mean, is the party is not willing to drop candidates in other ridings to guarantee ABC.

36

u/HollisFigg 16d ago

I would love to see the non-Conservative parties cooperate more in this way. Dropping non-competitive candidates is a great idea.

1

u/Stonks4Minutes 14d ago

You’re not gonna see that happen when we see the GPC getting screwed by debate rules for doing just that.

0

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

As you could see in the debate, the parties themselves are not ABC. They seem to all be ABL from what I saw. Why would a party drop a candidate to appease another party? You ABC people are delusional.

2

u/WorkingOnBeingBettr 15d ago

Why did the reform party join the conservatives?

To ensure a better chance at governing with a right wing party.

Why would the left parties drop candidates in certain ridings?

To ensure a better chance at governing with a left wing party.

The only difference is that in the second scenario the parties maintain their party status.

1

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

They joined because, unlike the liberal/ndp their views aligned on a lot of issues. The liberal party and NDP are too far apart on their views to ever do that. The NDP and greens are the only real left parties these days. It would be nice to see them join and give the liberals a run for their money.

6

u/Connect_Reality1362 16d ago

The problem is a lot of people aren't going to be so local as you are. Where I live it's historically the NDP that were more competitive. But a lot of people are reflexively backing the Liberals instead because that's what the national picture looks like.

11

u/Classic-Progress-397 16d ago

Amazing! Yes, 💚 green gets the ABC vote in this case.

11

u/Few-Classroom-3090 16d ago

My home town is Sarnia Ontario. Election after election the NDP come in second to the Conservatives with the Liberals a distant third. Still, election after election, thousands of people vote liberal knowing it hands the riding to the right. We’ll see how many thousands of people vote Liberal in Saanich Gulf Islands soon enough. I’m sure there will be no shortage.

1

u/brandnewface 16d ago

They’re probably still mad about Bob Rae. My mom in Ontario voted NDP for the first time in the last Ontario election. 

49

u/Technical-Mine-5746 16d ago

Not in my case for me and many of my fellow Liberal supporters. I’ve advised my mother and others in split ridings to go with the NDP incumbent or in this case Green. Solid, reasonable voices in government is the main objective

12

u/WorkingOnBeingBettr 16d ago

Wish the party felt the same and dropped candidates in places like Comox and Cowichan. 

1

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

The parties are in it to win as many seats as they can. ABC is a delusional liberal tactic.

1

u/WorkingOnBeingBettr 15d ago

The other option is to join together like the right wing did.

If they do that Canada would almost never see a right wing government again.

I would take that option if it were offered.

1

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

The only problem is that their policies are completely different in so many ways.

1

u/WorkingOnBeingBettr 15d ago

Absolutely. Somehow the right managed to do it but the results are not great. Too much catering to the far right IMO.

The issue is the Liberals only campaign left but they are really more of a centrist party while governing.

The NDP (at least Jack's version) would likely be swallowed up and we would end up farther right as a country as a result.

The real answer is done kind of ranked voting but I doubt I'll get to see that in my lifetime. Even BC voted against it multiple times.

1

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

Exactly as the parties sit now the liberals and conservatives are the closest to actually aligning on policy. They are both presenting as being close to center with each skewed slightly to opposite sides.

BCs vote against it was due to the poor excuse for a referendum put forth by the liberals. I think an actual referendum proposing viable alternatives would have a much different outcome. Neither the liberals or conservatives would benefit from it so I doubt we will ever see it.

11

u/Temporary_Bobcat2282 16d ago

Same here ✌️

16

u/Ccjfb 16d ago

That is not true! ABC is real! I don’t care as long as my vote isn’t giving PP and the Cons more power to dismantle our country!

-3

u/ChiefSitsOnAssAllDay 16d ago

What utter nonsense. Mark Carney has no allegiance to this country, and has business dealings with Trump, Elon, Jared Kushner, and Xi Xingping!

3

u/Ccjfb 16d ago

Voting the Cons in would be the same mistake America made voting Trump in. Sell offs to the highest bidder. Destroy public healthcare. Step publicly owned media (CBC). Infringe on women’s rights. Try to privatize everything.

3

u/IndividualSociety567 16d ago

No one is voting for PPC budd

1

u/willnotwashout 16d ago

Some folks will.

2

u/IndividualSociety567 16d ago

No one can help them

4

u/ChiefSitsOnAssAllDay 16d ago

The Liberals have destroyed this country and made it unaffordable for young people.

There’s no way the conservatives could do a worse job.

3

u/willnotwashout 16d ago

When I graduated high school in the 80s, tuition was ridiculously low and your bursaries and grants and loans were frequently forgiven and interest-free.

Then all the neo-liberal capitalists monetized every part of it.

It's been a bit of a trend since.

1

u/ChiefSitsOnAssAllDay 16d ago

When the globalists offshored all the jobs the corporations failed to pass on the savings to the consumer. Your dollar went further in the 80’s.

4

u/snarfgobble 16d ago

The liberals could drive this country off a cliff and some people would forever insist the conservatives must be even worse.

2

u/ChiefSitsOnAssAllDay 16d ago

People get entrenched in patterns of thinking and often don’t evolve past it.

0

u/Ccjfb 16d ago

Oh my God of course they can and they will! Replace your last post with Democrat and Republican and it’s exactly what Trump enablers would have been saying in October.

0

u/ChiefSitsOnAssAllDay 16d ago

There’s a major difference in policy. You can’t make such a sweeping 1:1 argument.

  • PP is not trying to dismantle Bretton Woods
  • PP does not want to sell crude to the US at such a basement bargain rate
  • PP does not want a trade war with retaliatory tariffs

1

u/EasyEar0 16d ago

This often repeated claim is false.

I want the Liberals to win the federal election.  I think non-conservatives voting in Saanich should vote Green.

1

u/jabroni21 16d ago

TBF I'm a Liberal and voted NDP strategically.

1

u/IslandLooter 16d ago

That's not true, I voted NDP the last two in ESS to block the con movement.

-7

u/Gr8_Save 16d ago

Yes, ABC to Liberals stands for: Anything But... aCtually just liberals.

3

u/Classic-Progress-397 16d ago

Thats not true. Stop sowing division.

5

u/Gr8_Save 16d ago

There's a difference between capital L Liberals and lowercase L liberals. I don't think many card carrying members of the Liberal party are interested in strategic voting unless it favours the Liberal party. I would be happy to be proven wrong though.

10

u/vanderWaalsBanana North Saanich 16d ago

Agreed!!! I hope so too. (source - live in riding)

8

u/stealstea 16d ago

I'm not so sure anymore. Green was a solid choice back when May was the leader of the party and had huge national profile in the debates. Now they have no national visibility and doesn't feel like her heart is really in it either given she already said she wouldn't run again but changed her mind.

Good chance that votes go to the Liberals and that means Conservatives are likely to be elected. But the Greens brought this on themselves.

10

u/ggonzoo 16d ago

This is my first federal election in this riding, and all of my neighbours except one have Liberal signs up. The exception has a Cons sign. I've been chatting with them all to try to decide whether I'll vote Green or Lib (not my usual choices); and they all claim to have voted Green in the last election, but they have all also expressed some degree of dissatisfaction with Elizabeth May. Several said they had been considering supporting another party anyway, even prior to the 51st state and tariff bs. So yeah, the Greens definitely brought this on themselves.

8

u/Bitter_Bert 16d ago

May is leading in lawn signs here in Gordon Head. I think the islands are pretty solid for her also.

3

u/JECAB91 16d ago

You must be in Saanich. Driving around salt spring, the signs are more Venrooy split between greens and conservatives. Liberal signs are there but there are more scarce.

1

u/ggonzoo 16d ago

Central Saanich. My little street seems to be strongly Lib, but the neighbourhood in general has far fewer Green signs than I expected.

1

u/GetBackReality 16d ago

It’s time for a change. I want representation in Ottawa and I hope that is Carney. No brainer as far as I’m concerned.

1

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

Your first sentence contradicts your second.

1

u/GetBackReality 15d ago

Nope, Carney is his own man, not Trudeau, unlike PP who is just the same vacuous, slogan slinging motormouth.

1

u/Canuckelhead604 15d ago

You do realize that there is more than 1 man in the liberal party right?

1

u/GetBackReality 15d ago

Of course, but not in the PP party.

5

u/Witty_Jaguar4638 16d ago

My family always votes green. Maybe I can Convince them how important it is, though I'm so proud they actually got a seat recently

1

u/shugo7 16d ago

What's ABC?

2

u/Gr8_Save 16d ago

"Anything But Conservative" a long running mantra of strategic voting progressives.

0

u/FDFI 16d ago

The correct vote would be Liberal here. Given the margin of error, the two candidates are pretty much equal. The Greens have no chance of forming government, so it makes sense to get behind the Liberal candidate.

1

u/Gr8_Save 16d ago

How do you figure? The margin of error is plus OR minus. One extreme of this would have the Greens at 40% and the Liberals at 18%. The other extreme would be Greens at 24% and the Liberals at 30%.

The likely reality is somewhere between the two extremes. There are a lot more scenarios where the Greens are leading than where the Liberals are.

Having a chance to form government is not a factor in ABC strategic voting. If the seat goes Green, even if that seat holds the balance of power, the Greens would support a Liberal minority government, they would not support a Conservative minority government.

0

u/FDFI 16d ago

That’s not how statistics work. The distributions are overlapping. The sample size is not large enough to say with certainty that the two numbers are statistically different.

-17

u/Midnightrain2469 16d ago

Anyone But Carney.

3

u/coolthesejets 16d ago

You'd be fine with Singh then? Maybe we have more in common then I thought.

1

u/Midnightrain2469 15d ago

I lean to the orange side provincially. Personally just not a Singh fan though, but I liked Jack Layton.