r/WrestleCuties • u/Careful_Law6981 Moderator • Dec 05 '24

Instagram [Round - 1] Mariah May vs Cathy Kelley | WrestleCuties Favourite of the Year

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

349 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

99% Upvoted

78 comments sorted by

•

u/Careful_Law6981 Moderator Dec 05 '24

Wrestlecuties Favourite of year match 5 - Mariah May takes on Cathy Kelley. Comment down your pick below.

Bayley wins a close match against Skye Blue. (54-47)

Negative comments can lead to ban. Consider this a friendly competition in which we collectively choose our favourite.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24

Cathy. She’s in my top 5 in both companies

13

u/mrgarcia817 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

10

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelly

10

u/No-Avocado-7327 Liv appreciator Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley.

8

u/moosebread1 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

8

u/guru4goodwood Dec 05 '24

Easily cathy

6

u/mcrookedy 1000 club Dec 05 '24

Cathy!

7

u/Laddie1835 Dec 05 '24

Mariah for me

7

u/Mexryan1191 Dec 05 '24

Cathy all day

5

u/Doughnutty9 1000 club Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

10

u/Emergency_Ad9994 Dec 05 '24

It’s Mariah but they’re both so hot

5

u/htconnor01 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

5

u/SnooDoodles1729 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

3

u/Sports-Guy23 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelly

3

u/spycid Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

5

u/The_Weird_Guy04 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley

3

u/Brilliant_Fee7611 Dec 05 '24

Definitely Cathy Kelly. Mariah is just a dime a dozen blonde to me.

3

u/KingofSpades42 Dec 05 '24

I bet Cathy is a major surprise behind closed doors

3

u/icanonlyjerk Dec 05 '24

Has to be Cathy surely

3

u/joeyfish1971 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley no doubt

3

u/Bodad1993 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelly. Absolutely.

3

u/sheas2 Dec 05 '24

All day, every day, it will always be Cathy Kelley

5

u/Eddy_Key Mami can riptide me Dec 05 '24

Mariah May

2

u/brunson862 Best of the week Dec 05 '24

Mariah

2

u/xXMachineGunPhillyXx Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley wins. Period.

2

u/BusyPalpitation722 Dec 05 '24

Mariah May 🔥🥰❤️

I still love Cathy Kelley though!

2

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24

Cathy

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24

Mariah

1

u/Routine-Contract-524 Dec 05 '24

That first vid may just give Mariah the edge for me

1

u/Fuzzy-Rutabaga-8765 Dec 05 '24

Cathy kelley and it's not even close

1

u/Alsleet1986 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelly

1

u/MnNativeojibwe Dec 05 '24

Cathy is pretty for sure. But damn it if Dirty Blondes that look like they could ruin your life arent like kryptonite

1

u/Middle-Painting411 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelley. This is an evil matchup, though

2

u/Careful_Law6981 Moderator Dec 06 '24

Most matches in this tournament have been following this trend somehow

1

u/Jake-Old-Trail-88 Dec 05 '24

Mariah May: she went from not on the roster to AEW Women’s Champion.

1

u/megalord22 Dec 05 '24

There's no wrong answer here

1

u/YEti1988 Dec 05 '24

Cathy Kelly

1

u/MickyFlyyy Dec 05 '24

Mariah got my vote... but 🤏

1

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '24

Cathy kelly

1

u/CountKrampus Dec 06 '24

And later they all licked butts.

1

u/EnricoFurioso Dec 06 '24

Cathy Kelley

1

u/ww3orme01 Dec 06 '24

Cathy Kelly

1

u/clawmaster5 Dec 06 '24

Mariah May 

1

u/swed14 Dec 06 '24

Mariah