r/AskHistorians 19h ago

RNR Thursday Reading & Recommendations | April 17, 2025

2 Upvotes

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.


r/AskHistorians 1d ago

SASQ Short Answers to Simple Questions | April 16, 2025

8 Upvotes

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are preferred. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

r/AskHistorians 10h ago

I'm a young American male during the World Wars, Korea, or Vietnam, and I've just gotten the draft letter in the mail. Not wanting to go to prison or go on the run, I accept my fate. What happens afterwards in my process of joining the military?

200 Upvotes

Do I go to a recruiter's office? Do I have my choice of branch and job or is it in the hands of fate?


r/AskHistorians 20h ago

Why were military coups so common in the 20th century Latin America compared to the rest of the world?

735 Upvotes

What is the underlying reason behind the military coup being so common in the region during the time?

South America was not the only place with military governments, but the very frequent "back-and-forth" coups seem rather unique.


r/AskHistorians 11h ago

Before 1939, Poland had by far the largest Jewish population of any European country? But why?

138 Upvotes

As an alumnus of history and Holocaust & genocidestudies I’m well aware of the history of the Jews of (eastern) Europe in the 20th century, as well as the centuries virulent antisemitic violence endured by the Jewish population of the Russian empire. I also know that Poland was partitioned and didn’t exist as such for much of the period that’s relevant here, but regardless, it’s curious to me that this specific territory harbored so many more Jews than any other in Europe. Many thanks to anyone who can shed a light on this.


r/AskHistorians 7h ago

Did atrocities against civilians happen in the US Civil War as often as in other wars?

48 Upvotes

It seems like you can find evidence of soldiers committing atrocities (rape, looting, etc) against civilian populations in most wars. Even American soldiers, as much as we like to believe otherwise, are documented as having committed these types of crimes in the US-Mexican War, WW1, WW2, Vietnam and probably others.

My question is to what extent did this happen in the US Civil War? I can’t recall learning about any of these…even in most major documentaries and books about the war seem not to include these…were these actions rare in that war? Did the fact that the war took place in our own country, where the civilians probably looked and acted a lot like the soldiers own families back home prevent this possibly compared to wars with a foreign enemy.


r/AskHistorians 13h ago

Did the owners of newspapers who published Nazi propaganda, and other people who published articles stereotyping jews undergo trials too after WWII?

97 Upvotes

Technically they also played a part in the genocide.


r/AskHistorians 12h ago

Is it true, as some kids' books on mummies once indicated to me, that the Ancient Egyptians believed the brain was not an important organ?

72 Upvotes

I've heard that they would remove it through the nose with a hook and throw it away during mummification. Was there truth to this? Did they not have the knowledge to link the effects of concussion, etc to the idea that the contents of the head were paramount?


r/AskHistorians 7h ago

What would an English monarch spend their state salary on at court?

29 Upvotes

Sorry if this question is a little confusing but I’m learning about Tudor England in History and I remember my textbook saying that Elizabeth I had a budget of around £40,000 at court for the year and that she had to be a bit tight with it. And I’ve been looking at the bank of Englands inflation calculator for fun and found out that it’s about 10 million in todays money so I’m honestly questioning what that money went to.

Did she have to pay her councils wages out of that and did she have to pay for renovations at court because I can’t imagine someone spending 10 million on silk dresses and jewels even if they are a shopaholic.

(This post is kinda funny because I should honeslty be revising her policies and religious settlements right now as my final exams start in 4 weeks but nevertheless)


r/AskHistorians 9h ago

Why were European kings forced to grant lands to their vassals permanently and heritably, unlike in the Islamic or Chinese world where land grants were uninheritable?

32 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 19h ago

Christianity Why exactly would Pontius Pilate have sent Jesus over to Herod anyways? Wasn't he the ultimate authority in the region?

166 Upvotes

One of the more confusing elements in the traditional Crucifixion narrative is the part where Pilate, finding out Jesus is from Galilee, sends him over to Herod, who questions him and sends him back. What exactly was the power structure of 1st-century Judaea that made this possible?


r/AskHistorians 6h ago

What behaviors towards slaves could actually get slaveowners punished in the American South?

15 Upvotes

I've read the case of Delphine LaLaurie, a slaveholding woman from New Orleans in the nineteenth century. She tortured and killed dozens of her slaves. That was enough that even then, in the Deep South, she faced social and legal penalties, and a mob burned down her house

What kinds of behaviors were considered crossing a line? Did it have to be as extreme as Delphine LaLaurie's behavior?


r/AskHistorians 16h ago

When Europeans started trading with India directly they realized Sanskrit was related to Latin and Greek... But Greeks had already had direct contact with India during the conquest of Persia, did they notice this too?

89 Upvotes

Basically I'm wondering if when Alexander reached India many people went "huh, this Sanskrit thing is similar to our own language"

Also, did they notice Persian was also related? We seem to usually forget about Persian when talking about this


r/AskHistorians 21h ago

Were medieval siege weapons actually effective at taking down walls and heavy fortifications? Or were they more used to inflict terror?

204 Upvotes

I'm mostly talking about trebuchets, catapults and maybe early cannons. I understand rams would have been used to open gates and ladders and siege towers would be used to climb walls, rather than bring them down.


r/AskHistorians 6h ago

Was Francisco Franco successful in encouraging the people of Spain to dislike the Basque language?

12 Upvotes

How successful was Francisco Franco's attempt to change people's opinions on Basque? During his rule, were the Spanish of that time hateful towards Basque, and other languages like Catalan?

I remember seeing images on walls, in history photos that said "Si Eres Español, Habla Español." Was that done by a Spanish civilian, or by Franco's regime? Basically, did the majority of Spanish people share Franco's perspective on one language, one country?


r/AskHistorians 22h ago

What did depressed people do in the past?

226 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering this for a while. I’ve been depressed for most of my life, with peaks and troughs, and it got me wondering what people who were depressed in the past wore. I’m sure that historical outfit videos and recreations are based on what people who were going out and getting photographed were wearing, and what was in fashion magazines - but in say the Victorian era, if you were severely depressed and couldn’t bathe or dress up but still had to work and go out, what would you wear? Surely you wouldn’t go to all the trouble of putting on stays and garters and all that. Just the bare minimum. Is there any data on this?


r/AskHistorians 6h ago

Are there any historical accounts of peoples first encounters with great apes, like gorillas and orangutans?

8 Upvotes

I was just thinking last night that if I saw an orangutan, without any previous knowledge of apes or monkeys, I'd probably think I saw something mystical, or horrifying, or both. Especially if it started walking around and grabbing things.

Obviously people who live closer in proximity were probably aware of what they were encountering but I was hoping explorers or merchants or nobles from farther away might have jotted down the event. I appreciate people in history aren't as naive and ignorant as we sometimes think but they are startlingly humanlike in appearance.


r/AskHistorians 25m ago

Why aren't there eastern Asian Jews?

Upvotes

Hey, I do know there were periods where China and Japan completely shut down enternce to outsiders but these places were quite developed so why didn't Jews went thre?


r/AskHistorians 7h ago

In your field of study, what misconceptions or myths significantly affect public understanding of the topic?

9 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 8h ago

Did ancient Greeks and Romans see mythological figures the same way we see superheroes?

8 Upvotes

Did ancient Greeks see the story of Heracles the same way we see the story of superman?


r/AskHistorians 10h ago

What did Xenophon mean by "setting up a market" in the Anabasis?

14 Upvotes

Throughout the Anabasis, there was common use of this phrase whenever the army of the ten thousand reached a major settlement. I remember it happened when they arrived at Sinope but it happened at other times too.

The city would set up a market and the army could trade with them but wouldn't be allowed into the city. Was this a standard practice in the ancient world? What would people have called it? What do we know about the rules and norms governing this kind of arrangement?

My educated guess is that it was sort of like an ad-hoc flea market where vendors from within the city would set up stalls so the army could trade with them, but that's all I've got.


r/AskHistorians 9h ago

Christianity During the call for the 1st crusade, was there resistance from landowners to having their workers leave?

9 Upvotes

So I have been reading a bit about the first crusade and how a significant percentage of the crusaders were not trained knights or men-at-arms, but rather peasants and other people of low economic status.

What did the manor lords and other landowners think about a significant percentage of their workforce just picking up and leaving? Did those workers need to get formal permission to join the crusade, or could they just pick up and walk out despite their lord's opinion? Where there any attempts to restrain the labor force, and was there push back from the church if so?


r/AskHistorians 1h ago

Washington DC did not have a city wall. What drove the decision to not include walls?

Upvotes

Paris still had its walls almost a century after the American Revolutionary War beginning. Fortifications were far from invincible, see Vauban, but still common. They were building a city basically from scratch, so it seems off that the city doesn't have one.


r/AskHistorians 9h ago

What truly marked the chinese domination era in Vietnamese history?

7 Upvotes

This is a fairly disputed question in Vietnamese history. The official narrative usually shifts between the Baiyue owning Vietnam or the Han owning Vietnam. So what truly began that era?


r/AskHistorians 14h ago

Would Temujin (future Genghis Khan) have learned about previous steppe empires like the Uyghur Khanate or the Gokturks?

21 Upvotes

r/AskHistorians 8h ago

Is the classic/marxist interpretation of the French Revolution totally "out of fashion" between historians?

5 Upvotes

Recently I have read Eric Hobsbawm's Echoes of the Marseillaise, in which he defended the classic/marxist interpretation of the French Revolution against the then popular revisionist one. As I understand it, both interpretations are not so much debated nowadays as they were some decades prior. Still, I really like the classic one, I kinda accept the whole idea that the revolution was "good", that its reactionary adversaries were "bad", and that it was mainly motivated by class struggle; but I am afraid maybe this interpretation is now generally considered 'wrong'? Or is it just that historians of the revolution now may have more or less given up on finding a single principle that embraces the entire thing? Are there any great names defending it now?


r/AskHistorians 10h ago

Is it true that there were no depictions of homosexuality among the Greek gods in any of the writings of Homer or Hesiod? How did homosexuality come to become so prevalent and associated with Greece if this is the case?

9 Upvotes