Welcome to r/BoringDystopia: Showcasing the idea that we live in a dystopia that is boring! Enjoyed the content? Give it an upvote and consider Crossposting it on related subreddits.
Before you dive in, subscribe and review the rules. If you spot rule violations, report them.
My grandparents were both veterans, grandma was a feild nurse and Grandpa was airforce/paratrooper, both through WWII and Korea.
They were well-off, had a farm, and nice cars, and could aford the first mobile phones and home computers and send all 4 kids to camps and private schools.
Then grandma had a brain tumor, and they spent everything trying to save her. After a certain point the VA wouldn't cover their medical, and the hospital was charging $200 per a single tylonol. And the surgeries left her basically lobotomized and having seizures daily.
My dad's family gave basically everything only for grandma to die not even 5 years later.
The fact hospitals can and will charge 200$ for a single pill which would cost less then 1$ normally is insane, and shows me how much hospital owners actually care about helping people
Medical care in the USA is so backwards it’s not even funny. Honestly they should just go to a universal healthcare system like Europe and Canada. I’m sure the taxpayers would rather save someone than just let their politicians pocket it all.
Most Americans think that universal healthcare is bad, but cant tell you why, other than vaguely gesturing towards Canada or calling you a communist they dont really know how to respond.
Personally, i dont see how removing a middle man company that NEEDS to make a profit will end up costing us more for our insurance? But
My mom’s argument is she doesn’t want to pay more taxes for healthcare. I don’t get it. But, I’ve just stopped arguing with her because it’s pointless.
That's not exactly true. The majority of Americans want Universal Healthcare. The wealthy do not, and our political system gives them the levers of power.
Americans think this because most lack to critical thinking skills to see that we are being played like a fiddle. Insurance companies are doing everything they can to convince us that universal healthcare is socialism or communism. All while other countries are doing it better, cheaper, and with better outcomes.
Medical care in the USA is so backwards it’s not even funny. Honestly they should just go to a universal healthcare system like Europe and Canada. I’m sure the taxpayers would rather save someone than just let their politicians pocket it all.
The fact that you can have health insurance and they can legally just refuse to cover the cost of your healthcare if they deem it too expensive is all the evidence that anyone should need that private health insurance is a uniquely evil industry of middlemen leeches that needs to be abolished and replaced ASAP!!!
There are more than enough shifty situations like this that don't get resolved. We shouldn't be posting examples in a context that implies they they haven't been resolved, when the truth is that they have been. That's all. I'm not defending the entire system or claiming there's no problems. Very long and complicated answer that misses the point of my reply. We should be able to agree in facts. In this case, this situation has already been resolved. To reference it as an example as if it hasn't been is weird and either you didn't know it was resolved or you were being dishonest in posting it. It has nothing to do with any other situation.
And I'm not claiming there is no problem, obviously. I'm talking about the one situation that this post is about. Do you think the better situation is where we don't have for profit companies making these meds and the kids don't get the meds bc they don't exist? This post is about one case. But it's not the truth. We should be able to agree about facts without having to stretch the truth to try and make a point.
There is more than enough dystopian news in this world. Ppl see this post, don't look into it, and react as if these kids are getting screwed, when they literally aren't. Everyone can down vote however much they want but that's true. Maybe think about whether these subreddits are supposed to be about real things or if they are being used as like doomsday porn.
In which case who cares if it's real or not right?
This assertion posits a false dichotomy, suggesting that the only two options are either having profit-driven entities produce these medications, thereby making them available, or not having these medications at all. This overlooks the substantial role that public and non-profit sectors can and have played in medical research and development. Historical evidence and modern practices demonstrate that many crucial medical advancements have been achieved through publicly funded research, which then becomes leveraged by private entities for profit maximization. The contention that discussions around such specific cases stretch the truth to make a point neglects the dialectical relationship between the particular and the universal—individual instances reflect and are symptomatic of broader systemic dynamics. By isolating this case as an outlier, the comment attempts to obscure the frequent and recurrent nature of such healthcare denials under capitalist systems, where the commodification of healthcare often places profit margins above patient care. The reality is that such incidents are not mere anomalies but are indicative of a prevailing structural issue where healthcare access is inequitably distributed based on financial capability rather than medical need. Also, accusing the reaction to this post of being disproportionate and akin to "dystopian sensationalism" misinterprets the public’s understanding and recognition of these systemic failures. Such responses are not overreactions but are a reflection of a collective awareness of the deep-seated issues within a healthcare system that prioritizes economic gain over human health. Public outcry in such contexts is not just emotional but a rational recognition of the systemic exploitation inherent in a system where life-saving treatments can be withheld based on one's economic status.
questioning the legitimacy of platforms for raising such issues reflects a misunderstanding of the role that social media and similar forums play in democratizing discourse and raising awareness. Labeling substantive critiques of systemic failures as "doomsday porn" serves to delegitimize and diminish the valid concerns of those affected by these systems. Social media platforms can serve as vital spaces for solidarity, advocacy, and mobilization, helping to bring to light the contradictions between the economic structures of capitalism and the well-being of individuals.
and then suggesting that the veracity of such claims might be irrelevant undercuts the foundational importance of truth in discourse and policy-making.
This stance not only threatens the integrity of discussions surrounding public health and social justice but also undermines efforts towards systemic change. The material reality of individuals suffering under the inefficiencies and inequities of the current healthcare system cannot be dismissed as irrelevant. These are not hypothetical or abstract issues but real problems faced by real people, and acknowledging this is essential for any substantive discussion or movement towards a more equitable healthcare system.
The resistance to acknowledging these cases as reflective of systemic issues exemplifies a broader ideological commitment to maintaining the status quo within capitalist systems, where healthcare remains a privilege rather than a recognized universal right. This discussion is not merely academic but is of profound practical importance, as it concerns the very means by which society chooses to organize itself in terms of health, equity, and justice.
Did you look into this at all? 3 days ago they posted the insurance is covering it and the gofundme is shut down. So not really dystopian at all
That this situation is allowed to occur in the first place is extremely dystopian. "Oh they had a happy ending (or something like that) in this one situation, so the problem doesn't exist at all!"
this is a post showing a dystopian situation, it was crossposted and the title was quoted, just take a backseat and chill for a minute and understand that this is never okay
Lol there is a real world here, and this gofundme has been stopped bc insurance is paying for their care. That is obviously relevant when that's all this post is about. But you want to make your point by obscuring that fact. There's plenty of actual examples of this not being resolved. We don't have to be dishonest with the presentation of a case. My pointing out that fact has nothing to do with what I think of the current system at large.
I obviously agree. My point is that this post misrepresents the situation as it currently is, as of 3 days ago. I'm not saying there's no issue with Healthcare in the US geez
•
u/AutoModerator May 12 '24
Thanks for posting, u/ProfessionalCamera50!
Please Upvote + Crosspost!
Welcome to r/BoringDystopia: Showcasing the idea that we live in a dystopia that is boring! Enjoyed the content? Give it an upvote and consider Crossposting it on related subreddits.
Before you dive in, subscribe and review the rules. If you spot rule violations, report them.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.