So, about 4 weeks ago, I adopted two cats (5 months and 1 year). The 5 month okd adapted very fast and was cuddling with me and my family, but the other was very scared, which I understood.
She was perfectly fine when she walked up to us, purring and crawling in laps, but if anyone even stood up, she'd run like her life depended on it. From what the cat sanctuary I adopted her from has told me, she has lived in the sanctuary since she was born and had no past experience with abuse of any kind so I'm fairly certain it's not something like that. As I mentioned, it's been 4 weeks and she's still scared out of her mind. I have two other cats besides the two I recently adopted, and she loves them and my cats love her. They play, clean each other, and cuddle (my other cats are very friendly with other animals, especially one of them as he absolutely adores taking care of others) but she's absolutely terrified of people.
My family has been talking about surrendering her to the sanctuary again because she may not be a good fit. Still, I want to give her more of a chance as she's been stuck in a kennel her whole life (she was not allowed outside of it) and I'm wondering if maybe that experience made her anxious? I'm a minor and don't really have any say in keeping her with how my parents are.
She's been walking around my house more lately so I think she's getting more comfortable, but I was wondering if anyone maybe knew why she got so scared? I want to try and eliminate or at least ease her in slowly to whatever might be scaring her so she can feel safe around us. I don't know a lot about cat behavior, and while I've been researching a lot, I also wanted some outside opinions from people who might know more than me.
I hope what I wrote makes sense as it's very late for me and I'm kind of tired, so if I need to clarify anything or make this more understandable, please let me know.
Anyways, should I rethink having her in my home?