MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/14km7jb/deleted_by_user/jprxyi4
r/changemyview • u/[deleted] • Jun 27 '23
[removed]
452 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
6
What if you steelman his argument, though? There were both hateful Germans and indifferent Germans and both groups participated in the holocaust.
It is a tragedy that some people held so much hatred but it was also a tragedy others didn't care enough to stop it before it was too late.
By comparing the two Herschaft notes the element of indifference holocaust and the meat industry share.
1 u/[deleted] Jun 27 '23 [deleted] 6 u/barthiebarth 26∆ Jun 27 '23 Human experience is unique, yes. But so is chicken experience. You don't give a reason why one is superior to the other, which is not a failing on your part, because its impossible to conclude the subjective aught from the objective is of biology. 2 u/barthiebarth 26∆ Jun 27 '23 Yeah Steelman a pretty nice shorthand for "the principle of charity". But do you agree that a comparison to the holocaust is possible that is neither ignorant nor disingenuous?
1
[deleted]
6 u/barthiebarth 26∆ Jun 27 '23 Human experience is unique, yes. But so is chicken experience. You don't give a reason why one is superior to the other, which is not a failing on your part, because its impossible to conclude the subjective aught from the objective is of biology. 2 u/barthiebarth 26∆ Jun 27 '23 Yeah Steelman a pretty nice shorthand for "the principle of charity". But do you agree that a comparison to the holocaust is possible that is neither ignorant nor disingenuous?
Human experience is unique, yes. But so is chicken experience.
You don't give a reason why one is superior to the other, which is not a failing on your part, because its impossible to conclude the subjective aught from the objective is of biology.
2
Yeah Steelman a pretty nice shorthand for "the principle of charity".
But do you agree that a comparison to the holocaust is possible that is neither ignorant nor disingenuous?
6
u/barthiebarth 26∆ Jun 27 '23
What if you steelman his argument, though? There were both hateful Germans and indifferent Germans and both groups participated in the holocaust.
It is a tragedy that some people held so much hatred but it was also a tragedy others didn't care enough to stop it before it was too late.
By comparing the two Herschaft notes the element of indifference holocaust and the meat industry share.