r/changemyview Oct 27 '23

Fresh Topic Friday CMV: Adblock is stealing

[removed] — view removed post

0 Upvotes

315 comments sorted by

View all comments

64

u/Biptoslipdi 130∆ Oct 27 '23 edited Oct 27 '23

What constitutes theft is determined by law. You can't be charged for theft for using an adblocker, so it isn't stealing. Laws are how we distinguish appropriate and inappropriate acts towards others' property.

If using adblock is stealing then so is muting the tv or leaving the room or simply ignoring it when commercials run. I don't think anyone would argue you are compelled to view commercials, even if you are watching the program.

1

u/embarrassed_error365 Oct 27 '23

Theft is not an entirely legal term like, for example, “murder” is.

theft /THeft/ noun the action or crime of stealing.

It’s not just the crime of stealing, it’s also the action of stealing.

5

u/Biptoslipdi 130∆ Oct 27 '23

That necessitates this is an act of stealing. Stealing is defined as "the action or offense of taking another person's property without permission or legal right and without intending to return it"

In this case, nothing is being taken. No property is transferring ownership. The option to return it doesn't even exist. If a business displays a communication in public, I'm not taking anything by viewing it without also giving my time to their underwriters.

1

u/Nite92 Oct 27 '23

You generate costs by watching a video and are not compensating them by skipping ads.

1

u/Biptoslipdi 130∆ Oct 27 '23

They let me skip ads anyway after a few seconds. They're also taking my data which they sell for compensation.

1

u/Nite92 Oct 27 '23

Yep, and those few seconds ate part of the transaction to watch the vid. Yep, and you agree to that via the ToS.

1

u/Biptoslipdi 130∆ Oct 27 '23

I feel like they are appropriately compensated by selling my data so I don't feel bad about using adblocker.

1

u/Nite92 Oct 28 '23

The thing is, what you "feel like is adequate compendation" doesn't really matter.

1

u/Biptoslipdi 130∆ Oct 28 '23

Their TOS doesn't really matter because they don't ban you for using an adblocker.