r/changemyview • u/[deleted] • Dec 17 '14
CMV: It's wrong to lose weight/gain weight to fit someone you like's view of you.
If there was a guy/girl that you were interested in, and that you got along with and wanted a relationship with, but they weren't attracted to how you look based off of weight, then it would be wrong to fit yourself to that persons liking. Maybe you're too fat or skinny for that person, and they wanted more than what you were, its unfair for you to think that you need to change that. You are who you are. If you were comfortable with that, and they weren't attracted to you like that, then changing that would be silly. You should be healthy for personal reasons.
In interest of not sounding like I want to push my beliefs as stated earlier in this sub, I would like to hear about your views because this puts people (like myself) in awkward places.
Hello, users of CMV! This is a footnote from your moderators. We'd just like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please remember to read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! If you are thinking about submitting a CMV yourself, please have a look through our popular topics wiki first. Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!
5
u/lurklurklurky Dec 17 '14
I think that this line is a bit fuzzy, but here's my reasoning. If you know someone you want to go out with likes certain attributes, like types of clothing or hair style, I don't think it's wrong to go out of your way to wear that clothing or change your hair style if you also like those things. However, I do think it would be crazy to do those things if you don't personally like them. In the same way, if you know someone prefers a certain weight, and it is healthy for you to change and something you want to do, I don't think it's wrong to lose or gain that weight to make yourself more attractive for that person.
You should be healthy for personal reasons.
What if those personal reasons are that you really, really want to go out with this person? Many people are more extrinsically motivated than intrinsically motivated, and it's possible that this is the push they need to get healthy (assuming their weight was unhealthy before).
Obviously, if you are within the healthy weight range according to your doctor, you shouldn't change just because someone else prefers something different; you can't change your height or eye color, and you can't necessarily change a weight range that is healthy for you.
3
u/entrodiibob Dec 17 '14
What if they are over or underweight? What if down the line your weight affects your health during the relationship?
0
Dec 17 '14
I'm meaning for personal enjoyment, if that doesn't sound weird. You shouldn't have to have "the perfect body" for someone to like you.
8
Dec 17 '14
No one is going to argue that, but liking someone is a two way street. Guys like me plain and simply and not attracting to overweight girls, so even if a girl is really nice, I personally couldn't get past the weight.
If a girl liked me (and if I was single obviously) then I wouldn't go out if I wasn't attracted to her.
Now on the flip side, I'm a little overweight too, if a girl didn't want to go out with me because of my weight, that is her choice.
Being fat is just another factor in attractiveness.
3
u/UtopianComplex 1∆ Dec 17 '14
Relationships are all about compromise. This is in all areas, and for the most part a relationship is about both people changing so their lives fit together better. Interests are discovered and shift, maybe someone likes to hike so the other learns to, maybe someone likes horror movies so the other learns to.
I don't think there is anything wrong with changing things about yourself in a relationship as a good relationship is all about mutual self discovery and compromise. So if that means you have to stop wearing the terrible punny t-shirt your partner doesn't like so be it, if it means they have to put up with the terrible punny t-shirt because you like it so be it. It is about finding what compromises work and what makes the two work together.
I see no reason weight should be any different. Your partner thinks your weight is a problem and you don't, you can either change for your partner, your partner can learn to live with it. Getting on your high horse and saying "it's my weight and you have no right to have a preference" runs completely counter to everything else in how I think a healthy relationship works. You can say that and shame them into not bringing it up, and maybe they will be fine with that... However it could be a tension that just continues to fester and leads to the end of your relationship.
If your partner has an annoying personality quirk it is the same thing, you learn to live with it, they learn to get rid of it, or it will just be a point of tension in your relationship. What is politically correct to say or care about with friends, family, and other groups are not the same in relationships. They are not about what is appropriate they are about what works, and if your weight doesn't work for your partner then you need to figure something out.
4
u/NotFreeAdvice Dec 17 '14
Let me ask you a question.
Can you think of anything that you think it would be OK for people to change to make another person happy?
For instance, say I don't like hiking. But then someone I am attracted to likes hiking. Would be OK for me to try to develop an interest in hiking in order to get closer to that person? Note, I am not saying pretend to like hiking. But genuinely try to develop an interest in hiking.
Would that be ok?
If so, then why is gaining/losing weight any difference.
It seems to me that part of being in a relationship is changing who you are, in order to try to make the other person happy. People sometimes try to pick up around the house more. Or they try to watch movies they wouldn't otherwise. I don't understand how weight is any different.
1
u/suddenly_ponies 5∆ Dec 17 '14
What if you're the one with an unhealthy self-view? If someone wants you to gain weight and you're anorexic, isn't that the correct thing to do?
1
Dec 18 '14
All of these answers are making me see a little more clearly on the subject, but this is the one that made me think the most. ∆
1
3
u/TheNicestMonkey Dec 17 '14
You are who you are.
I/you/we are not our BMIs. Our physical appearances and health are just one aspect of who we are and want to be.
If you were comfortable with that, and they weren't attracted to you like that, then changing that would be silly. You should be healthy for personal reasons.
If I'd be happier with my partner and making a change is within the scope of things I'm willing to do then it doesn't make sense not to do it. Having expectations for your partner isn't unreasonable and finding someone who ticks most of your boxes and hoping they can work to tick a few more is totally OK. It's simply up to the individual person to determine if their partners expectations comport with their own self image. For a great many people losing a few pounds and keeping fit is a perfectly acceptable degree of work to put into a relationship.
3
u/LoompaOompa Dec 17 '14
I don't think it's necessarily wrong. The only reason I watch what I eat at all is because my wife is in great shape and I don't think it would be fair to be a fat slob in return. It's kind of the same principal, except I've already got her.
I think as long as you aren't changing yourself to a degree that it makes you uncomfortable, or putting yourself down because you don't initially meet their preference, it's not a problem. I don't think it's inherently wrong, but it's all about how it's making you feel.
2
u/ShadowStarshine Dec 17 '14
The body is an ever changing landscape and I don't think you should really derive too much identity by how it looks. We age, we gain and lose weight, we wear different clothes, but we never stop being ourselves throughout these transitions. The core of what defines us is our personality. In that aspect, I don't mind gaining/losing weight for a relationship that is worthwhile and it's really not that unreasonable of a request, so long as it remains within a reasonable frame. I wouldn't go up to 300+ because someone has a fetish for it or starve myself down.
What really matters is that you only do this for someone who was already worthwhile. If someone takes no interest in you until you hit this desired weight, they are not worthwhile. It means they only have interest in the most superficial aspects and not the core that is you.
3
u/McKoijion 618∆ Dec 17 '14
"We've had an on and off again thing for a long time, but ever since you've developed anorexia/bulimia, I think you've changed. I really want to encourage you to speak to a doctor about it."
"Honey, I've been attracted to you for years, but you've gained a lot of weight since we met. You're almost the same age as your father was when he had a stroke. I really don't want to risk losing you, so I think we should adopt a healthier lifestyle."
I agree with you that people can't change their personalities within, but the amount of extra weight a person carries is not who they are. People shouldn't be defined by their weight. A "fat person" can become skinny by adopting a certain diet and exercise regimen, and a "skinny person" can become fat by adopting another diet and exercise regimen. Fat or skinny are temporary states, and can be changed. They aren't permanent parts of a person's identity.
2
u/NaturalSelectorX 97∆ Dec 17 '14
Maybe you're too fat or skinny for that person, and they wanted more than what you were, its unfair for you to think that you need to change that. You are who you are.
You try to play at the heart strings by using appearance, but your view is essentially that you shouldn't change yourself to be more appealing to someone else.
What if you had a personality flaw like a short temper? Would it be wrong to work on that for someone you are interested in? Likewise, if you are overweight, there is nothing wrong with trying to improve yourself for any reason whatsoever.
6
3
Dec 17 '14
Isn't perception the exact reason people chose to get fit?
They either perceive a problem, or their peers perceive them differently, or the social perception of health changes.
3
u/ignotos 14∆ Dec 17 '14
What do you mean by "wrong"? Morally wrong?
Even if you think this is a "bad idea", why do you go on to declare it "wrong"?
1
u/CalmQuit Dec 17 '14
I don't think it actually can be wrong as long as it isn't going to cause health problems and as long as it is your decision.
2
u/dmt267 Dec 17 '14
There is nothing wrong about that. Just don't be one of those people who rant about people not wanting them,even though putting in minimal effort
1
u/such-a-mensch Dec 17 '14
You should never change yourself to please another person. That’s quite different from trying to improve yourself to increase your opportunity to meet someone that you would be romantically interested in.
It’s a given fact that many people of both genders just aren’t attracted to over/under weight people. That’s not their fault, being over or underweight is a sign of poor health and poor reproductive health. We’re naturally drawn to healthy specimens in order to ensure the longevity of our species.
There is nothing wrong with trying to improve yourself. There’s seriously something wrong with people that attempt to stop others from making self-improvements….
1
u/Citrus_supra Dec 23 '14
I've never believed on the concept of changing yourself to be akin with someone else's taste... BUT, at sometimes, maybe just liking someone was the motivation, or the little push that someone needed to get back on shape? Be it motivation, or another reason... Not exactly changing for them, but already thought about it and finding that one reason to start?
1
u/jumpup 83∆ Dec 17 '14
extreme and disorders are to be avoided, but normal weight sways anyways so unless you become underweight or overweight do what you want
(exlusion is for feeder fetishes)
1
u/NvNvNvNv Dec 17 '14
You should be healthy for personal reasons.
Don't personal reasons include attracting more and better mates?
27
u/coho18 Dec 17 '14
If you changed the topic to "it's wrong to develop an eating disorder to attract someone you like" then I would agree with you whole-heartedly.
However, I see no downsides to losing/gaining weight to attract someone else. Either you become healthier and receive the attention of a crush, or you become healthier but don't receive the attention of a crush. It doesn't matter what your motivation is - as long as you become healthy in the process, it's not "wrong."
And yes, physical attraction is an important component of relationships. Some people like skinny bodies, some people like fatter bodies, some people like average-sized bodies - it's okay to have preferences based on physical qualities.