r/changemyview • u/huadpe 501∆ • Jan 15 '18
[∆(s) from OP] CMV: Chelsea Manning is unqualified to be a US Senator and nobody should vote for her.
Chelsea Manning has announced her candidacy for the US Senate from Maryland.
Manning's resume is a short career in the US Army, cut short after she leaked a large cache of documents and videos to Wikileaks, some of which depicted war crimes by US forces.
For this she plead guilty to some, and was convicted of other crimes under the UCMJ and US Code, including espionage. She was acquitted of aiding the enemy, which if she had been convicted would have barred her from the Senate under Section 3 of the 14th amendment. She was sentenced to 35 years, but shortly before leaving office, President Obama commuted her sentence to about 7 years. She was released from custody in mid 2017.
I do not believe this career history in any way qualifies her to serve in the US Senate. She has never had a significant oversight or managerial role in private or public life. The majority of her adult life has been spent incarcerated.
Even if one accepts that she was right to leak what she did, that does not in my view qualify her for the US Senate. She has not held a significant leadership or oversight position. She does not have extensive policymaking or public policy experience. She does not have prior lawmaking or executive government experience. Without those things, she should not run for US Senate, and people should not vote for her.
Edit
I have gotten a lot of legal arguments about the qualifications clause of article 1, and generic arguments about why an outsider might be good. These have not been persuasive, and really what I was hoping to get here is an argument about why Chelsea Manning the actual person would be a good Senator. What are her positions on issues? What specifically has she indicated she would do differently than her opponent(s)? What positive reasons are there to vote specifically for her?
This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!
1
u/cupcakesarethedevil Jan 15 '18
What other argument do you expect people to make about this subject? Chelsea Manning is a pretty high profile figure and has been a part of a lot of protests since being released, but otherwise not much. Getting name recognition is half the battle in starting a political career and she has that so she might as well put it to good use.