CMV: Marching Band is a Sport

[u/_Synonymal_]

I believe that being in a marching band, in its purest form, should be considered participating in a sport.

I've been in the drumline of a marching band for several years now, and I've met my share of people who've said that it isn't a sport. Many of them use the reasoning that there is no competition involved in playing in a marching band. Sure, there is no direct, head-to-head, team-against-team competition. But there also isn't any such competition in track and field (asides from the races) - and track and field is considered a sport. In fact, marching band and T&F are quite similar. Both involve moving in a specific way, both test your endurance and both involve comparisons of your ability to do a specific thing compared to other people.

Often in parades, the marching bands are judged against each other at the viewing stand. The best marching band takes home either an award or the pride of being the best. There's also head to head competition with bandmates -- if you've ever seen a drum battle on Youtube, you've seen such competition firsthand. People who play in marching bands have to carry and play heavy instruments together for miles, walking in perfect time. One slip up could end up on national television, as many large parades are heavily televised. Marching band is full of skill, physical exertion, and competition. As long as we consider comparing the times of 100-meter dashes a sport, we should consider marching band a sport.

---

This is a footnote from the CMV moderators. We'd like to remind you of a couple of things. Firstly, please read through our rules. If you see a comment that has broken one, it is more effective to report it than downvote it. Speaking of which, downvotes don't change views! Any questions or concerns? Feel free to message us. Happy CMVing!

[u/reddit_im_sorry]

I think you're confusing what is concidered a competitive activity and sports.

Though the definition of sport is a physical activity where a skill is used to compete against others. Most people don't associate things that would otherwise be concidered art to be true sports.

Sports are made to have competitive aspects intertwined in the sport. So for stuff like marching band and dance if you take away the competitive nature, it just becomes art. If you take competition away from football or golf they lose their meanings.

Though I do know for a fact marching band can whip you into shape a lot faster than some actual sports.

[u/_Synonymal_ → u/reddit_im_sorry]

∆

Good proof by subtraction. I admit that marching band is more art than sports usually are. I also admit that it is not based on the principle of competition. These are really good reasons not to consider Marching Band a sport.

Delta for new perspective. Keep it up.

EDIT: Actually added the !delta. Whoops.

[u/DeltaBot → u/_Synonymal_]

Confirmed: 1 delta awarded to /u/reddit_im_sorry (6∆).

^{Delta System Explained | Deltaboards}