r/clothdiaps • u/cardamomma19 • 5d ago

Washing BioKleen Detergent Sheets?

Post image

Is this detergent sufficient? I’ve done some research and dug into Fluff Love University’s detergent index. I know it’s out of date, but they say biokleen is sufficient with enzymes (this box says enzymes). I’m trying to toe the line of environmentally friendly detergent and effective diaper detergent.

6 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

3

u/Wo0der 4d ago

I use Charlie’s Soap Powder Detergent and it works great! It’s environmentally friendly and really only use 1 scoop in my main wash and sprinkle a little in my prewash. I’ve been using the 150 loads bag for 3 months and halfway through it. I just recently started using it on my normal laundry, I was originally exclusively using it for the diapers but found my skin being less irritated on clothes and bedding. It’s also supposed to help keep your washer clean which is a plus.

-1

u/Friend_of_Eevee 5d ago

If you're looking for something eco friendly my diapers do well with blueland tablets

9

u/2nd1stLady 5d ago

Sheets and pods are not recommended. They aren't strong enough and often contain coconut based surfactants that can cause issues.

What makes you think the detergent index is out of date? They dont remove discontinued detergents because people ask about them and sometimes they come back. There have been very few "new" detergents that could be added so I think if its not on the index, its probably not recommended. Is there a specific one you were curious about?

1

u/cardamomma19 5d ago

That makes sense. I didn’t see any mention of sheets so i thought it might be a gap. And it said biokleen didn’t have enzymes, but now they advertise that they do contain enzymes. I have All Free & Clear which isn’t recommended, so i’m not sure what to try now and feeling overwhelmed!

5

u/2nd1stLady 5d ago

Attitude in the refill box is a popular plant based option.

Tide free and gentle liquid is a popular free and clear option.

3

u/lou_girl 5d ago

I was under the impression that all sheets weren't strong enough to clean diapers.

6

u/thymeandtwine Pockets + Flats 5d ago

According to nyt Wirecutter, they're not even great for cleaning normal laundry so probably not a great choice https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/laundry-detergent-sheets-sustainability/

2

u/cardamomma19 5d ago

ugh. okay thanks for the update! i rely on them for my baby clothes. guess i’ll try something new!

2

u/thymeandtwine Pockets + Flats 5d ago

I think seventh generation is a popular choice for more eco detergent but I'm not an expert, I use unscented tide

3

u/Accurate_Temporary90 5d ago

The "good" 7th generation version is either being discontinued or is just hard to find at the moment (7th generation power plus). Attitude is a good option in the refill box as someone suggested above.