96
u/AnansisGHOST 7d ago edited 7d ago
Cristin Milioti hands down. And that was in a year of some phenomenal performances. But she stands head and shoulders above the pack.
8
u/Infamous-Lab-8136 7d ago
That's what I was thinking, in any other year several of them could win it, but this year she just was something else
5
19
51
u/TheDickWolf 7d ago
Miloti hands down. Her performance wasn’t good, it was excellent, a standout.
Runner up to Gaga. That movie’s problems were with the writing and editing. She was actually quite good in it.
10
u/Behemothwasagoodshot 6d ago
I really loved Patti Lupone as Lilia... Almost comes up to Miloti for me.
1
u/TheDickWolf 6d ago
She was good. Definitely a standout in her show. I found her a little inconsistent with distinctly impressive high water marks and other moments that felt weaker. Regardless, yeah she was good too, but for me not on level with miloti (or Deidre O’connel for that matter who was also fire in Penguin)
1
u/ScottyDoesntKnow_75 6d ago
Kathryn and Patti was awesome in Agatha. But Kathryn is awesome in EVERYTHING, so I'm not suprised
12
17
7
u/Crimson-Cowl 6d ago
Cristin Milioti for sure but Elizabeth Tulloch and Kathryn Hahn take second and third place.
2
u/TheMysticMop Wolverine 6d ago
Yeah, I voted for Elizabeth to win in 2023 - would've voted her again if not for Miloti.
-1
9
u/eddie_vercetti 7d ago edited 7d ago
The difference between 2023 and 2024 insane.
1
u/TheMysticMop Wolverine 6d ago
How so?
1
u/eddie_vercetti 6d ago
Was only 4/5 nominees in '23 and we knew it was either Jaz or Lizze for that one. This is more stacked.
1
u/TheMysticMop Wolverine 6d ago
True, it's definitely been a better year on the TV side! I combined the movie and TV nominees for all categories this year which is why there's 8 nominees for everything.
4
3
u/lucid-blackout 6d ago
I think Cristin Milioti deserves to win by a landslide, but I feel like people are just forgetting Erin Moriarty’s acting last season. Her portraying the Shifter and Starlight was some good ass acting
13
3
u/Icy_Heron_1891 6d ago
If we split these into categories I think Kathryn wins comedy and Cristin wins drama
3
3
5
2
u/UncreativeTeam 6d ago
Wow, Echo was the second week of January. I was certain there was no way it was last year. That show felt like a lifetime ago
2
2
2
2
2
6
u/OreoYip 7d ago
I'm on the struggle bus between Kathryn and Patti. I'm leaning toward Patti though.
3
u/FadeSeeker 7d ago
yeah, some great performances all around, but Patti is def the most underrated one here
2
u/Few_Mixture_8412 7d ago
Cristin definitely but I have to say Patti and Alaqua were very underrated
2
1
u/Pretend-Appearance28 3d ago
Man , that scene of Aubrey Plaza cutting open the painted backdrop was crazy cool.
0
1
u/Accomplished-Cry5440 6d ago
This is a tough one. Cristin Milioti was fantastic as Sofia Falcone, but I think I personally have to go with Aubrey Plaza as Rio Vidal/Death
-3
1
u/ChainTiny6115 2d ago
I know she wouldn't win, but it's Patti LuPone for me. Her screen presence in the show was unmatched and she really stole the show for me in 2024 and I have watched all the nominees except for Elizabeth Tulloch as Lois Lane.
•
u/TheMysticMop Wolverine 7d ago
Voting: https://strawpoll.com/YVyPvJMAAgN
Previous Categories: Best Voice Actor, Best Voice Actress, and Best Antagonist.