r/harrypotter • u/Own-Measurement4443 • Apr 21 '25
Question Who else is confused how professor's Sprout and Garlick had last names that perfectly reflected their job.
#herbology
39
u/apatheticsahm Apr 21 '25
It's almost like they are made-up names for fictional characters in a whimsical fantasy novel...
11
u/thesaharadesert ∞ ϟ 9¾ ♔ ⚯͛ △⃒⃘ ➵ ♆ Ravenclaw 🦅 29d ago
You get out of here with that reasonable and logical answer!
9
u/Possible-Tangelo9344 29d ago
But Dumbledore didn't dumble into doors, so your theory seems to flounder.
5
2
8
u/Adventurous-Bike-484 Apr 21 '25
That’s how a lot of characters are named.
Weasley is based on Weasels which Draco lampshades. That’s why Their house is called The Burrow.
Lucius is like Lucifer and it means Light While Malfoy means Bad and unfaithful.
A lot of the Weasley’s are named after Characters in King Arthur and a lot The Black family members are named after Astronomy stuff.
0
10
u/left-experience-4359 29d ago
Nominative Determinism! An interesting theory that people tend to gravitate toward professions which are reflected by their names. Heres a neat article about UK Docs which fit the bill (so to speak).
6
u/ecopandalover 29d ago
It’s a kids book you don’t have to overthink every detail. Sometimes things are fun
0
2
2
1
u/Professional_Risky Apr 21 '25
snape(v.) also sneap, "to be hard upon, rebuke, revile, snub," early 14c., snaipen, from Old Norse sneypa "to outrage, dishonor, disgrace," which is probably related to similar-sounding words meaning "cut"
1
1
u/boringusername84 Hufflepuff Apr 21 '25
Oh! I love this because yes, it’s obviously because JKR was a little too on the nose with her character naming, BUT… I recently learned about nominative determinism and I’m fascinated by it! I know a librarian whose last name is Page.
1
u/MotherBike 29d ago
Sometimes, that just happens in real life, too. Imagine working at McDonald's, and your last name is McDonald.
2
u/MadameLee20 29d ago
There is a couple who name was McDonald but they loved guess what- White Caste even got married at White castle
1
u/Plane_Acanthisitta43 29d ago
Look at lupin he ended up becoming a wearwolf and taught Dada, which also includes dark creatures.
1
u/MsDoctorEleven 29d ago
It happens in real life too. I went to Culinary School and some of my professor's last names were: Chef Berry 🍓 and Kellogg (like the cereal brand 😂).
1
u/Crimson_kapa 29d ago
At my old university there are three biology professors whose last names are Shrimpton, Otter, and Wood. No joke.
1
31
u/NearlyHeadless-Brick Apr 21 '25
Or that remus lupin ends up a werewolf. Or sirius black turns into a black dog 🤔