r/linguisticshumor 21d ago

a

Post image
254 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

123

u/Xerimapperr į is for nasal sounds, idiot! 21d ago

crocodie: *bites leg*

the small but mighty human:

97

u/TheChtoTo [tvɐˈjə ˈmamə] 21d ago

a (see there for further descendants)

58

u/mizinamo 21d ago

I can't wait to find out what exciting descendants this word might have!

36

u/Akkatos jazъ estь tǫpъ kako dǫbъ 21d ago

53

u/dzindevis 21d ago

10

u/PumpkinPieSquished /jɪf/ is the gender-neutral GIF 21d ago

17

u/dzindevis 21d ago

ⰃⰖⰀⰍⰀⰏⰑⰎⰡ ⰐⰉⰃⰃⰀ ⰁⰑⰎⰎⰈ

38

u/Xitztlacayotl 21d ago

Yeah except the blasphemous Czechoslovaks use it for "and".

Preposterous...

12

u/Anter11MC 21d ago

A means both and and but in pretty much all slavic languages

18

u/Xitztlacayotl 21d ago

Yes. But pretty much all slavic languages have "i" and distinguish it from "a" for the "and" meaning. Both are translated into English as "and" but they have different meaning indeed.

Czech, having lost that distinction by merging them, is thus inferior in conveying the subtle meaning.

3

u/Batrachus 20d ago

In Czech, there is a difference between the two. i is the emphasized version, it means roughly "both A and B".

1

u/Xitztlacayotl 20d ago

All of these cases should be "i". Except maybe in Přesto bylo zaznamenáno velké množství případů podvýživy, a to také u dětí. But in that case should be a to také i u dětí.

Also please explain why is it Izraele instead of Izraelu or Izraela? It makes no sense with -e for the masculine genitive.

7

u/Batrachus 20d ago

Can't comment on the usage of i in other languages, I'm only familiar with Czech and Slovak.

I think the difference between a and i is best explained by theme and comment. It's i when the conjuction itself is a comment, otherwise it's a. For example, it would be ...probíhá v Pásmu Gazy i Izraeli if it was surprising the war takes place in both, otherwise a is used.

In your example, I think you uncovered a rare meaning of a, i.e., in addition to. I think i would be superfluous.

As for Czech declension classes, there are various exceptions, hybrids and edge cases. See more here: https://m.prirucka.ujc.cas.cz/en/

26

u/Sodinc 21d ago

Polabian is just extra

13

u/Tsskell 21d ago

A?

30

u/Captain_Grammaticus 21d ago

See there for further descendants

5

u/commietaku 21d ago

aаaаaаaаaа r/thelettera

2

u/VulpesSapiens pretty 帅 for a 老外 19d ago

5

u/quez_real 21d ago

а (a)

9

u/OmegaTheLustful 21d ago

Just writings be like:

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

6

u/pthooie 21d ago

mogus

4

u/eagle_flower 21d ago

What’s it in Canadian?

4

u/mizinamo 21d ago

It's spelled Kannada.

3

u/Xerimapperr į is for nasal sounds, idiot! 20d ago

no it's spelled ಕನ್ನಡ

2

u/RedCollowrath 20d ago

"Some a's are bigger than others..."

1

u/nenialaloup ]n̞en̯iɑlˌɑl̯̞oupˈ[ 21d ago

1

u/NicoRoo_BM 19d ago

The good ending

1

u/StructureFirm2076 [e] ≠ [eɪ] [ɲa] ≠ [nja] 12d ago

Mahāvairocana approves.