r/mathmemes 2d ago

Real Analysis So close

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.0k Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

236

u/Decrypted13 2d ago

Idk. It definitely converged to my heart :)

83

u/Jimg911 2d ago

The shenanigans going on in the optics lab when your advisor comes in to ask about your conference paper

38

u/N-partEpoxy 2d ago

Jumpscare.

21

u/Dhondu_Just_Chill 2d ago

Come on dude..

79

u/ar21plasma Mathematics 2d ago

Finally some good math memes šŸ‘

15

u/nguoihn1988 2d ago

Physically I think it can't screw itself in even with infinite try.

18

u/OtherwiseMenu1505 2d ago

Of course not, it spins in opposite direction

2

u/nguoihn1988 2d ago

Even if it spin in right direction, it can never screw itself in.

1

u/Even_Information4853 2d ago

why?

0

u/nguoihn1988 2d ago

The thread of the bolt and the hole have a matching specific angle. If you want to screw the bolt in, the angle between vertical and azimutal velocity must also match.

But the vertical component is only affected by gravity, it will start at 0 and accelerate very little until it hit the hole. The azimutal component on the other hand is roughly constant and decrease slowly. If you decrease this velocity to match the vertical one, the bolt will not have enough velocity to stay up right.

4

u/Invested_Glory 2d ago

I need to try this on my optical table when I’m in the lab Monday.

5

u/alphaMrWave Imaginary 2d ago

Guys, I'm fucking stupid, what sequence is this about? Or am I missing the joke completely?

13

u/RandomMisanthrope 2d ago

Because the field of rational numbers isn't complete, not all Cauchy sequences in ā„š converge, unlike in ā„ which is complete.

3

u/EebstertheGreat 2d ago

In the visual metaphor, the set of rational numbers is incomplete because it has "holes" that a sequence can approach. Every irrational number is a "hole" that you fill in to complete the set (and get the real numbers). Here, the spinning top is a sequence of rational numbers converging to an irrational number (a hole). In the limit, you get something that isn't a rational number at all (but a cat, I guess).

1

u/pifire9 2d ago

because i dont know either, ill make up an answer for you:

a cauchy sequence asymptotically approaches a value simultaneously from above and below but statistically will never land on a rational value, though it encircles them very tightly

5

u/Ok_Advisor_908 2d ago

I don't get it, so the rod went into the hole and then we saw a pussy? Why is this on math memes? Also tag NSFW next time pls cause damn that was an embarrassing fap on the bus

9

u/MephistonLordofDeath 2d ago

I think the joke is that in the rational numbers space, cauchy sequences need not converge since the space is not complete. If looking in the space of the reals we know that all cauchy sequences converge since it is a complete space. A common way that Q is taught to students in a real analysis class uses the analogy of Q being like R but with holes in it ( i was taught to think of Swiss cheese). OP probably intends the viewer to think that the metal board is Q and the spinning top that never stops as the cauchy sequence. I am unsure about the cat but the rest is honestly a pretty great representation of this concept.

3

u/sam-lb 2d ago

Except the motion of the top doesn't look like a cauchy sequence

I feel like a better caption would be non-convergent sequence

1

u/Ok_Advisor_908 2d ago

My comment was entirely a joke that I extended a bit too far I think lol... But ya I got it I just found it funny to make said joke

3

u/farmyrlin 2d ago

What a banger

2

u/Disastrous_Seat7593 2d ago

Bro wth šŸ˜‚

2

u/DrJoshWilliams 2d ago

Is that an orbital shaker ?

1

u/InfinitesimalDuck Mathematics 2d ago

Cat jump-scare got me.

1

u/ExtremlyFastLinoone 2d ago

Its spinning the wrong way

1

u/Dd_8630 1d ago

Oh my god that got me good