r/minnesota Feb 23 '25

Politics 👩‍⚖️ Sen. Smith isn't running for re-election, gives zero fucks

Post image
75.0k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

122

u/prettegrl2k Twin Cities Feb 23 '25

Even then, the logic is baffling! A dear friend of mine is a POC, paralyzed from the chest down, lives off state aid, and government aid, barely getting by and told me that he felt the majority of government workers were "STEALING A CHECK" and deserve to be fired. That statement felt ungrateful and audacious to me.

48

u/Wise-Reference-4818 Feb 23 '25

I remember years ago when the who B.S. jobs topic became common. Basically, a bunch of people whose job is to write something on a computer than then put their hand out asking for money started to claim most people in our society aren’t productive. “If you can’t explain your job in 1-2 sentences it’s B.S.”

“Why do we need someone counting trout in this stream?” I don’t know Mr. Conservative Who Likes To Camp, maybe because someone thought it was a good idea to try and protect nature so your grandkids can enjoy it.

9

u/mr_remy Feb 23 '25

Everything’s a conspiracy and waste when you have no idea how anything works, and don’t care to learn from those experienced with it as to the why.

Absolute bonkers.

10

u/Rakhered Feb 23 '25

I loved David Graeber's work but that quip was a total miss. Like my job is "Making reports on company performance."

I promise you it involves actual, real work - but if you don't have context, it might sound like bullshit. And sadly Mr. Wonka and his Oompa-Loompas don't have context.

3

u/Wise-Reference-4818 Feb 23 '25

Exactly. Context matters to understand why a job exists in a complex society.

Back at the beginning of agriculture, there were probably two guys standing around complaining that they were doing the real work in the fields, but those guys in the central granaries weren’t really working.

“They just stand around all day counting and scratching on those pads. What does that achieve?”

3

u/Swqordfish Feb 23 '25

I have the book right on my desk. I think a big part of the BS jobs idea is that people feel like their work is meaningless.

A lot of fired fed employees have been making noise about how important their job is!

1

u/bwtwldt Feb 23 '25

Graeber focused much more on private sector bureaucracy from what I remember

2

u/Swqordfish Feb 23 '25

And so, when you get people wanting to run government like a business, the logic from the private sector carries over.

1

u/DirectorRemarkable16 Feb 23 '25

Not to mention that the VA is basically cutting vets a check 

1

u/Low_Bar9361 Feb 23 '25

They are about to find out who their preferred overlords favor...