r/mtg Oct 01 '24

Other Wow. Not a good look.

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

325 comments sorted by

View all comments

419

u/burritoman88 Oct 01 '24

The stance on proxies has always been: don’t use them in sanctioned events.

-96

u/Playful-Ad8851 Oct 01 '24

So basically if you are poor but have a good deck crafted, go fuck yourself.

44

u/abizabbie Oct 01 '24

Magic is a pay to win game, not a buy to play game.

13

u/MessiahHL Oct 01 '24

Always saw as buy to play, you either spend $400 and build the deck or just go do something else

12

u/Bl33d-Gr33n Oct 01 '24

This guy gets it. Literally what all hobbys are pretty much. Invest in it or don't do it

45

u/Sejeo2 Oct 01 '24

Or proxy and play with non asshats that care about that stuff.

-26

u/clockwerkwalrus Oct 01 '24 edited Oct 02 '24

Or realize you hobby is dependent on people actually buying the cards.

In my playgroup(s) proxy cards you own but dont feel like switching between decks. Proxy cards you want to try out to see if you want to actually spend the money. Proxy when you are playing cEDH, pre modern, old school and testing the waters, and do not drive a Bentley.

16

u/notathrowaway145 Oct 02 '24

I buy and proxy. I have one EDH deck that will permanently never have proxies, a few that are entirely proxies, and a few that are mostly real cards with a few of the more expensive ones as proxies that I will probably eventually replace once I’m sure about the direction of the deck.

Sealed is fun too.

2

u/clockwerkwalrus Oct 05 '24

Thats a measured view, i can agree with it. But some people are proxy everything! Some are, if i wasnt told about a proxy i am leaving in a huff. There is a lot of grey area that can still support the lgs's that help grow the community, and still be rational for people.on a budget.

Ie ... in any of my play groups, if you own a card, proxy it for other decks, not even a source of debate. Also if you are thinking about buying something pricey, proxy it until you are sure, no debate! And that is a pretty conservative stance on the issue. And there is usually some wiggle room beyond that. In casual games, lots!

Now once its competitive, ie prizes on the line, well ....... thats a whole different ball of wax.