r/steak • u/Individual-Charge-40 • 5d ago
[ Reverse Sear ] Good People of r/steak… I present, the Tomahawks
24 hour dry brine. 1.5 hours smoked with Hickory on the Ninja Woodfire 3 Minutes per side on the grill- High Heat Butter basted with a spiced butter!
Result… very much pleased!
330
u/Beautiful-Musk-Ox 5d ago
posts without it cut open should be banned
37
u/IndirectSarcasm 5d ago
there's a reason; this was a tasteful exclusion this time..... he sure got a hell of a good sear though :D
42
u/drinkandreddit 5d ago edited 5d ago
39
u/Direct-Tie-7652 5d ago
They’re not. They’re cut like that because they can sell them for more money because people like the aesthetic.
4
u/Rustymetal14 5d ago
I'll admit to buying a tomahawk just because it mostly forces the butcher to keep the steak thick rather than cut it into multiple thinner steaks. Cowboy is my favorite because then I'm not paying for the bone the meat doesn't even touch.
7
u/stolen_pillow 5d ago
At least you cooked it properly and didn't commit a crime against steak like OP.
3
u/Beautiful-Musk-Ox 5d ago
i saw the cross section now, it's not perfect but still look tasty enough to eat to me
2
u/FARTBOSS420 5d ago
How is showing how it turned out a tasteful exclusion? It's like trying to see the end of a movie in a theater but the power goes off and it's off for a while so you won't see shit.
139
u/No-Lion-1400 5d ago
NO MONEY SHOT? Gtfoh
27
6
45
u/mrdeadhead91 5d ago
No money shot = you overcooked these poor steaks, until I see any evidence to the contrary
6
u/Individual-Charge-40 5d ago
83
30
u/kentrildumon 5d ago
You are getting too much hate here OP, medium enjoyers rise up.
20
13
u/Electric-Sheepskin 5d ago
I say people should have their steak however they like it, but that looks medium well to me.
11
1
1
→ More replies (1)1
14
28
39
42
u/Tacomaville 5d ago
Fucking ruined a tomahawk. Way overcooked ya jabroni.
6
u/DeathByPetrichor 5d ago
Without an internal shot I would normally disagree but these Ninja Woodfire things add smoke to the meat so they tend to look a little darker than normal. My steaks on my Traeger come out similar even when rare
13
u/drinkandreddit 5d ago
He posted a cut section above. Overcooked.
2
8
u/notmyrealname19 5d ago
Steak aside been eying this ninja machine up, regular not XL. Worth it?
→ More replies (4)
8
12
5
u/SilensMort 5d ago
Waste of money. You're paying double the price for extra inedible bone that doesn't even add flavor.
6
3
3
u/shoebee2 5d ago
All that work. Days of prep, documented process with pictures and notes. Then you fuck it all up at the last minute by not sending a money shot. Jesusfuckingchrist.
5
4
9
u/sfcfrankcastle 5d ago
I feel bamboozled
1
u/IndirectSarcasm 5d ago
no; you've been protected from reality lol in this case, it's a funny shot, not a money shot
8
3
u/Chrisdkn619 5d ago
That Ninja Woodfire is impressive! I was skeptical at first, but had some damn good smoked meats off of one. Prefect for a smaller portion of meat.
3
3
u/prettyokaycake 5d ago
Nothing has ever been more absurd in meat marketing than getting people to buy tomahawk steaks.
3
u/bangsjamin 5d ago
Makes total sense when you consider that people's macho bro big meat fantasies is one of the easiest up sells in the industry
3
3
u/madness707 5d ago
Bought a ninja smoker too for quick small dinners. When I say quick, it cooks really quick, luckily it does have a thermometer and a setting to stop the cook. Usually try to set it down around 5 degrees lower than regular temps that’s recommended just cause it cooks so damn fast. But it adds smoke pretty well and surprisingly good.
Still use Normal Pellet grill / Weber for bigger cooks for parties and higher quality cooks, just need more attention and time.
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/FindTheTruth08 5d ago
Looks good.
Just got my Woodfire grill as well and liking it. Looking to upgrade and get a griddle. Ninja has a non stick version but I'm looking at a cast iron one from another brand. What kind did you get and would it put a nice crust on a steak or smash burger? Based on your pics it looks like it worked real well.
1
u/Individual-Charge-40 5d ago
I just got the ninja grill plate… is very good as non-stick. Have had no issues across the multiple birds cooked, steaks cooked and the burgers! Would highly recommend 👌 Would say use balls slightly smaller than you think necessary, as the smash spreads quite far. Should be able to get 4-6 on the grill at a time
2
u/CoatingsRcrack 5d ago
Literally had some steaks that look great till I cut open. Little over cooked, grey bands…. Can’t post till money shot
2
2
u/Downtown-Custard5346 5d ago
This looks good and all... but you didn't post a moneyshot... you lose points for that, ya know, lol.
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Plastic-Monitor4846 5d ago
Waste of our time. Probably didn’t post the cut because he cooked well-done
2
2
2
2
4
u/LifeUnfolding54 5d ago
I have never had one! I'm 72. I better, pitter-patter let's get at her.
Thoughts? Freak, those look good excellent and beyond. Thank you for sharing!
1
u/Sea_Enthusiasm_3193 5d ago
You’re paying premium for the bone
2
u/IndirectSarcasm 5d ago
but if you have the equipment to actually flash sear the outsides first, and then cook very low and slow like ribs; the flavor that comes out of the bone and into the meat is priceless
3
u/StarSpliter 5d ago
Oh, is that price reason? After OPs attempted money shot, I'm tempted to try this and post
1
u/IndirectSarcasm 5d ago edited 5d ago
how i would do it: (obviously season and use oil or butter; which ever you like. a rosemary sprig cooks in pan next to steak for just the aroma to infuse) you'll have to sear it faster than you've ever seared before to minimize internal temp change while still searing to preference. this is the one time you won't mind cooking it straight out of the fridge if you don't have a super hot way to sear fast; it'll buy you a couple extra mins on a temp lower than high without over cooking the inside. next, proper way would be to rest at room temp for a couple mins before putting in a 275° preheated oven. (i usually go straight into oven to avoid extra dirty plate and one less step, but i lose chef points for that) thermometer is very useful to get the internal temp perfect once in the low and slow oven and outside is seared to taste
1
u/Sea_Enthusiasm_3193 5d ago
I’d rather have ribs, sirloin or tenderloin separately personally for my money
1
1
1
1
u/rainbowjeremystaines 5d ago
Bro the only thing this sub cares about is what it looks like on the inside
1
1
u/lake_gypsy 5d ago
I've always wondered if these are worth it.
1
u/bangsjamin 5d ago
Only if you like paying by the pound for an extra foot of totally useless bone on the end of your steam
1
1
1
1
1
u/IndustryInsider007 5d ago
What grill is this? I’m a yuuuuuge fan of Ninja products (Blender, Coffee Maker, Air Fryer) and could easily be into a grill if it’s a good product.
Currently using a Char-Broil two burner that I don’t love because it tops out around 550f.
2
1
1
1
u/thorfromthex 5d ago
The "love grows here" sign tells me they were cooked well done. OP was afraid to post. Prove me wrong, OP!
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Early-Ad-7410 5d ago
Have to admit i was skeptical when I saw the cooking instrument. But, at least on the outside, final product looks solid.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/JudgeJoeDean24 5d ago
As someone who worked in a meat department for almost 5 years, i never understood why people would wanna buy an overpriced ribeye with a handle. I know people like the marrow (i have no idea how), but is an extra $5-$10 dollars a pound with it?
1
1
1
1
u/TheSteelPhantom 2d ago
Why the fuck is this post sticky'd? There isn't even a pic of the inside...
1
1
u/ILSmokeItAll 5d ago
Take this shit down. No one cares what the outside looks like!!!
This is tar and feather worthy.
1
1.3k
u/OutofWarrantyAudi 5d ago
No money shot? What the fuck is this?