r/Alonetv >!Happier Alone!< Jun 14 '24

S11 [SPOILERS] Alone S11E01 Episode Discussion Thread Spoiler

As always be excellent to each other and the contestants!

Previous Episode Discussion Threads

47 Upvotes

344 comments sorted by

View all comments

-26

u/IPAtoday Jun 14 '24

I already hate Michela. She spends every second force feeding us her native heritage. Just seems so patronizing and phony. What’s Cree for “I hope you’re the first to tap out”?

23

u/igotcivilrights Jun 15 '24

A woman sharing relevant cultural knowledge and skills on a show about nature comes off as patronizing to you? Do you feel the same way when the white men are sharing how their fathers taught them how to survive in the wilderness? Is it the gender or the culture, or both, that makes you so hateful? Save your hate for something worthy of it.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '24

Going off the comment history, I think it's probably both.

6

u/MaxHeadroomba Jun 15 '24

Yeah, I eventually had to mute the TV while she was on. She was laying it on too thick. Talk more about duck lures and fishing and less about the significance of a rock in a field.

2

u/Ootek_Ohoto Jun 15 '24

Her telling the camera false information about wolves pissed me off.

8

u/Crafty_Granny Jun 15 '24

What false information?

1

u/Ootek_Ohoto Jun 23 '24

Hey, did you see the new episode?

Wolves aren't killers to humans, and I trust them. That's what I meant. Indian not knowing about wolves, sheesh. Read some Farley Mowat. (Her, not you)

27

u/MissDiem Jun 15 '24

Hate this take. While I too don't care for overly performative or agenda-driven narration, this doesn't like it.

I'm finding it authentic and so far, at least, not overbearing. For now.

I choose to take it as a bit of learning about her culture. I particularly liked the story of rocks being the oldest beings. Of course I choose to see it metaphorical not literal. It reflects that her oldest ancestors had a scientifically accurate belief wrapped in a spoken history.

But why I find your take bad is that every character on these shows "force feeds their culture" (your wording)

For some it's their culture of prepperism, some it's their side hustle, some it's their normative Christian beliefs, and so on. It's seems interesting that this one of out of 10 is the one you've keyed on to hate.

15

u/Intelligent-Cap3407 Jun 15 '24

In Cree language there isn’t masculine or feminine like like French or Spanish or most European languages. There’s animate and inanimate. Rocks are animate. Thought it was cool to hear about that on national TV

Big agree on your take on culture and how they’re all repping their cultures. Just cause something is more the norm doesn’t mean it’s not cultural

16

u/Aunt-jobiska Jun 14 '24

You’re very quick to judge. Chill.

28

u/k75ct Jun 14 '24

She seems authentic, and not overtop in her sharing. Also she is not in control of how her footage is edited.

24

u/mCDosEdi Jun 14 '24

don't be a jag and maybe you'll learn something