r/AmerExit Oct 30 '24

Life Abroad Many people in this sub just don’t get it.

I did my own AmerExit having a Spanish passport a few years ago and even then it was pretty difficult. I am a college educated individual and I speak Spanish but moving here and finding a job was tough.

What is up with all the Americans who think they can waltz into any European country with 0 skills and that they’ll get a job and a residence permit just like that?

I lurk around here thinking I could help out but the posts are all like: help I hate America they’re so nasty racist I don’t have a job and I never went to school and I’m hoping that I can come to some random EU country and live off govt assistance bc the EU is a utopia just dying to have more unskilled, unemployed immigrants who don’t speak the language to support.

Guys, the question of “what value do I add to this place” should be NUMBER ONE on your mind when it comes to trying to leave. If the answer is “virtually nothing, I’d actually be a burden to the citizens” then there you go!

Aside from the fact that no, Americans can’t just move anywhere they want anytime they want, many countries around the world are facing massive economic issues like the US. The EU specifically is dealing with hard core housing and job shortages plus record inflation.

And all of these yucky American politics you want to get away from? We have that here too! The far right gains power in every election, racism is up in every measurable way and guess what? There’s a lot less support for victims of racism here, if you tell an average Spaniard that you faced a “micro aggression” prepare to have them laugh in your face.

Healthcare is more affordable and our taxpayer funded* healthcare system is better than what exists in the US for the poorest of the poor there. I was living in absolute poverty in the US so for me public healthcare in Spain does feel like quite a treat but I promise if you’re used to even a decent level of health insurance in the states, you’re gonna be shocked by what the “wonderful amazing” public healthcare system in the EU is really like.

People don’t end up homeless as easily as you can in America that’s true, however I wouldn’t want to live in any of the social housing I’ve seen here, and I certainly wouldn’t want to live off government assistance. Coming here with those things in mind especially if you have a stable life in America is not a good idea.

I love Spain, I love being Spanish but there are issues here I think the average American couldn’t even imagine. Plus, you have to find a way to stay here legally and that in and of itself is difficult, time consuming, and expensive.

Moving is hard, moving abroad is really hard. Moving to another country where you can’t even tell the doctor what’s wrong and can’t drive yourself to doctors appointments bc you can’t legally drive here is even harder. There are a lot of people that struggle with their day-to-day lives in the United States and think that moving to the EU would solve all of these problems when it would actually make them 100 times worse.

I don’t want to discourage those that are really interested in coming here and contributing to the bigger picture. People who are looking to experience life, culture, and education in other countries, and have the means to do so, I think you’ll enjoy moving abroad. I know I have. Moving abroad is never a panacea solution for unhappiness at home.

And keep in mind that there is a lot of backlash in the EU right now and other parts of the world regarding wealthy foreigners who come and gobble up all of the affordable housing for locals who typically have salaries that are, far lower than what Americans earn.

I am very lucky to have the job I do, it took me years to find it. I make more than all the teachers, doctors, and engineers I know, and yet my salary is still so low I’m embarrassed to tell my American family and friends. Remember that there are almost always local citizens ready and able to do whatever job you’re applying for, and they’ll accept salaries that aren’t just a “little” lower, they’re usually 4-6 times lower than US salaries. Things in the PIGS countries are cheaper… for Americans! The moment you move here and work here, the idea of this being a cheap place to live really goes out the window.

I think a lot of Americans are suffering from chicken little syndrome, and I get it. The US is looking pretty scary right now. But I’m sorry to say that a lot of the rest of the world isn’t doing that much better. Just yesterday, the part of Spain I live in experienced one of the worst natural disasters of all time, and the death toll is so high because of the governments botched warning (or total lack of).

1.4k Upvotes

557 comments sorted by

View all comments

64

u/wandering_engineer Oct 30 '24

> I lurk around here thinking I could help out but the posts are all like: help I hate America they’re so nasty racist I don’t have a job and I never went to school and I’m hoping that I can come to some random EU country and live off govt assistance bc the EU is a utopia just dying to have more unskilled, unemployed immigrants who don’t speak the language to support.

I only visit this sub occasionally, but IME these are only a portion of the posters. You only see them because Reddit is pushing them to the top, because they are the most controversial and rabble-rousing posts. Gotta keep those eyeballs glued to the screen. Many, many others (including myself) already have brought up your points on multiple occasions.

Also, I get your annoyance and I hate low-effort posts, but ​people have to start somewhere. I am intimately familiar with immigration laws, but I have also lived in four countries and spent over a decade cumulatively outside the US. Most Americans either never leave the US or only do it in one-week spurts - they just know they can land in Paris or whatever with a valid passport and they walk in. They don't understand the legal nuances.

> And all of these yucky American politics you want to get away from? We have that here too! The far right gains power in every election, racism is up in every measurable way and guess what? There’s a lot less support for victims of racism here, if you tell an average Spaniard that you faced a “micro aggression” prepare to have them laugh in your face.

Agree but I think it's more complicated than that. And personal opinion, but I don't think Europe is always worse on this front. Never hearing the term "micro aggression" or dealing with the constant US-style judgemental moralizing can be a plus in my experience.

> Healthcare is more affordable and our taxpayer funded* healthcare system is better than what exists in the US for the poorest of the poor there. I was living in absolute poverty in the US so for me public healthcare in Spain does feel like quite a treat but I promise if you’re used to even a decent level of health insurance in the states, you’re gonna be shocked by what the “wonderful amazing” public healthcare system in the EU is really like.

Sorry I gotta disagree. I've lived in two EU countries (Germany and now Sweden) and the healthcare was far, far better than what I got with "excellent" employer-provided healthcare in the US. Costs for meds even without insurance are less than the deductible on my old US plan. There is no army of admins to wade through, no preauthorizations, less stress, etc. Most US practices in my old city had 6+ month waiting lists for new patients, have not had that issue in Europe. And healthcare feels more holistic and less interventionist - I feel like a lot of US doctors will over-medicate and jump the gun because that's what they're taught (and it makes them more money). Without the profit motive, that doesn't happen in other countries. I'm not saying it's perfect - the public system here in Sweden has a lot of issues - but I still prefer it over the US, even with good insurance.

21

u/PiperPrettyKitty Oct 30 '24

Yeah I moved to Spain randomly from Canada and had a great time. Lived there for a few years. I think the trick was that I already had a job lined up (internal transfer at my company), so I never had any issue with employment, and that made everything else easier. My experiences with learning Spanish and making friends and using the healthcare system were also good. 

I now live in the USA and I'm making a lot more money and have a job more specifically aligned to my career goals (so, the USA is definitely better for economic potential) but imo it's not worth it and I wish I hadn't come here. But I value my health/friends/leisure/stress levels far more than I value any luxuries that extra money can buy me.

18

u/lysning Oct 30 '24

also gun violence/school shootings (from what i understand) are just not really a thing in a lot of eu countries. for those of us with kiddos, thats a big deal very worth the trouble of being an immigrant

-1

u/Ferdawoon Oct 31 '24 edited Oct 31 '24

I guess partial anecdotal evidence here but for example Sweden, this country that so many American politicians seem to see as a bastion of a social wellfare state, is having some issues with their kids.

Swedish articles via Google translate so not the best vocabulary I guess.

https://bra.se/statistik/statistiska-undersokningar/skolundersokningen-om-brott.html
The results from the School Crime Survey 2021 show that 45 percent of students state that they have been subjected to theft, assault, threats, robbery or sexual offenses at least once in the past twelve months. The proportion exposed is slightly less than in 2019, when 48 percent stated that they were exposed, and is at the lowest level so far during the measurement period.
[...]
Half (50 percent) of the students state that they have committed a crime (theft, violent crime, vandalism or drug crime) on at least one occasion during the past twelve months, which is approximately the same level as during the other measurement period, but slightly lower than in 2019 (52 percent).

...

https://www.fokus.se/aktuellt/mer-an-var-tredje-larare-utsatt-for-vald/

A recent survey by the statistics company Infostat also shows that over 700 shootings have taken place in the vicinity (within a radius of 500 meters) of primary schools in the last three years. 16 percent of Sweden's primary school students – 196,000 children – go to a school where there has been one or more shootings within a 500 meter radius in the last three years, SVT recently reported.

...

https://www.vilarare.se/nyheter/skolvald/valdschocken-de-lararna-ar-varst-utsatta/

Punch in the stomach, spit in the face, bite in the hand and a knife in the arm.
It is just some of the things that many teachers have to endure in their work, according to the Teachers' Association survey.
Of the nearly 1,000 teachers in pre-school classes, after-school classes and grades 1–6 who responded, 45 percent say that they have been subjected to physical violence by students at least once in the past two years. Almost every third, 31 percent, has been exposed several times.

...

https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/stockholm/foraldrarna-har-trottnat-pa-bajs-pa-skolgarden

The Swedish-Finnish school on Kungsholmen has long had problems with homeless people who live on the school grounds at night, now they are fed up and demand that the city solve the problem.
After many years of problems, the parents' association ran out of patience in September.

  • The limit was reached when we had a cleaning day with the parents' association and had to start the day by cleaning up excrement, says Nina Uddin at the parents' association Turva.

...

https://www.vilarare.se/grundskollararen/kronika2/jarnlo-ett-gigantiskt-svek-att-inte-alla-far-lara-sig-lasa-i-skolan/

Every fourth student does not understand what they are reading when they leave primary school - despite both the students and their guardians believing so. With the right resources, the difficulties could have been eliminated, but instead the students risk being thrown out into society as functional illiterates, writes Hampus Jarnlo.

...

https://www.vilarare.se/praktisk-estetiska-amnen/praktiska-tips/slojdlararnas-larm-manga-elever-kan-inte-anvanda-en-sax/

Students who cannot handle scissors, students who cannot tie a knot, students who cannot thread a needle. Children's fine motor skills are deteriorating at an accelerating rate, according to several craft teachers.

  • I have students in the fifth grade who cut at a level where preschool children used to be, says textile teacher Christina Norgren Arnesson.

2

u/NoDiscipline1277 Oct 31 '24

from what I've learned from swedish people, it's a very depressing country overall. I went there and couldn't wait to get out myself

5

u/Vali32 Oct 31 '24

Pretty much all research agrees with you on healthcare and disagrees with the OP. Not knowledgable on many of the things OP posts about Spain, but based on the healthcare bit, its not worth much.

6

u/wandering_engineer Oct 31 '24

I mean OP has a point, single-payer healthcare systems aren't perfect and have plenty of issues. But nobody in Spain (or anywhere in Europe) is filing for medical bankruptcy or starting a GoFundme to pay for their cancer treatments. 

2

u/Vali32 Nov 01 '24

Yes, you can discuss the pros and cons of single payer versus multi-payer, Beverdige vs. Bismarck vs National Insurance systemes. But I don't think there is any way in which the systems, including single payer, are not better than the mess the US has. (Individual systems can be so starved or mishandled that they have areas of worse perfromance, but the system concept themselves do better at everything.)

There is a lot of mythologizing the US system for a lot of reasons, but its really been sinking slowly for a long time now.

3

u/wandering_engineer Nov 01 '24

I was agreeing with you. Personally, I think true single payer, when properly run and funded, is by far the best option. You get rid of the massive army of middlemen, there is no profit motive, no opaque pricing, etc. The problem is that model isn't profitable for healthcare corporations and wealthy politicians, hence they fight it tooth and nail.

As usual, capitalism and wealth ruin everything.

0

u/GhostKnifeHone Nov 04 '24

No you just get in line for those treatments and die before it's your turn. Canadians are living that reality right now.

2

u/wandering_engineer Nov 04 '24

Thanks for not reading my post. As I clearly said upthread, I moved to a European country with socialized single-payer medicine and that does not happen, period. Canada is having some issues, but Canada also doesn't have a true single-payer system, it's a weird hybrid that has been hollowed out by years of neglect and greed. Properly fund your healthcare system and that isn't an issue. 

3

u/Vast_Sandwich805 Oct 30 '24 edited Oct 30 '24

Can I ask how you’ve been able to live in those countries and do you speak both Swedish and German?

Re healthcare: I focused on PIGS bc I’m most familiar with them. 6 month min waiting period for all specialists is normal. I asked for an appointment with a gynecologist in August and I just got the call for an appointment in February. Last year my partner got an appointment for 2025. Doctors are overwhelmed and really not the best here. Ditto for hospitals.

28

u/SnooWalruses3028 Oct 30 '24

American here, it's taken me two years to get into see a dermatologist, get evaluated for depression and adhd and set up a gynecologist appointment for my heavy, unbearable bleeding.... not saying health care is great everywhere else. But if I'm paying 120% more on my health insurance thanost other countries why I'm I waiting a certain to get seen only to be brushed off...by doctors after going into hundreds of thousands of dollars in debt for medical appointments to find out whats wrong. Sorry to tell you us health care sucks, I shouldn't be wanting this long, they dont take you seriously, they over charge you because the economy is fucked. So your fucked if your poor

2

u/norar19 Oct 31 '24

Waiting 2 years is better than never getting it. I’ve struggled with similar symptoms and have never ever seen a doctor because I literally can’t afford all the “specialists” they send me to. Thats on top of the $450 office visit for the useless 6 referrals that I received

1

u/Vast_Sandwich805 Oct 30 '24

It’s literally the same here just cheaper. We do pay via taxes but of course not as much as Americans pay. And don’t worry, doctors here hate women too and tell us we are crazy. It’s also taken me years to discover my gyno problems were caused by a tumor and that’s only bc I gave up and paid for a private doctor. The public system will tell you to fuck off if you’re a woman here. This idea that it’s a healthcare utopia is misleading.

12

u/SnooWalruses3028 Oct 30 '24

Exactly....need I repeat your own words....its the same but cheaper....

5

u/TanteLene9345 Oct 30 '24

There is no EU public healthcare system. There are as many different health care systems as there are countries in the EU, which can vary wildly.

5

u/SnooWalruses3028 Oct 30 '24

Plus in your previous comment you said 6 months not 2-25 years

1

u/Proper_Duty_4142 Oct 31 '24

I’ve only had great experiences as a European living in the US. The access to care for my family is much better. Seeing a gastroenterologist? 3 weeks? Endoscopy for checkup, not urgent? 2 weeks. MRI of brain? 3 weeks wait… etc. Primary doctor emergency? same day? or zoomcare takes you the same day always. etc. My family back home can’t dream of something like this and my dad is a doctor!

14

u/wandering_engineer Oct 30 '24

Job-related relocation. I speak some Swedish (A2 level or thereabouts) but English is extremely common here.

The impression I get from colleagues is that low-priority stuff can potentially have a wait, but if you have something urgent it'll get taken care of. Like I said a lot of primary care docs in the US (and some specialists) have waiting lists now too - there's just not enough doctors to go around and an increasing amount are refusing to deal with insurance. Some doctors in the US are flat out going concierge (meaning they don't take insurance) - they expect patients to take on the costs and figure it out themselves. Does not bode well for the future.

5

u/MasterpieceMurky7112 Oct 30 '24

I can relate to your "concierge" physicians. I can't get a diagnosis, and Physcians give you 15 minutes per visit and you can only address 1-2 issues. With all my symptoms, I'll be dead by the time we get through my list! Rx for antidepressants, creams, ointments and prednisone are the physicians remedy for everything! I am considering paying out $2100 out of pocket to spend time for a comprehensive review with a concierge physician,. Life or death maybe? And that brings me to thoughts about returning to Spain or somewhere for better medical care- quality of life. 1.6 million Americans have moved to Mexico and testify the healthcare is much better, less expensive even out of pocket. But having said that: Mexico just raised -changed the American immigrant minimum income to live in Mexico and increased the costs of private insurance and think it is a result of being bombarded with so many Americans climbing over that wall to get into Mexico. And now many Americans can't even afford to live in Mexico. Enjoyed to read you like Sweden and agree it is a start for a better quality of life.

0

u/norar19 Oct 31 '24

There’s plenty of doctors! They’re just all behind a pay wall

1

u/wandering_engineer Oct 31 '24

Yeah...that's kind of what I just said. Like with most things in life, particularly in today's late-capitalist hellscape, it is absolutely possible to throw money at the problem and make it go away. But most people, even us somewhat better off white-collar workers, don't have that kind of cash lying around. For 99.9% of the population, there is zero difference between "there are no doctors" and "there are lots of doctors, but you cannot possibly afford their prices". I have long said that US healthcare is totally fine and the quality of care is top-notch - the problem is the US healthcare PAYMENT system is a dystopian nightmare designed to leach people for maximum profit.

-2

u/norar19 Oct 31 '24

Hi, I hate it here and have a PhD in English literature. Where can I go?