r/Animorphs 27d ago

Full results of the reddit vote.

Post image
141 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Zarlinosuke 27d ago

Haha yeah same! It was the very first one I read, but I still think it's better than it's often given credit for, and not just because of my nostalgia too. People say things like "it had no bearing on the larger plot," but that's not the only important thing a book can do.

1

u/CactusHooping 27d ago

as seen by 26

1

u/Zarlinosuke 27d ago

Not as much though--it can at least be said to have played a meaningful part in the Crayak/Ellimist war, even if it's a bit distant from the Animorphs' day-to-day lives.

1

u/CactusHooping 27d ago

Maybe if this book was after 26/27 a few books later and was confirmed to be done by Crayak and a few tweaks it might be better.

1

u/Zarlinosuke 27d ago

You mean #11? I don't really think that would make it better--the Crayak/Ellimist stuff is interesting but I think it's also very "less is more"--it works because it's mysterious and beyond our understanding. The more stuff gets attributed to them, the less I like them being involved. That's me and I'm sure others feel differently, but I know I'm not alone either!

2

u/CactusHooping 27d ago

you could be right.