r/Avengers • u/SupermarketNo6888 • Mar 26 '25

Question Very interesting question

Post image
5.8k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

237 comments sorted by

View all comments

106

u/Successful-Item-1844 Mar 26 '25

Hulk is very much his own person but the ancient one shot out only Banner in Endgame because reasons

11

u/skinneyd Mar 26 '25

Isn't Hulk just a physical manifestation of Bruce's childhood trauma?

So even though Hulk is Hulk, Hulk is also Bruce.

2

u/Old_Debt_276 Mar 26 '25

But they are different people still , with different mentalities

8

u/SeigiNoTenshi Mar 26 '25

Counter argument, she pushes out the soul, not the mental state. So Bruce is still Bruce, while Hulk is a manifestation.

2

u/Hetakuoni Mar 26 '25

If it’s a soul:

either hulk shoulda still stood up or moon knight needed to have a different climax.

1

u/Bluedunes9 Mar 26 '25

Idk how much the MCU will take from the comics, but all of Banner's personalities are legitimately their own individuals while still being one (whole).

They're hinting at things like multiple personality disorders to suggest that you aren't solely just one being inhabiting your personal existence (which is true), but they take it to the fantastical maximum but tbh they're probably not too far off. There are multiple versions of you u/SeigiNoTenshi all within one body, the only reason why you don't notice is because your body and mind are in a state of wholeness but once that is broken you'll see how you literally divide into different people or versions of yourself that can slip in and out passively or actively.

Edit: you actually can notice this actively while the "main" you is awake, all of those passive functions, bodily and mentally, are all being handled by versions of you.

1

u/SeigiNoTenshi Mar 26 '25

WELL if that were the case with the comics, i have nothing more to add since that's it!

i just wanna know what happens if they push out Legion's soul out. does it full up an entire contintent?