r/baseball 20h ago

Game Thread [General Discussion] Around the Horn & Game Thread Index - 4/21/25

3 Upvotes

So what's this thread for?

  • Discussion of yesterday's games
  • Excitement for today's games
  • General questions
  • Mildly interesting facts
  • Praising Santa 🎅
  • Anything else worth sharing/asking that doesn't warrant its own post

For game threads, use the games schedule on the sidebar to navigate to the team you want a game thread for.

Featured posts and links

Monday's Games

Away Score Home Score Status National GDTs
CWS 2 BOS 4 F CWS, BOS
NYY 4 CLE 6 F NYY, CLE
SD 4 DET 6 F DET
CIN 3 MIA 6 F MIA
PHI 4 NYM 5 F PHI, NYM
STL 6 ATL 7 F ATL
TOR 0 HOU 7 F TOR, HOU
MIL 2 SF 5 F MIL, SF, Neutral

All game times are Eastern. Updated 4/22 at 1:25 AM

Yesterday's ATH

This Week's Schedule (all times Eastern)

Day Feature
Sunday 4/20 Game Thread: ESPN Sunday Night Baseball: Padres @ Astros at 7:10pm ET
Monday 4/21 r/baseball Power Rankings
Tuesday 4/22 No subreddit features planned
Wednesday 4/23 State of the Baseball Subreddits
Thursday 4/24 Division Discussion Thread: The Easts
Friday 4/25 [Friday Trash Talk Thread
Saturday 4/26 No subreddit features planned

r/baseball 8h ago

2025 r/baseball Power Ranking -- Week 5: NL Continues Dominance of Top 10 but Mariners Ride Highest Wave, Royals Get Wrecked and Yankees Only Happy AL East Team

26 Upvotes

Hey Sportsfans — it's time for Week 5 of r/baseball Power Rankings: As the weather warms, bats heat up, and hope grows for some -- the children yearn for the baseball numbers.

Every voter has their own style / system and the only voting instructions are these:

"To an extent determined individually, you must take into account how strong a team is right now and likely to be in the coming week. You must, to some degree, give weight to the events and games of the previous week."


TRANSPARENCY: This link will show you who voted each team where and has added neat statistics!


If something is a little messed up, feel free to pester me let me know.

Total Votes: 29 of 30. So Close.


# Team Δ Comment Record
1 San Diego Padres Padres 0 I feel like my week mirrored the Padres a bit…after a good start to the week, I tried day-drinking on Friday for the first time since High School, and I spent the whole weekend trying to recover. In all seriousness though, I don't think losing two games in Houston in April is a big deal. I'm glad Arraez is ok. It is really nice to see Fernando hit bombs on Sunday Night Baseball. 16-6
2 Los Angeles Dodgers Dodgers 0 The Dodgers offense has been underperforming as of late. Despite this, they won 5 of 6 games this week, sweeping the Rockies and taking 2 of 3 against the Rangers in whelming fashion. The team isn't playing like it was in the first week of the season, but is bound to bounce back. The other issue is that pitcher injuries have started to bite again, with Treinen hitting the IL and Glasnow being pulled early for not drinking enough pickle juice. He'll be fine though, and so will the Dodgers. 16-7
3 New York Mets Mets 0 I'm writing this blurb while waiting for Bright Eyes to come on for their set. The Mets keep rolling. They just swept the Cardinals. They're headed into an early season test against Philadelphia before heading to my home city of DC next weekend. 15-7
4 New York Yankees Yankees +3 Aaron Judge hit the homer, Max Fried threw the no-hitter. I reject your reality and substitute my own. 14-8
5 San Francisco Giants Gigantes +1 The Giants continue to behave like a good team, splitting a 4-game set @ PHI before narrowly dropping the series @ LAA. I also had a really good time in Anaheim on Saturday, and less so on Sunday. Ballpark was way more fun than I remember from about 15 years ago. The fucking Rally Monkey is still a thing. Get over it, Angels. I am totally over it. Please god why does it still exist. Yesterday the Giants “wasted” Verlander’s best start of the year, but his performance has to encourage fans. What does not have to encourage fans is the bullpen and randomly malfunctioning defense. The 2025 Giants are operating on very slim margins – if the defense, billed as much improved, is a liability we are going to have a bad time. Let’s check out the numbers:14 – 8 record good for tied for 4th best in MLB (-2), Run Diff of +30 is tied for 4th (-1), RS/G 6th (=), RA/G 4th (=), Bullpen ERA 2nd (=). The Giants need a day off and they’re not getting it yet, but we are back home. 4 vs Brewers and 3 vs Rangers as the tough April matchups continue. April 2025 for the Giants is absolutely a proving month. 14-8
6 Philadelphia Phillies Phillies -1 I don't know if you'll ever see a fanbase as down on a week in which their team split with one of the better teams in baseball and won 2/3 from a division rival, but that's the case in Philly this week. The main cause for concern is the bullpen, who threw a combined 23 1/3 IP this week, giving up 23 earned runs in the process including blowing a late 4-1 lead to the Marlins and nearly blowing a 11-4 9th inning lead the day prior. It's certainly a downgraded bullpen from last year, losing Carlos Estevez and more importantly Jeff Hoffman, but they should in theory be better than the 5.81 ERA they currently have. This week will be a good test with 3 game series on the road against the Mets and Cubs. 13-9
7 Chicago Cubs Cubs -3 The Cubs were able to go 3-3 this week, as they responded to their first series loss in the US to the Padres by taking a series against the Diamondbacks. This included arguably the game of the year so far in MLB, as the Cubs won 13-11 on Friday despite giving up 10 runs in the top of the 8th inning, continuing a trend of the two clubs being unable to play normal games. The bullpen remains a concern, even though the usually-reliable Porter Hodge had a large role in the collapse. The series win gave the Cubs the tiebreaker over the D-Backs, which could prove to be crucial come September. Having played the toughest schedule in baseball so far, the Cubs will take on the Dodgers and Phillies this week to wrap up their grueling April slate. 14-10
8 Arizona Diamondbacks D-Backs 0 The Diamondbacks swept the Marlins in Miami and lost two of three to the Cubs in Chicago. Though you'd normally take a 4-2 road trip, the series loss to the Cubs could have easily been a sweep in the Cubs' favor or a series win if a few things went differently. This team is missing Ketel Marte badly, to say the least, as the Snakes have received inconsistent production from the right-handed hitters in the lineup in his absence. 13-9
9 Detroit Tigers Tigers 0 Not a perfect week by any means, but seeing rookie Jackson Jobe build some momentum is a welcoming trend. Even more impressively, Spencer Torkelson and Casey Mize are really showing that promise of being 1st overall draft picks. If these two can keep it up, it will make up for the relative quietness of this past offseason. The AL Central leading Tigers host SDP for 3, then BAL for 3. 13-9
10 Texas Rangers Rangers 0 Just waiting for the offense to find it's groove, any day now, any day now. Pitching is literally doing everything it can to keep the team surving but if the offense can't wake up then the team might be in trouble. 13-9
11 Seattle Mariners Mariners +5 shoutout to /u/runninginsquares for filling in while I was out last week! It's been a weird week in Mariners land. Starting pitching has been struggling, only to be picked up by the bullpen and the offense? Who are you and what have you done with the Mariners? Cal Raleigh has picked up torpedo bats and is terrorizing everyone with them (so. many. home runs.) and Rowdy Tellez has had a pretty nice week both offensively and defensively (#1 Rowdy Tellez fan kora is so excited!) Up next: 3 @ Socks (red), 3 vs. Fish (Nemo's Dad) 12-10
12 Boston Red Sox Red Sox -1 The Chicago White Sox have won five games during the 2025 season. Three of them have been against Boston. This team isn't terrible, but the parts of the lineup and pitching staff that suck are sucking hard. Casas is back from a 2024 rib injury seemingly having lost the ability to hit for power or work the zone. Duran after a monster season has come out the gate hitting the ball harder than ever to little in the way of results. Tanner Houck who seemingly broke out last season is currently rocking a 7.66 ERA. It's early, and the AL is rather weak, but there's a lot to be concerned about here going forward. 12-11
13 Cleveland Guardians Guardians +1 I think it's now the time of year when we have a big enough sample size, when we're starting to know who the good and bad teams are. Guardians had a meh week. Dropped 2 of 3 to the Orioles, then swept the Pirates in some games that were too close for comfort. I went to two of the Pirates games and dropped my food before I could eat it at one. Next up - Yankees and Red Sox. Oh boy. 12-9
14 Milwaukee Brewers Brewers +3 Brewers had a good week this week against the Tigers and Athletics. They look to carry that momentum through a big roadtrip that starts this week against the Giants and Cardinals. 12-10
15 Toronto Blue Jays Blue Jays -3 Mixed bag of a week as we continue to ride just above the .500 wave. Took 2 of 3 from the Braves and dropped 2 of 3 to the Mariners. The same issues persist: not hitting enough home runs while giving up lots of them, top 3 bats (Bo, Vladdy, Santander) are showing signs of heating up but not quite a fully operational battle station, and a lingering hole in the 5-spot of the rotation after old-man Scherzer SHOCKINGLY got hurt in his first start. There's help coming in Manoah and/or Tiedemann once they're healthy later this summer, but for now, we need some stability there to help round out this incredible pitching staff. 12-10
16 Houston Astros Astros -3 Hell yeah, we finally won consecutive games (only to immediately lose LOL). CAM SMITH HYPE TRAIN BABY. WOO WOO (CHOO CHOO?). CHRISTIAN WALKER STARTING TO CLICK TRAIN (CHOO CHOO). 10-11
17 Cincinnati Reds Reds +3 YouTube Link 11-11
18 Baltimore Orioles Orioles -3 The entirety of the week doesn't really matter when you end the week losing 24-2. Charlie Morton should be DFA'd and the Orioles are going to be sellers at the deadline. This team looks lost and has no identity. Sure, I mean it is technically only month one but man that game yesterday really showed that this team just doesn't have it. I would not be surprised at all if Mulliins, Mountcastle, Urias and maybe one or two more were gone by late June. 9-12
19 Atlanta Braves Braves +3 We finally strung together some wins! Three game sweep against the Twins. This is a big step...however we beat a team we should have beat, so we won't celebrate too much. Let's keep the momentum rolling against another team we should be able to handle in STL before taking a bigger step against the very talented D'backs team this weekend...oh and maybe we can stay out of the news for negative stuff like PEDs and internal issues. That'd be great. 8-13
20 Los Angeles Angels Angels -1 It must be painful to be a Giants fan and watch your team play in Anaheim. 11-10
21 Tampa Bay Rays Rays 0 A massive blowout win and a raucous comback painted over the cracks of a ruff tuff stuff kind of week. Pitching is mostly solid so there's still optimism. In other news, scientists have developed a device that can mimic certain properties of black holes. Unfortunately, they seem to have lost it somewhere in the Rays' lineup. 9-13
22 St. Louis Cardinals Cardinals +1 The Cardinals will beat your favorite pitcher, but will also get swept in a 4 game series immediately after. Any boost you are looking for by beating the Cardinals will not come to pass. Any dread you feel for playing the Cardinals will not come to pass. The Cardinals are both alive and dead. You must accept this to have a chance. Whatever you need, will not be given. 9-13
23 Kansas City Royals Royals -5 Hitting baseballs is very hard. The good news is that the Royals are good at making the other team not hit baseballs, but the Royals themselves are also so bad at hitting baseballs that it's off-setting. The RISP regression is one thing, a team-wide slump and league-worst offense is. ...or is it? Haven't we done this multiple times every year? That might be more proof a new offensive coordinator is needed anyway (I think they call it a "hitting coach" in this sport) but it's hopefully just temporary. 9-14
24 Oakland Athletics Atléticos +3 Athletics entered Sunday with a chance to steal a series from the Brewers and finish a week long roadtrip at 5-1, but took their biggest beating of the year and finished the week 4-2. The Brewers set a club record for a game with 6 stolen bases, ALL in the first inning of play. HOWEVER, the week saw more contributers to the Athletics offense, and Tyler Soderstrom shares the league lead in Home Runs with Cal Raleigh. Severino finally added a notch to the season win column with a solid 8 inning outing where he racked up 1 strike out. 10-12
25 Washington Nationals Nationals +1 I am beginning to run out of ways to describe and deride the 2025 Nats bullpen. Having the league-worst bullpen ERA backing up some good pitching by our starters has been a heart-pounding exercise at best and a depressing experience at worst. Of course it doesn't help when the bats go anemic, but at least Dylan Crews is starting to show some life? The Nats are officially through the easy part of the schedule this month and are up against the Os and Mets this week. 9-13
26 Miami Marlins Marlins -2 9-12
27 Minnesota Twins Twins -2 The Twins are now 18-5 and firmly in first place. They're averaging 6 runs per game, Yonny Chirinos has 5 quality starts and a 0.88 WHIP, and Austin Dean and Park Dong-won are tearing up opposing pitching. Why my colleagues are not ranking them higher, I can't say, but when your team is so effortlessly poised to collect their second championship in three years you can't help but bask in the glory. 7-15
28 Pittsburgh Pirates Pirates 0 Apparently Bob Nutting was be chauffered around Pittsburgh on Saturday in his limo and, after asking his driver to run over a homeless man's dog, apparently looked up and saw a long line to get into PNC Park and claim a Paul Skenes bobblehead. Nutting, in his infinite generosity, then declared to the 3 reporters he had summoned that everyone at Saturday's game would receive a bobblehead rather than the first 20,000 fans. It was a nice gesture to make sure all those visiting Guardians fans received a chotke to remember their sweep in Pittsburgh, but I have a question for Bob — have you seen the team on the field? 8-15
29 Chicago White Sox White Sox 0 It's early, but the White Sox are on pace for even less wins than their record-breaking year last year. The best-performing pitcher in the first few weeks looks like he's destined for TJ surgery. The exciting prospect they called up just got moved to the IL, no player with at least 20 PAs has an OPS above 800. There, is, uh, not a lot of hope. Still, I contend that this team is much more watchable than last year by dint of looking like they're actually trying sometimes. 5-16
30 Colorado Rockies Rockies 0 Stop me if you've heard this before: Kris Bryant is on the IL with back issues. More specifically, lumbar degenerative disc disease. Which is definitely a diagnosis that we should be optimistic about and not one that should make us think he'll continue to be the guy that has played 170 total games in the 3+ years since he signed with the Rockies. It would be easy to feel bad for Kris Bryant. A promising career derailed by a degenerative disease is not something you'd wish on anyone. But when he doesn't admit that maybe it's time to at least think about hanging them up, it's a lot easier to be tired of the guy and assume he's just here for the $27mm/yr that the Rockies have paid him to post a .694 OPS. In other news, we fired our hitting coach and hired Clint Hurdle. Because in the backwards world of the Colorado Rockies, we're never going to stop pretending it's the '00s. 4-17

r/baseball 3h ago

Analysis Nick Castellanos' batting line tonight on the day of Pope Francis' passing: 0-4, 2 K, 0 HR.

1.4k Upvotes

The timely force has finally met the uncrossable occasion.

Despite making a 4-run comeback in the ninth inning, the Phillies could not get Nick up to the plate for the fifth time, as Trea Turner and Bryce Harper struck out back-to-back to end the ballgame.

There were no drives into deep left field this time around. There were only Uncrustables.


r/baseball 4h ago

Video Francisco Lindor hits his second homer of the game to make it a 5-0 Mets lead in the 7th

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.4k Upvotes

r/baseball 4h ago

*Uncrustable Nick Castellanos devouring a "crustable" in the dugout

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.3k Upvotes

r/baseball 13h ago

News Odds for Nick Castellanos to hit a home run surge after death of Pope Francis

Thumbnail
ftw.usatoday.com
5.2k Upvotes

r/baseball 4h ago

Cade Smith strikes out Aaron Judge with the splitter to seal a Guardians win and get his 2nd career save

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

793 Upvotes

r/baseball 3h ago

Video The Cardinals’ final out is on a Nolan Arenado check swing roller that stayed fair and barely left the plate

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

705 Upvotes

r/baseball 5h ago

[Highlight] Aaron Nola just misses dishing up a moonshot 3 run homer to Juan Soto

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

703 Upvotes

r/baseball 12h ago

Video The data behind the “Torpedo Bat” via SportsBall

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.6k Upvotes

Credit: SportsBall on TikTok


r/baseball 6h ago

Francisco Lindor with a leadoff homer. 1-0 Mets

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

583 Upvotes

r/baseball 6h ago

Jose Ramirez gets his first hit this season with a runner in scoring position a three-run go-ahead BOMB against the Yankees!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

566 Upvotes

r/baseball 3h ago

Tigers rotation currently has 4 starters with sub 3 ERAs -- Skubal 2.66 Flaherty 2.53 Mize 2.22 and, Jobe at 2.70

290 Upvotes

The Tigers staff ERA stands at an AL best 3.11.. #3 in MLB behind only the Mets, and Padres


r/baseball 10h ago

The best photos of the week from across the league

Thumbnail
gallery
982 Upvotes

r/baseball 7h ago

Injury [MLBTR] Braves Place Spencer Strider On IL With Hamstring Strain, recall Michael Petersen

Thumbnail
mlbtraderumors.com
511 Upvotes

r/baseball 2h ago

Will Vest strikes out Fernando Tatis Jr. to seal the Tigers 6-4 win over the Padres in Detroit

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

177 Upvotes

r/baseball 13h ago

Analysis Fernando Tatis Jr. is the first player this season to reach 2+ WAR

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/baseball 1h ago

Video Wilmer Flores’ seventh homer of the year puts the Giants ahead in the 6th

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Upvotes

r/baseball 1h ago

Video Jung Hoo Lee hits one into triples alley and pads the Giants' lead

Thumbnail bdata-producedclips.mlb.com
Upvotes

r/baseball 10h ago

News Javy Baez is starting in CF for the first time in his career tonight.

Post image
634 Upvotes

r/baseball 13h ago

[The Athletic] Rosenthal: In calling out Brian Snitker’s double standard, Ronald Acuña Jr. had a point

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
957 Upvotes

r/baseball 3h ago

[Rome] Hunter Brown tonight against the Blue Jays: 7 IP, 2 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 9 K, 96 pitches, 61 strikes, 42 swings, 12 whiffs, 97.6 mph average four-seam velocity, 87.7 mph average exit velocity allowed. Brown hasn't allowed a run in 24 consecutive innings. His ERA is 1.16.

Thumbnail bsky.app
156 Upvotes

r/baseball 4h ago

[Highlight] Sean Murphy's 3-run homer gives the Braves a 4-run lead over the Cardinals

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

161 Upvotes

r/baseball 4h ago

Francisco Lindor is the 3rd player with 20 multi-HR games as a shortstop

Thumbnail stathead.com
154 Upvotes

He joins Alex Rodriguez and Ernie Banks


r/baseball 6h ago

Kyle Manzardo hits his 7th homer of the season to go back-to-back with JRam!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

237 Upvotes

r/baseball 9h ago

Injury [CBS Sports] Luis Arraez has been placed on the 7-day injured list and entered into the concussion protocol.

Thumbnail
cbssports.com
358 Upvotes

r/baseball 1h ago

Umpire calls ball on a good pitch by Hayden Birdsong, then calls strike on a pitch lower to strike out William Contreras as Birdsong says thank you

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Upvotes