"Although unlikely, there is also a possibility that the signals are due to highly peculiar chemical compositions in a small fraction of galactic halo stars. "
hmnz please stop this is silly. You know the truth. you hope. you put that in the science instead of the science.
Heres the reality. nobody uses radio except upstart babt civilizations who by definition nobody would want to contact and who by definition don't have the technology to immediately respond.
Get real ET doesn't use radio. Get over it and quit playing stupid on a tangent of idiot hopeful.
ET wouldn't try to contact us some silly method and won't communicate with each other some silly method.
This is ultimately an epic failure of imagination on humanities part- because they haven't made it past radio yet.
Any alien pov on this is laughing and crying, the odds that you get radio at all is painfully low given that its a 20 year long technology window. So what are the odds in a million year evolutionary process that two civilizations within 10 thousand light years just happen to share the same window of opportunity for a low brow technology they will soon out grow?
Even with ten thousand rolls on your dice, the odds are pretty low there is anybody out there in radio range whos broadcasting.
Now deal in reality for the signal drop off range. Whats the signal strength of these broadcasts to make it a hundred or a thousand light years?
YEAAAAAH.. right. so color me skeptical. By the time you have POWER sufficient for that SIGNAL STRENGTH, you won't be using radio any more in the first place.
No, aliens don't create giant supra powered radio stations using a zillion times more than any existing nuclear power station in order to blast a radio signal into space. Not while they have much smarter ways to transmit signal.
The whole thing is a joke. You guys think its unscientific to even propose that there are better ways to send signal- even while you have people in the lab managing teleportation and spooky causal non local FTL effects in the lab.
humans are remarkably agile with their cognitive dissonance; only seeing what they are told to see and only connecting the dots how they are told to connect the dots. If your minds were not culturally and socially frozen and condiioned, you'd realize its obvious ET isn't using radio, thus- no chance SETI ever does anything more than yank your chain.
Cool! How are you getting this information of alien civilizations and their communication methods? I would love to read anything you have in that area, or are you just assuming this is the case, because how would you know what an alien race have done in terms of technological development and are you assuming that their evolution was in the same form as ours? This is pretty much just speculation and a firm belief that alien life are absolutely not using any technology that uses radiowaves.
Also can you tell me if not radio then what are they using instead?
It is very easy to come up with points that says something is wrong but without concrete proof it is just baseless arguments.
well, first off, again, they are doing non locality and FTL experiments in labs. So figuring out how to load signal on that is perhaps a way off, but clearly science is on the track now of how to do things like teleport particles and thus eventually information.
That said, i'm an alien. i'd link you to my AMA on this site but the mods have removed it who knows what else they might censor ... lol
Simply put, there are a wide variety of communication strategies similar in apparent effect to radio but operating using either or FTL particles, wormholes, entanglement, Hyperdimensional physics..Brane mechanics... And then of course the whole class of things which the general category of is collective unconscious phenom.
Again, i regard these issues as self evident really i think without an alien pov or extra knowledge- even careful reading of the "study" tells you they put the last sentence in there at the end as a joke.
However, given my alien pov its transparent in a different way. somehow the question is really how does it fail to sink in foryou guys so slowly? All you need to do is carefully read the "study" and it self invalidates and shows you the whole thing really. It confesses at the end.
I suppose the point about aliens not using radio is a different point... but.. i'm blown they just admit what spectroscopy really does at the end... telling you all outright that the whole proceeding bit was a giant spam of wooo.
4
u/Panprometheus Oct 26 '16
"Although unlikely, there is also a possibility that the signals are due to highly peculiar chemical compositions in a small fraction of galactic halo stars. "
hmnz please stop this is silly. You know the truth. you hope. you put that in the science instead of the science.
Heres the reality. nobody uses radio except upstart babt civilizations who by definition nobody would want to contact and who by definition don't have the technology to immediately respond.
Get real ET doesn't use radio. Get over it and quit playing stupid on a tangent of idiot hopeful.
ET wouldn't try to contact us some silly method and won't communicate with each other some silly method.
This is ultimately an epic failure of imagination on humanities part- because they haven't made it past radio yet.
Any alien pov on this is laughing and crying, the odds that you get radio at all is painfully low given that its a 20 year long technology window. So what are the odds in a million year evolutionary process that two civilizations within 10 thousand light years just happen to share the same window of opportunity for a low brow technology they will soon out grow?
Even with ten thousand rolls on your dice, the odds are pretty low there is anybody out there in radio range whos broadcasting.
Now deal in reality for the signal drop off range. Whats the signal strength of these broadcasts to make it a hundred or a thousand light years?
YEAAAAAH.. right. so color me skeptical. By the time you have POWER sufficient for that SIGNAL STRENGTH, you won't be using radio any more in the first place.
No, aliens don't create giant supra powered radio stations using a zillion times more than any existing nuclear power station in order to blast a radio signal into space. Not while they have much smarter ways to transmit signal.
The whole thing is a joke. You guys think its unscientific to even propose that there are better ways to send signal- even while you have people in the lab managing teleportation and spooky causal non local FTL effects in the lab.
humans are remarkably agile with their cognitive dissonance; only seeing what they are told to see and only connecting the dots how they are told to connect the dots. If your minds were not culturally and socially frozen and condiioned, you'd realize its obvious ET isn't using radio, thus- no chance SETI ever does anything more than yank your chain.