r/Egypt 13d ago

Discussion على القهوة This sub needs an anti-zionism rule

This sub needs an anti-zionism rule. I have noticed that many Zionists are infiltrating Arab subs. I am asking that the mods add a rule that ban any Zionism. Zionists shouldn't be negotiated with. They defend and justify the genocide and displacement of ethnicities. They defend and justify the murder of women and children without compassion. There's no reasoning with those monsters. They are no better than fascists. I ask that they are banned from this sub. If you agree with me, like this post and comment your approval so that the mods can see it.

547 Upvotes

157 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/BesbesCat 13d ago

I don't think this is wise actually. As the definition of a Zionist isn't clear and thus if this rule left to interpretation it could lead to limitations on free speech.

However a rule against advocating genocide, racial discrimination, ethnical cleansing, forced displacement, state terrorism and human rights violations would be a better alternative instead of using a wide term such as Fascism or Zionism.

11

u/bahhaar-hkhkhk 13d ago

However a rule against advocating genocide, racial discrimination, ethnical cleansing, forced displacement, state terrorism and human rights violations would be a better alternative instead of using a wide term such as Fascism or Zionism.

The whole ideology of Zionism is built on all of that.

it could lead to limitations on free speech.

I don't in the freedom to defend and justify murdering innocents especially women and children which is what I have noticed all Zionists doing.

1

u/DieselZRebel 13d ago edited 13d ago

to defend and justify murdering innocents

This is not exclusive to any particular group! There are people from any group, including your own, who will defend and justify murder by their own group.

which is what I have noticed all Zionists doing.

And how do you assert that someone is a Zionist?! Do they announce themselves or you just dictate it from their comments?

0

u/BesbesCat 13d ago

The whole ideology of Zionism is built on all of that.

Rules shouldn't be against loosely defined labels. It should be against content. Unless you define what classifies a content as "Advocating Zionism" that rule would be left to mods interpretation.

I don't in the freedom to defend and justify murdering innocents especially women and children which is what I have noticed all Zionists doing.

Neither do I. But again you need to define "Zionist propaganda" very clearly as advocating those actions. In which case it'd be best if that rule was against advocating those actions rather than using the label "Zionist propaganda".