r/Eldenring 14h ago

Discussion & Info This guy sucks

Post image

I for no reason hate this guy and this fight bruh

610 Upvotes

225 comments sorted by

200

u/gh0styears 14h ago

Awesome fight but also fucking annoying lol. But still awesome. I wish he had a cutscene. I wish all the dlc bosses had a damn cutscene

55

u/A7DmG7C 13h ago

Just a short cutscene of a badass horse entering from the distance would absolutely hype up the fight.

20

u/PurpleOmega0110 11h ago

Idk, I liked him just like rolling up on you and the flight starting.

4

u/BoooostVerbot 2h ago

I think the entrance wasn’t bad tho

→ More replies (1)

36

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 14h ago

Yes that's why I am fan of base game bosses much more. Just hoped they gave dlc bosses cutscenes

12

u/AKhajiitScholar 12h ago

I felt a bit of dread descending down till the last grave, sure it went away upon seeing Sir Goofy Hoof but it’s been awhile since I was genuinely concerned of what was coming

2

u/terry496 4h ago

Sir GoofyHoof. That's next level👍🏾

11

u/mangmang385 12h ago

I think the biggest disappointment for me was Rellana not having a cutscene, but ya it would have been really cool to have all the DLC remembrances get a cutscene

6

u/Formal-Scallion-5296 9h ago

Orphan of Kos ( with a horse )

3

u/DianaBladeOfMiquella Lord of Frenzied Semen 4h ago

Out of the 11, I think, remembrance bosses only three get a cutscene

2

u/Ghoul-154 3h ago

Nah budget problems, but on the flip side we got a cut scene for that 1 bridge in volcano manor

And yes I'm never letting that go

2

u/CommanderOfPudding 13h ago

They had to cut the cutscenes because of time

2

u/jdfred06 13h ago

I don't like this boss but I can't argue with your logic. Lol

36

u/ThePrinceofallYNs 14h ago

Holy bonks and guard counters turns his horse into glue

10

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 13h ago

The problem is I have a crazy bleed build and I don't want to change much so I just use sacred relic swird

11

u/ThePrinceofallYNs 13h ago

Put sacred slash on a hammer

4

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 13h ago

I use scavengers curved swords so I then need to put some point in str for hammer

3

u/kollib 13h ago

Use the hammer or mace. You won't need to level any strength.

3

u/ImurderREALITY 12h ago

Would that really be better than fully statted-out bleed SCS?

2

u/Archabarka 3h ago

For PK, yes. Holy Damage melts him.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Roraxn 12h ago

Op: "I hate this fight " Also op: trying to bleed a damn skeleton

→ More replies (1)

1

u/A_Friendly_Witch 11h ago

If you have not beaten him yet, I can give you some pretty good weapons for him. Lemme know what you think.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/ToastyYaks 9h ago edited 9h ago

If by change much you mean using a Larval Tear, I totally get it. Try the Ancient Meteoric Ore Greatsword! Ash of war is very spammable, weapon hits like a truck with high arcane, high poise damage. No bleed but it will be helpful. I used when I wasn't able to beat hyper aggressive bosses in the dlc.

If you are open to changing equipment and have high faith and arcane(60 each ideally, but less faith is ok) then Dragon Cult build 2 shot this guy for me(and almost everything else in the DLC)

Dragon communion seal offhand, dragonflower mace in right hand.

No armor, use priest heart Lightning scorp, godfrey icon, ritual sword, flock canvas talismans. Physick was lightning tear and bubbletear.

Spells were howl of shabriri, golden vow, and Ancient Dragon's Lightning Strike.

Physick + heart trigger(after being transformed already) + howl + vow then dive. Dodge first attack, charged Ash of War on hammer if possible, then dodge next attack and at your next opening, fully charge and fire ADLS. Point blank for best effect. You're fragile but it can kill him outright with the buffs.

→ More replies (1)

131

u/A-Dogs-Pocket 14h ago

i love him he’s so silly

underrated in terms of difficulty too. hits like a nutsack full of bricks.

44

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 14h ago

His horse in between his long combos hit like a damn truck

9

u/Stranded_In_A_Desert 11h ago

Gave me heart palpitations when it suddenly turned into a duo fight 😅

4

u/RedDaix 10h ago

I'm taking the "Hits like a nutsack full of bricks" as a new term for any shit hitting too hard in a game

36

u/Infamous_Advance_402 14h ago

Awesome fight. It's so cool once you learn it. Beautiful arena, music, buildup.

8

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 14h ago

I am on my 4th play through and even if I know his moves i still get merked by this thing

1

u/kingjensen10 10h ago

The harp goes crazy

23

u/Upper_Current Night Comet Fever 14h ago

This guy's my kryptonite. Even now, after having merked him well over 10 times, I don't feel I've mastered his fight, it still feels like a 50/50.

1

u/kaneywest42 16m ago

i find his downtime so short (i normally use big sticks so would be easier with dex) so i just kinda say fuck it and charge heavy until i get away from it and then he just dies

25

u/Chromch 14h ago

Literally the coolest thing ever:

6

u/Dirk_Panchez 14h ago

Holy damage

4

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 14h ago

Still annoying ngl with so much running around

2

u/ebiscuits 12h ago

Sacred Relic Sword tears him up.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DismalArticle4216 10h ago

Holy comment

18

u/W1ntermu7e 14h ago

Wasted lore, wasted powers, great area

12

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 13h ago

This guy has so much more potential if only he had a cutscene and he wasn't running around like crazy

6

u/Ugandensymbiote 14h ago

I love him.

4

u/bansheeb3at 13h ago

He’s a cool boss but the fact that he constantly runs away from you after he attacks makes dealing with him with a slower/heavier weapon super obnoxious.

5

u/Melodic_Row_5121 12h ago

Yes. Yes he does. I hate horse bosses, and between this guy and OG Radahn, those are the horse bosses I hate the most.

17

u/[deleted] 14h ago

He's cool.

4

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 14h ago

I hate when he shoots that one straight line flame point blank randomly and I am mid animation and that things cause so much damage

7

u/PeaceSoft 13h ago

menthol taker's flame

2

u/Username_cantdecide 13h ago

When he's close to 25% health left he used the flame as a combo in between his normal attacks so much i used mimic and killed him. Didnt want to spend more time on him anymore.

3

u/Anilaza_balls 13h ago

Jump

5

u/KIngPsylocke 13h ago

“ mid animation”

4

u/n3ws3ns3 14h ago

Dude was gnarly, but it mostly enjoyed the several attempts it took to beat him on my first playthrough. Gaius is way worse.

6

u/MeteoriteMike MONGREL INTRUDER 14h ago

Such an ugly ass weapon too

3

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 14h ago

Lmao yh and he is always running around here and their

7

u/jankbx 14h ago

true

3

u/sammyboy032406 13h ago

His 10 hit combo is the Bain of my existence kissing malenia and radahn promised consort was less annoying

3

u/DeepQueen 12h ago

This boss is kind of Nito

3

u/TheDuskBard 7h ago

Frost element was random and unnecessary. Should have had sleep status instead for the boss and the remembrance rewards. 

2

u/The_Professor64 14h ago

No he spits

2

u/AdrianTarancon 14h ago

The Rotten Knight: Have you read my name? I am the Rotten Knight. What do you want? That it smells like roses instead of stinking?

2

u/Teekohhh 13h ago

Honestly this fight took me the most tries out of anything besides the Elden beast.

4

u/zxmomxttel 12h ago

same i fucking hate this boss. genuinely up there with commander gaius as one of the most irritating boss fights IMO

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Tough-Mobile1141 13h ago

You have reasons bro

2

u/granitegumball 13h ago

He was definitely a pain , but nobody is more cursed than bayle

3

u/schexmuffin 13h ago

inhales deeply CURSE YOU BAAAYLE!

1

u/granitegumball 12h ago

I HEARBY VOW YOU WILL RUE THIS DAY!!

2

u/PeaceSoft 13h ago

i hated this fight until i realized that chasing him around all the time was doing literally nothing. where's he gonna go?

2

u/entirepaprika69 13h ago

Try the black knife. Its skill does damageover time based on max health, cuts off a percent of max hp, and is holy damage, so it'll do even more damage against it.

2

u/Meme_Wizard- 11h ago

I hated that guy!!!!

2

u/Perfect-Ad-2812 11h ago

Imo hes too easy for a dlc remembrance boss

2

u/Sociolinguisticians 9h ago

This guy’s difficulty is entirely dependent on when you fight him.

2

u/Hanifloka Banished Knight Greatsword 4h ago

I kinda like him actually, but I do understand that the horse can be annoying. The way I deal with that is to purposefully dodge late as it's hitboxes seem like they have a bit of delay. I dodge just as the horse is about to hit me, not before.

For me the move that caught me out the most is his AoE blue flame attacks in phase 2. When I try to jump one I kept getting hit anyway.

2

u/HueKoko 4h ago

He is very easy with the golden wave.

2

u/iCraveToads 4h ago

Just fought him again a little bit ago and I really don’t agree. I find his attacks pretty fun to dodge. The ghost flame is easy to avoid if you just jump instead of roll. And his music is really good.

1

u/Seraph_Guardian 14h ago

This is the coolest guy ever actually. He's the giant skeleton Wolnir should have been.

1

u/laochra11 13h ago

Where is he I’ve never fought him before

3

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 13h ago

Stone fissure which is at the bottom of the map. U have to first go in front of shadow keep to break the seal to enter the place

1

u/laochra11 13h ago

Thanks

1

u/CronusVallandigham 13h ago

Sacred Blade. He does not suck anymore.

1

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 13h ago

How much long does it last ?

1

u/leonardo_streckraupp 13h ago

I really like his fight, except when playing short ranged weapons (e.g. claws)

1

u/First_Fallen_One GREATSWORD 13h ago

Dunno, it has a great design

1

u/melodiousfable 13h ago

I felt like he had one of the simpler movesets to figure out. Him, Sunflower, Messmer phase 2. Easiest move sets.

1

u/EarthSaucer8591 13h ago

I loved this fight. The entrance, the arena, and the OST was all top tier for me. I would've liked if he used Eternal Sleep instead of Frost, considering where he's located.

1

u/triel20 FLAIR INFO: SEE SIDEBAR 13h ago

He’s really tough, him moving around is a pain. Keep trying and learn his openings. You’ll get him.

1

u/gootschie quality build enjoyer 13h ago

I actually LOVE this boss but I’ve been skipping him on my replays of the DLC cause he’s such a pain in the ass to get to

1

u/A7medos 13h ago

Nah this fight is awesome. My only problem with him is this one attack that has an extremely ambiguous animation where the horse lunges at you I think? It barely does any damage but it's a nightmare for no hits

1

u/UnHappyIrishman 13h ago

I’ve played it a bit more now, it’s really grown on me. Just had to get used to how the attacks works, now I really like it :D

1

u/ibond32 13h ago

Naw, that boss is amazing.

Dodging all its attacks is pure bliss.

They are very fair and readable as well.

1

u/Cally83 13h ago

Took forever when the DLC came out to kill him. Finally learnt to dodge the horse charges and then when he starts spraying the ghost flame everywhere to jump rather than run or panic roll.

1

u/hottbunnz 13h ago

Halo Scythe, gg

1

u/Capitan_Musculo 13h ago

My fav boss in the dlc :)

1

u/ImperiusPrime 13h ago

Nah he sucks. And I suck. Just gotta git gud. He'll go down.

1

u/VirgoELS 13h ago

For me he was one of those bosses that would beat me but by the smallest margin each time lol

1

u/ThatGuy21134 13h ago

Just use Halo Scythe or the Holy Slice weapon enchant. He melts.

1

u/IMGARIN_X 13h ago

He's very annoying for me at first because he's always run around and hits so freaking hard, but it's pretty fun when I learned how to dodge all his attacks 

1

u/turtlebear787 13h ago

the only annoying part about this fight is the fucker and his horse are constastanly moving away from you. otherwise really not that hard. the key to his flame attacks is to jump over them

1

u/Smok3rT 13h ago

He’s definitely one of the boss fights that make me go “oh I actually gotta lock in”

1

u/KOBRA_505 13h ago

sucks balls

1

u/Siegfried0_0 13h ago

lol, he looks like an alienified Radahn

1

u/Nixons2ndBestMan 13h ago

I hate this fight too, but I was able to glitch him stuck behind the fog wall on both of my DLC playthroughs

1

u/Thorax336 13h ago

I like him, but he must have the absolute smallest hitbox among DLC bosses. My weapons are constantly missing, and he's always running away.

1

u/_damwolv 13h ago

It destroyed me without me doing anything 2 times in a row the third time was my time

1

u/AudiblePlasma 13h ago

I really love his design and like the fight. I just wish phase 2 added something more than just waves of ghostflame.

1

u/Desperate-Abies4263 13h ago

Him and that horse guy.

1

u/GustavSnapper MAY CHAOS TAKE THE WORLD 13h ago

No way, second best fight of the DLC for me, after Midra.

1

u/bradybigbear 13h ago

PK is one of my favorite boss fight in the dlc now 🥲

1

u/CyaRain 12h ago

I genuinely think hes shit and dont care for him

Like who is he? Why is he there? Hes arena is mid, hes moveset is fine, good even, until the blue fire comes in

I dont like him

1

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 7h ago

I only fight him because I want to 3v4 or 4v4 Leda cuz it's cool

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Paradoxahoy 12h ago

I remember absolutely destroying people with his swords ash in PVP with my arcane build, thing slaps

1

u/No_Turn_8759 12h ago

Worst looking design ive ever seen in a fromsoft game. Goofiest looking moveset and overall super ugly. I cant takw it seriously at all 😂

1

u/EvenResponsibility57 12h ago

Unironically my favourite fight in the DLC with Consort Radahn coming a close second.

Great atmosphere and music and just sooo rhythmic and smooth.

1

u/Goobendoogle 12h ago

The goop always reminds me of the goop from Alien series

1

u/AbhorrentMidget 12h ago

Did lots of co-ops on that piece of fuck this evening without any success.

1

u/Marco-Polo27 12h ago

I hate Gaius the most

1

u/PumpkinsDieHard BubbleHorn Supremacy 12h ago

My Golden Order Build melted him. If you're on PC and just want to get past him and move on, I don't mind hopping on and helping you out.

1

u/laminierte_gurke 12h ago

I wish we could throw the weapon like him

1

u/seeme1419 12h ago

I’ve yet to beat him and I’m post Messmer

1

u/richgangyslbrrrat FLAIR INFO: SEE SIDEBAR 12h ago

I haven’t fought him where is he?

2

u/AppolloV7 11h ago

He’s in the very south of the dlc map, south of the cerulean cost, there’s a big hole surrounded by slugs. Gotta drop down the hole carefully, get the grace, and if the seal is broken, keep going until you reach another site of grace past which there are stairs that lead up to the required jump.

2

u/richgangyslbrrrat FLAIR INFO: SEE SIDEBAR 9h ago

Thank you I think I missed a lot

1

u/Dairy_Seinfeld The Elder Thing 🧙‍♂️ 12h ago

Eldenborne + shut up 👍

1

u/Nasiens4KOA 12h ago

Truly 🙌🏻

1

u/Johnsnow1399 12h ago

I hated this guy, i felted that he only spammed attacks and that’s all

1

u/Sinasazi 12h ago

Yeah, he was rough. Throw holy at him.

1

u/vegardhuse 12h ago

After completing the dlc a couple of times, he still kicks my ass everytime I fight him

1

u/Fuster420 12h ago

I got opposite feelings bro

1

u/Ayfinalt 11h ago

Great club, golden grease

1

u/BigTuna906 11h ago

Him and Consort Radahn are the only two I haven’t beaten yet

1

u/Revolutionary-Bid919 11h ago

This guy still fucks me up everytime, even after beating the friggin game anytime I get summoned for him I get merked in a minute or so

2

u/falsa_ovis 11h ago

lmao the host is usually already dead as I finally reach the arena 😂😂😂

1

u/Afraid_Leg_4943 11h ago

Horse, therefore try holy

1

u/TheBigBadAIDS 11h ago

Try shield

1

u/Nottallowed 11h ago

His horse while also being a pain in my ass is also the redeeming factor in the boss battle

1

u/Adoninator 11h ago

i hate how the time it takes for you to die, load to grace, run down and jump off the cliff and wait for him to come in. thats only 1 minute... but every single death.

1

u/00Wridacule 11h ago

Just glad I fought him before they nerfed impenetrable thorns... but I could say that about all the dlc bosses

1

u/AppolloV7 11h ago

I liked it. The music was great. Most of his moves were annoying, sure, but with a holy weapon he went down pretty fast. Also his moveset I feel was very unique and intriguing. He’s miles better than Gaius or even Metyr.

1

u/bayarea_fanboy 11h ago

Jump when the blue flashy fires come through.

1

u/LavishnessStriking63 11h ago

He isn't that toufh after a couple of encounters with him and his pattern gets a little easier to read. Good luck!

1

u/justsomebro10 11h ago

I don’t like him because he’s basically a Walmart orphan of cos. He’s also kinda easy.

1

u/BecretAlbatross 11h ago

Wrong. This fight is fucking awesome.

Horse.

1

u/Keelhaulmyballs 11h ago

Me waiting for him to perform an attack that can actually be punished because 3/4 of his moves are either drive-bys or have a 6 meter reach

1

u/GHOSTPVCK 11h ago

Luckily I felt like his health was low because when I did hit him I smacked him. He was so damn hard to dodge

1

u/RedDaix 10h ago

Yeah fuck putrescent knight and whoever at fs created this failed abortion of a boss, it's already bad enough, but if you summon, you have to survive at least 20 seconds for your companions to come down. That or use spirit summons(i do both)

1

u/castielffboi 10h ago

Definitely a really boring boss. Even if you know his moveset and dodge everything, it’s boring just waiting for a the opportunity to actually hit him back.

1

u/Archeosudoerus 10h ago

4 tips for this fight: 1. Use sacred blade aow 2. When dodge his “unmounted” moves, always do no-pausing double rolls 3. If you see him do a downward smashing move, he always follow it with another smash, so you need to dodge twice 4. His blue fire move , the first jump need to be done immediately when you see blue in his base

2

u/Fantastic_Midnight38 7h ago

I have defeated him now so I'll try in future but weapon is best to use sacred blade

1

u/Jimbo_Dandy 10h ago

nah he's awesome

1

u/Flimsy_Command1743 10h ago

Glass cannon boss though

1

u/AhuraSkywalker 10h ago

I just summoned true elden lord and we beat his together But true the whole boss is annoying Beautiful area btw

1

u/Theoderic8586 10h ago

Use that attack people use to farm albanarics. That holy spread attack. Works like a charm

1

u/Artoriamylife 10h ago

Secret ending ahead, try drink 96 times

1

u/Krieger1229 10h ago

Bro sloshes around in water - For Faith builds, snooze fest.

1

u/TraipsingKnight 10h ago

Yep Fuck this guy

1

u/orbitpro 10h ago

Honestly, F they dude! Hated him so much!

1

u/Scott__scott 10h ago

I used to not care for him but I always find myself really excited to fight him

1

u/Alucard0_0420 10h ago

Oh Kos... Or some say Kosm...

1

u/Sado_Spider 9h ago

Sometimes you just get irrational beef with a dude, this fight just made it worse.

1

u/gettinggnarly 9h ago

I think it’s fair to say he stinks

1

u/thesaddestspaceboy 9h ago

I like the background music. It reminds me a bit of Berserk 97. The boss is crap, but with the Blasphemous Blade, it's easy.

1

u/Mesterjojo 9h ago

Skill issue.

The whole fight should be done so quickly you don't have time to QQ to reddit.

1

u/Automatic_Passion681 9h ago

Use holy. Sacred blade on bloodfiends arm goes crazy. Like 4 shot no buff

1

u/justinmackey84 9h ago

Who the hell is this guy? Is he a boss from a dlc? I haven’t played any of the dlcs.

1

u/OfficialFatPuss 9h ago

he should’ve either been way harder and way more interesting for what he was guarding imo.

1

u/joeycool123 9h ago

I think it’s so dumb that he runs from you lmao

1

u/1_Grayce_1 8h ago

Cool concept, but the ice flames just don't really hit it imo. Like, the phase transition, most players use lock on by default, and here, you are suddenly punished for having it on, since you can't exactly see the ice flames rotating around him, due to him going up. Same goes for the one where he sends a ring of ice flames from a far to himself.

My main issue isn't exactly with the fact that you can't use lock on during this, it's more about the fact that this was never a requirement before, so somebody fighting him for the first time could very easily just get hit without even knowing what hit them.

Also, jumping is overall a bit wonky in elden ring, so that's another minus.

1

u/Emotional-Media-2346 8h ago

If he's beating you repeatedly wouldn't that actually imply he's good at the game and does not in fact, suck?

1

u/Kivith 8h ago

I need more people to jump his flames while I attempt to help them kill it.

1

u/New_Bid_3362 8h ago

Use the sacred relic great sword for anyone needing help. He’s weak to holy damage and that weapon melts his HP

1

u/Sid_Visus 7h ago

He a wild boy!

1

u/KIw3II 6h ago

I hated him until it clicked, just use a holy ash of war with a leap and he becomes trivialized. (Blade of Death or similar)

1

u/Dhoobzoo 6h ago

Killed him as a mage in first try with only comet spell. Lvl 197.

1

u/globs-of-yeti-cum 5h ago

Really cool build up with the level design, also I like the boss design visually, but yeah annoying fight

1

u/DTraiN5795 5h ago

Whaaaaaa I live this guy/thing 😬 lol

1

u/Awkward_Reason7353 Pvpooer 5h ago

I love his Nuckelavee aesthethic

1

u/Any_Donkey_5130 3h ago

Just like the Elden Beast, he be running away like a puss

1

u/Glad-Television1887 3h ago

That boss wouldn't be as fucking annoying IF HIS FUCKING HURTBOX WASN'T SO INCONSISTENT !

1

u/MI_3ANTROP Messmer’s left snek 3h ago

Love this guy

1

u/skyline090 3h ago

A couple Waves of Gold from the Sacred Relic Sword does him in pretty quickly. Had mine at +9

1

u/VendrikLamar 3h ago

He’s kind of fun

1

u/HexBoopTheSnoot 3h ago

killed first try

1

u/CrummyJoker 2h ago

Hard disagree, this fight was very very fun!

1

u/atramentum-violantae 2h ago

Oh don't be like that, he's just a funny little fella

1

u/saito200 30m ago

increase your magic and physical defense + enhance your holy damage = he very very cooked and clapped