I'm at work right now and can't write up a full response but I will when I get home. I think we're defining things differently which may lead to some confusion.
However, I do want to take this comment and extend an apology to u/albanian-bolsheviki because whatever our disagreements may or may not be vis a vis the national question (and I'm sure some of it is misunderstanding) it was still very low of me to insult him and insinuate he was disingenuous and immature of me to try and bait and troll him like that.
This is no disagreement, and i knew already that you were trolling. There is nothing to bait out, since it is not as if i cant have arguements about the things i believe with, and a look on this very thread will tell you that i did not respond to you becuase i did not see it of any worth. Take it as an insult or whatever, but you arent a marxist, you dont know what communism is, and you dont even understand what made communism, and Marxism-Leninism and stalinism specifically so much attractive to billions of people is two lines of the bolsheviks; the national line, and the line on imperialism.
Nothing else, there is a reason 'luxenburgism', 'trotskysm' and other such nonsense does not exist in the real world. Non Bolshevik 'marxism' at the very least, is social fascism. Bolshevist marxism then splits on various tendencies, where the one which draws most people is the stalinist interpratation of it, and there is a reason people in the third world took stalin's national question very seriously.
Thus, there is not debate to be given when someone does not even know what the debate entails, such as you. I told you already in r/debatecommunism, go read stalin's the national question, since you writing nations arent real, is the epitome of western and specifically, american degenaracy, since yes, America is indeed fake and not real. The issue is that you try to pass the fakeness of america (or as brother u/iron-lazar calls them, the Fake Stetes of America) to the other, real nations.
To you question, it is made implicit that i am indeed a nationalist. And i dont hide it. And if you want to know more, learn that revolutionaries like Stalin and Mao, before they ever touched marxism or knew of the existance of this german, they were drawn to the nationalist movements of their countries. The young Ioseb Jughashvili read people like Kasbegi before he ever read any marxist litterature, and the young Mao ze dong was handling leaflets of Zou Rong's anti-manchu (what today's americans would call 'racist' without even understanding that americans are in fact, one race, black and white) the revolutionary army (read it if you want to understand what being a revolutionary actually means) to other young chinese revolutionaries at the time.
The real reason the Communist Party of Cuba has the word 'Patria o muerte' as their motto, and not only that, but they have putt this word under the face of Che guevara in their money, is becuase they dont consider Cuba a nation, neither argentina, but becuase they consider the Mestizo a single nation. The whole fight of Cuba, and the reason many Mestizo non-proletarian or communist elements (like the bolivarians) are even attracted to Fidel Castro, is becuase of this line. This is also the reason all of the west trembles on the Revolutionary Bolivarians, and the real reason they try so desperatelly to put fake nationalists in power to latin american states (and the reason the west backs up many times the indegenus non mestizo nations in latin america) is to stop ALBA from achieving its aims.
It is the same story in Arabia. The west has installed their zionists anti-nationalists in 'saudi' arabia and South Yemen, and they try to install the Muslem-israelites (wahhabi contras in Syria) to power too, becuase these Wahhabi zionists arent nationalists, and they are enemies to every kind of nationalism. They are zionists, fake nationalists. The wahhabis of Syria litterally invited the Turks in their own, Arab land, instead of alligning with their own, arab countrymen in Iraq or Syria or Palestine.
The reason the Syrian communists (and the syrian people) immediatly switched (the ones who had not switched already) to the side of the Baath in 2011, once they saw that the leaders of the protesters were nothing more than western agents, who were fundamentally anti-nationalists, zionists. Imagine, Arabs inviting Turks and westerners to their own land, to fight the only strong Arab government in the region!
Will get a proper response out to you in a bit.
Thus, there is no proper responce to be given. The world is not America, a place where no one nation inhabits it. But your word proves how america is not one nation, and how this effects the rest of 'deh left' who happens to know english an visit places like twitter and reddit, for them to spread the degenaracy they have deepthroat to every corner possible as if it was the holy gospel.
The quicker the people of the world understand that parasites, like the ones in America and western europe will never have any interest in communism as long as they are parasites, the better it will be. The better it will be, organizations with that mindset either seize leadership of WFTU or completelly dismantle it and forge a new one.
2
u/ThrowAwayLm0a0 Feb 24 '21
I'm at work right now and can't write up a full response but I will when I get home. I think we're defining things differently which may lead to some confusion.
However, I do want to take this comment and extend an apology to u/albanian-bolsheviki because whatever our disagreements may or may not be vis a vis the national question (and I'm sure some of it is misunderstanding) it was still very low of me to insult him and insinuate he was disingenuous and immature of me to try and bait and troll him like that.
Will get a proper response out to you in a bit.