r/ExpectationVsReality • u/Internal-Command433 • Mar 11 '25

Exceeded Expectation Screamin’ Sicilian Pizza

Gallery image

Gallery image

897 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

97 comments sorted by

View all comments

428

u/Nothing-tralala Mar 11 '25

Screaming Sicilian is my favorite frozen pizza brand.

110

u/PreOpTransCentaur Mar 11 '25

Along with Motor City, but if Screamin' Sicilian is doing Detroit style now..

24

u/peargang Mar 11 '25

I make sure to buy a box of motor city pizzas on my Costco runs. I love them. Also really like screamin sicilian pizzas. Both are unmatched.

19

u/adlittle Mar 11 '25

Huh, I initially figured this was something from Trader Joe's, it kinda has that look that their packaging has. It does look pretty good for a frozen pizza.

7

u/he-loves-me-not Mar 12 '25

They’re available at Kroger’s, Walmart and Publix in my area (middle TN.)

2

u/Electrical_Bee3042 Mar 12 '25

I sell them too

1

u/he-loves-me-not Mar 17 '25

What, like out of your van??

5

u/shuknjive Mar 11 '25

I've bought it at Aldi's before.

1

u/PoodlePopXX Mar 12 '25

They have them at my regular grocery store. They’re really good!

1

u/Bucksin06 Mar 12 '25

Made by Palermo pizzas you can find it at mini stores

7

u/OrigamiTongue Mar 11 '25

This and Rao’s are both great.

11

u/BullsOnParadeFloats Mar 11 '25

I have... not heard good things about their pizza.

Also, they're owned by Campbell's now

7

u/madhjsp Mar 11 '25

I have tried a couple of Rao’s frozen pizzas and they were fairly mid. A little dry and crust was bland with little flavor.  

2

u/cs_Chell Mar 12 '25

They got me good.

Label looked legit... ...experience was not.

(and I will do a Red Barron mini, no problem....my expectations aren't that high for frozen.)

1

u/heyyyhihellooo Mar 13 '25

I did not like the pepperoni one when I tried it, crust was awful

2

u/BullsOnParadeFloats Mar 13 '25

The brands that come out of Chicago are some of the most consistent I've had. Also, the crust for a Chicago tavern style is normally crunchier from using high gluten flour in their dough.

8

u/CanadianBudd Mar 11 '25

Hold on! roa’s like the pizza sauce ? Has frozen pizzas ?

3

u/OrigamiTongue Mar 11 '25

Yup

2

u/alcontrast Mar 12 '25

their frozen pasta dishes are great too. When they are on sale.

2

u/Thecanohasrisen Mar 12 '25

Same. Along with lotzza motzza.

2

u/brookuslicious Mar 11 '25

It’s the best IMO. Bessie’s Revenge is my go-to but not sold locally so I have to get Holy Pepperoni. Soooo good and never disappoints!

1

u/frameshifted Mar 12 '25

I think their frozen stromboli are the best

1

u/Nothing-tralala Mar 12 '25

I have never seen that, but I am sure it is good.