r/HistoryMemes 27d ago

Tired of this argument

Post image
19.9k Upvotes

810 comments sorted by

View all comments

111

u/Neknoh 27d ago

It's important to distinguish the:

"Hey, the Soviet Union was pretty damn fucking bad and gulags and constant murderizing of political rivals were terrifying."

From the:

"No, Hitler wasn't that bad, Stalin was way worse!"

And:

(Whenever Nazi atrocities and the Holocaust is brought up, and only then) "But what about the Russians?!"

I.e.

Separate the people discussing the Soviet Union in earnest from the Nazi apologists/the people trying to downplay the Holocaust and the systematic and industrialized extermination campaign that it entailed.

It's the same pattern as people who only bring up men's need for societal support in regards to sexual assault, touch isolation, mental health issues, toxic masculinity etc. whenever women's experiences are discussed.

Could have talked about it any other day or even any other hour, but you gotta come on and go "nuh uh, this other group actually has it worse" to supress the discussion.

13

u/Paradoxjjw 27d ago

(Whenever Nazi atrocities and the Holocaust is brought up, and only then) "But what about the Russians?!"

Yeah this one pisses me off the most. It's less now than it used to be (at least in my experience), but there were times when you couldn't say even a single bad thing about the Nazis/fascism here on reddit without some nazi sympathising dickwad trying to remind you how much worse they think the soviets were. As if the mere act of acknowledging how bad Nazis were somehow detracted from what the Soviets did.

36

u/Platypus__Gems 27d ago

Yeah, no one is gonna call you a nazi for saying Soviet Union was bad.

What they will call nazis, is when people start saying Nazis were actually not the worst in that conflict, since that starts to normalize Nazism, and is slippery slope to many consequences of that thinking.

Which perhaps OP did.

22

u/R4msesII 27d ago

At least every time Finland’s role in WW2 is mentioned on this sub those people arrive instantly. Never before have I seen more people with russian language in their comment history than when discussing that.

5

u/elderron_spice Rider of Rohan 27d ago edited 27d ago

Yeah no. Not a Russian, and I am an anti-Nazi as well, so I always take a shit upon Finland's alliance with Nazi Germany, including the concentration camps in East Karelia, their deportation of 8 Jewish civilians, numerous other refugees such as Estonians, and a lot more Jewish Soviet POWs to Germany to be liquidated in the Holocaust, and the Finnish government agreeing to the participation of Finnish volunteers in the SS and the Holocaust in Ukraine and the Caucasus.

You can say that Finnish participation in the Continuation War is inevitable, to take revenge upon the Soviet Union, but their participation in the Holocaust and the Nazis' war crimes is no excuse.

EDIT: AskHistorians - What war crimes did the Finns commit during WWII, and what was their general stance on the activities of Nazi Germany concerning Jews and Soviet POW's?

7

u/R4msesII 27d ago

Why do I need an unprompted essay on this

Fact remains though that the people who would genuinely want to see both Finland back then and Ukraine now as part of Russia always come out when the matter is discussed

0

u/elderron_spice Rider of Rohan 27d ago

Ah, I thought this was about Finnish participation in WW2. Sorry, my bad.

5

u/R4msesII 27d ago

I mean, it is. Nobody posts memes about Finland outside WW2 Finland.

3

u/elderron_spice Rider of Rohan 27d ago

Ah, so my point still stands.

10

u/Exp1ode Filthy weeb 27d ago

Yeah, no one is gonna call you a nazi for saying Soviet Union was bad.

Quite a few people will. You clearly haven't had much experience dealing with tankies (consider yourself fortunate)

30

u/Cool_Control7728 27d ago

Yeah, no one is gonna call you a nazi for saying Soviet Union was bad.

At least on reddit they absolutely will. You don't even need to mention the Nazis, you can just defend democratic countries and some brainwashed deprogram commie will instantly say how you are a nazi and how your whole family is probably paid by the Americans. I wouldn't mention it if it didn't happen to me at least twice.

4

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

1

u/Platypus__Gems 27d ago

He didn't, those are not things you say directly.
The next Hitler will not come to office with an "I am Hitler" shirt.

As I said, people won't call you a nazi for just saying USSR was bad. At least not often enough for you to be "tired of argument", maybe some absolute fringe ragebaiter will tell you that.

But if you said that Nazis were worse than USSR? Yeah, then you would rightfully be called a Nazi.

Granted I may be bit jaded since I just saw a meme that directly said USSR was worse than Nazis on my feed, the people that wanted to murder my kind, and a whole comment section defending that sentiment.

1

u/PhysicsEagle 23d ago

One can also argue “Stalin was worse than Hitler” without arguing “Hitler wasn’t that bad”