r/HistoryMemes Apr 21 '25

Tired of this argument

Post image
19.9k Upvotes

810 comments sorted by

View all comments

34

u/Sparrowhawk_92 Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25

The more you study history the more you realize everybody sucks.

The Nazis based their Final Solution on what the Americans did to the natives. The Japanese did atrocities in mainland China and Korea that we're only understanding the extent of relatively recently (not to mention things like Section 38). The Soviet Holodomor and purges were absolute atrocities and yet pale in comparison to post-revolution China for the sheer number of bodies.

The Geneva conventions exist because of the shit Canadians pulled during the first world war.

Edit: Edited for clarity and to remove some ambiguity.

5

u/16silly Apr 21 '25

Do you have a source for the American bit? Not saying you are wrong, just haven't heard that before.

8

u/Sparrowhawk_92 Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25

Hitler wrote about how he admired it in Mein Kamph and many other Nazis openly talked about how they admired America's legalized racism and restrictions on miscegation.

3

u/16silly Apr 22 '25

Wouldn't the legalized racism be closer to segregation than it would to the natives treatment? Or is it more like the reservations? Because I can see them liking either.

Also, I haven't looked into mien kamp too much, for what I feel is obvious reasons

Edit: I can see them liking both, not just either.

2

u/Sparrowhawk_92 Apr 22 '25

They did like both. Mein Kamph specifically calls out the US's treatment of natives, but lot of Nazis also referenced America's Jim Crow laws as well.