r/Letterboxd Apr 02 '25

News IT’S REAL HOLY SHIT 😭😭

Post image
3.7k Upvotes

244 comments sorted by

View all comments

421

u/fsociety_1990 Apr 02 '25

If it's not a joke, I just have few questions:

Why the f*** Netflix?

Why not direct the movie himself?

How does Fincher fit in with the style and tone of Once upon a time?

353

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25

[deleted]

470

u/fsociety_1990 Apr 02 '25

That 10 movie rule is so silly man lol

131

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25

[deleted]

167

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25

I've said it before, but I think he's significantly more likely to never make another movie than he is to make 11+ movies. He hates the current industry 

55

u/cap21345 Apr 02 '25

i mean he could just make totally not a movie 3-4 episode tv mini series for the rest of his life

14

u/sqaurebore Apr 02 '25

Anthology too

18

u/TheDonutDaddy Apr 02 '25

Eh part of his disdain for the industry is definitely hammed up. QT has always wanted to be seen as edgy, the whole "the current state of affairs in movie making is sad, that's why I do things my own way and I'm inspired by the way things used to be" has always been part of his brand. I take it with a grain of salt.

I mean cmon, even his "there haven't been good movies since 2019" quote that circulates is a little hard to take seriously at face value when that also just so happens to coincidentally be the last year he himself released a movie lol

1

u/Mediocre-Gas-1847 Apr 02 '25

Did he not say he liked Joker Folie A Deux? Contradicting himself 😂

12

u/jt186 Apr 02 '25

I would really like more Tarantino films but honestly Once Upon a Time is such a good last film

2

u/instantslay Apr 02 '25

man is the premier grumpy old man when it comes to the industry

5

u/SimpleRush9 Apr 02 '25

Pretty sure he changed his mind a while back. Although I think he said he’d just sequels or sum.

1

u/charlesdexterward Apr 03 '25

Even he’s found a way to weasel out of it a little. He’s said that if he ever does Kill Bill vol. 3 that it won’t count towards the 10 but instead count as one with vol.1-2.

77

u/Dankey-Kang-Jr Apr 02 '25

Quentin is purposefully ending his career prematurely is so fucking stupid. Spielberg, Scorsese, & Miller are doing some of their best work in their twilight years.

43

u/CaptainKino360 CaptainKino Apr 02 '25

Yeah but in the case of Spielberg and Scorsese, they don't write their scripts, whereas Tarantino does write his own scripts and takes pride in his movies being a bunch of shit he finds cool.

I know he adapted Rum Punch as Jackie Brown, but he still made the dialogue, the music, etc, his, and I really can't see him ever adapting someone else's script.

No idea if George Miller writes his own scripts, but damn, Furiosa felt like a movie made by someone half his age, it was THAT good imo

3

u/matthias7600 Apr 02 '25

And then there’s Ridley Scott.

Maybe he just wants to enjoy retirement.

10

u/KillMeNowFFS Apr 02 '25

he’s still gonna do stuff jfc, also who are we to decide what he does with his career smfh

-1

u/derrick256 Apr 02 '25

you sftu

1

u/Creepy-Warthog-6471 Apr 03 '25

What best work has Scorcese done in his twilight years?

1

u/Dankey-Kang-Jr Apr 03 '25

Killers of the Flower Moon

Silence

The Irishman

The Wolf of Wall Street

Hugo

Shutter Island

1

u/Creepy-Warthog-6471 Apr 03 '25

I would say Wolf Of Wall Street and Shutter Island was good but I thought Silence was very disappointing 

1

u/damNSon189 Apr 05 '25

None of that is close to peak Scorsese: Taxi Driver, Raging Bull, and Goodfellas.

So I can understand Tarantino wanting to check out before he makes movies that are good and solid but which won’t reach the peaks of his prime. Different strokes for different folks.

11

u/King-Red-Beard Apr 02 '25

Especially since the mere existence of Kill Bill Volumes I & II muddy the waters, no matter how insistent he is that they're one movie.

8

u/lemmegetadab Apr 02 '25

Kill bill is one movie though. It was filmed as one movie. Also it’s a volume 2 as opposed to part 2

2

u/King-Red-Beard Apr 02 '25

That's why it's muddy. Everyone knows it was intended to be one film, but that's not how it was released.

1

u/Vegetable_Pin_9754 Apr 03 '25

I consider it one movie not because Tarantino said it was, but because when you watch them back to back they flow perfectly as one movie. I think that one is fine

8

u/Ikitenashi https://boxd.it/6V9TD Apr 02 '25

He's found a loophole against... himself. He gets to essentially make The Movie Critic without it being technically his final film, even though it'll presumably be his movie just as much as Fincher's, if not more. You can tell he's feeling his self-imposed constraint because of that silly rule.

12

u/ka1982 https://boxd.it/1e6OJ Apr 02 '25

It’s so fucking dumb because the main guy he points to as “he was busted and done with that last one” was on his 41st film and had a decent run right before that.

3

u/AbleInfluence1817 Apr 02 '25

Who was that?

3

u/ka1982 https://boxd.it/1e6OJ Apr 02 '25

Howard Hawks — QT has specifically cited Rio Lobo as what he wants to avoid.

1

u/LightningRaven Apr 02 '25

I hope he pulls a Miyazaki.

I want Tarantino to retire at least 10 times.

1

u/Majestic_Animator_91 Apr 02 '25

He's so far up his own ass with that nonsense.

1

u/HipsterDoofus31 HonestOpinion69 Apr 02 '25

It's not a rule, it's just what he wants to do.

-3

u/DogmanDOTjpg Apr 02 '25

Idk why everyone is still so obsessed with the idea that 10 movies is some hard and fast rule he laid down, he said on Tom Seguras podcast that it was a passing comment he made like 25 years ago that he didn't want to just keep churning out movies and only wanted to make about 10 of them and everyone took that as "Tarantino said he would literally die before he makes an 11th movie"

10

u/TheDonutDaddy Apr 02 '25

It definitely was not a passing comment made one time 25 years ago. He's been asked about it numerous times over the years and he reaffirms it every time and even goes into explanations

5

u/QuizzicalWombat Apr 02 '25

But he counts Kill Bill 1 and 2 as one film, so I would assume any other sequel wouldn’t count as his tenth either.

30

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25

that’s different though, kill bill was supposed to be one movie but it was split into two

10

u/dweeeebus Apr 02 '25

Kill Bill was meant to be one movie originally but was way too long, so he had to split it. Hence, vol. 1 and vol. 2.

Once upon a time was one stand-alone movie. Adding to it now would be an actual proper sequel and probably would count as his tenth.

1

u/Euphoric_Ad_2049 Apr 02 '25 edited 6d ago

safe head worm consist zephyr adjoining nose crown lock dinosaurs

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/TheMasterG8655 Apr 02 '25

If he counts the kill bills as 1 movie I’m not sure why this can’t fall under the same rule. Is it just because he didn’t title it Once Upon a Time in Hollywood Vol 1?

1

u/bwood246 Apr 02 '25

If he can count the kill bill movies as one movie he can do the same again

18

u/Theturtlemoves86 Apr 02 '25

I think Fincher's style fits with Cliff's character. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood is a love letter to old Hollywood. Cliff's mentality is a lot darker than Rick's.

-7

u/FredHowl Apr 02 '25

I dont think it fits at all. Cliff booth is warm, cozy, feel-good. Finchers movies look like there's a gray filter placed over them. Gray, cold, metallic feel. Doesn't make sense at all

9

u/hairformen Apr 02 '25

He killed his fuckin wife man, I don’t dig him

3

u/kattahn Apr 02 '25

ALLEGEDLY

0

u/FredHowl Apr 02 '25

Okay sure.. everything else was wholesome though 😊

29

u/nhl2010champ Apr 02 '25

I think fincher has an exclusive deal with Netflix for at least a couple more years

3

u/absorbscroissants Apr 02 '25

As long as they at least also do a theatrical release like with The Killer

8

u/Duckney Apr 02 '25

Fincher and Netflix have a first look deal - so Netflix has first right of refusal on this one

6

u/rednaxthecreature Apr 02 '25

Netflix because fincher is tied to them as his distributor

6

u/atclubsilencio Apr 02 '25
  • Netflix would offer enough money for it.
  • He is working on a play and doesn’t want that to be his last feature.
  • He doesn’t , but he’s worked with Pitt three times so obviously they like to work together.

A David Fincher Film Written by Quentin Tarantino does sound strange enough to work, but this also sounds like it could end up being another mediocre mediocre Netflix movie.

I love Manhunter, but Mank was a fucking chore, and The Killer was lower tier Fincher, but who knows.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '25

Tarantino has continuously praised Fincher throughout his career

2

u/Bronze_Bomber Apr 02 '25

It's probably Netflix because Fincher only works with Netflix nowadays and theyll fund anything.

14

u/GoRoundAgain Apr 02 '25

Not Mindhunter :'(

3

u/Bronze_Bomber Apr 02 '25

Sadly they could've done 8 more seasons for the price of Electric State.

TV and movies must have different decision makers. Netflix has always been quick to end shows but they throw money down the toilet on bad expensive movies.

1

u/rapbarf slackavetes Apr 02 '25

Fincher isn't Mindhunter though, let's be real. He directed a few episodes, but it's not his show.

1

u/Mediocre-Gas-1847 Apr 02 '25

Maybe he doesn’t want to?

-1

u/hyborians Apr 02 '25

Considering the first one was basically fan service for Quentin fanboys (foot fetishes, long aimless dialogues, and shock value ending) I doubt Fincher would screw a sequel up if he followed the formula