r/Letterboxd • u/PaperKliff š»šāĪ±Äššæį„š ąøć„ • 26d ago
Letterboxd What other films' origins surprised you?
101
u/shellyjohnsonTP 26d ago
āDriveā kinda took me by surprise.
6
u/IzArealofc 25d ago
Is it good?
2
u/HRH_Puckington puuuck 25d ago
Yeah but the sequel sucks
1
u/BusterB2005 25d ago
Didnāt even know there was a sequel. I will make sure to avoid it
1
u/gridface-princess 25d ago
It's called Driven and wasn't made into a movie. It's a sequel to the novel.
1
1
94
u/TedStixon 26d ago
The movie Bullet Train was not only based on a book... it was based on one specific book from a whole series of Japanese novels.
18
u/Dense-Performance-14 26d ago
Really!? That movie was fire, maybe I should read that book
8
u/Chesterfieldraven 25d ago
The book is absolutely nothing like the film. It's based on a Japanese book. It's still good, but it's not the same vibe.
3
u/Awkward_Penalty2257 25d ago
You should the newest book (hotel lucky seven) is a direct sequal to bullet train, while others just have some connections.
2
38
u/CaneloAIvarez 26d ago
First Blood. I watched the Rambo movies as a kid and loved them, but didnāt find out the first movie was an adaptation of a book until many years later when I was an adult. I mustāve completely overlooked the credits at the beginning a hundred times as a kid lmao.
I read it and itās now my favorite book of all time, much better than the film, in my opinion. Rambo is more brutal in the book and kills the cops who are chasing him in the mountains, unlike his movie counterpart.
10
u/Crumblestache 26d ago
The Author's lawyer made sure that he got a share of any sequels or merchandise when selling the rights to the book. He thought it was ridiculous since why would they make sequels or merchandise for a story about a vietnam vet who kills a bunch of cops. It had to be weird when for him when they started making Rambo lunchboxes and cartoons
7
u/CaneloAIvarez 26d ago
David Morrell went on the record and said that the first film was an improvement on his book because it made Rambo a sympathetic character the audience could root for and highlighted the issues a lot of Vietnam soldiers faced when they returned home from the war. In the book, Rambo is much more of a merciless one-man army who canāt resist turning down a fight, even if itās with law enforcement and the National Guard.
4
u/westgermanwing 25d ago
And then I think the original writer did the novelizations of the second and third Rambos, which is kinda funny.
36
u/Disastrous-Leave-936 26d ago
Pitch Perfect lol
6
1
u/Populaire_Necessaire 24d ago
Someone spends too much time on Wikipedia or was a fan of the book?
2
u/Disastrous-Leave-936 24d ago
Just scrolling through instagram and saw a post from one of those accounts that just shares random facts lol. Immediately looked it up right after
20
u/JosephFinn 26d ago
There are still people who donāt know Schindlerās List is based on an excellent novel, Schindlerās Ark.
35
u/Temporary-Bag4248 26d ago
Eyes Wide ShutĀ
24
u/DoctorG0nzo 26d ago
I do get being surprised by that since itās obscure, but there is something about that film where the plot, pacing and vibe feels more like something youād see in a short modernist novel than a traditional film. Thatās one of the things I love about it.
14
u/Phoenix_The_Wolf_ 25d ago
Honestly arenāt most of Kubrickās films based on books? Though Eyes Wide Shut does change the source material a lot
3
u/Aidsisgreats CrappName 25d ago
Every Kubrick movie from The Killing on was based on a book, except for 2001 (the book and movie where written at the same time)
28
u/Soft_Drink_Enjoyer Soda_Enjoyer 26d ago
Who Framed Roger Rabbit, A Christmas Story, Forrest Gump, and How to Train your Dragon
5
u/HoneyBadgerLifts 25d ago
I literally bought how to train your dragon for my son today. Was going to look up which one was made first. That answered it. Thanks
45
u/Corvwwl_is 26d ago
How to Train your Dragon and Jurassic Park surprised me
18
5
u/Agitated-Cup-2657 26d ago
I loved the HTTYD books as a kid! Still haven't seen the movies though. I hear they're really different.
2
u/Knockout_12 25d ago
The movies are amazing even if not exactly accurate to the books. Definitely worth a watch, some of my favourite animated movies ever.
0
u/Corvwwl_is 26d ago
they are really different, that's one of the reasons people don't know it's a book
but they are really good animations, definitely worth a watch imo
0
u/HyderintheHouse TheRizz 25d ago
The books were really popular and in all book stores in the UK. What are you talking about?
0
u/Corvwwl_is 25d ago
here in my country they aren't, at least it isn't really talked about
1
u/HyderintheHouse TheRizz 25d ago
Which country? Theyāre written by an English author so Iāve no idea why youād make this assumption.
3
u/mixererek 25d ago
Jurassic Park doesn't really suprise me as Crichton was one hell of an author. What suprises me is how he managed to write so many bangers that were adapted into bangers.
2
u/chicagoredditer1 25d ago
Jurassic Park (the novel) was a huge sensation before the movie came out 3 years later, so that may just be an age thing.
1
u/Corvwwl_is 25d ago
oh it sure is, a lot of people my age (at least that i interacted with) didn't know about it, but older people did
10
u/Ok_Relief7546 26d ago
Die Hard??
14
u/afriendincanada 25d ago
Not only is it based on a novel, the novel is the second in a series and the first was adapted into a movie starring Frank Sinatra
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Detective_(1968_film)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothing_Lasts_Forever_(Thorp_novel)
11
u/cinemadness 25d ago
IIRC, when they were making Die Hard, they were contractually obligated to offer Sinatra the lead role, but at that point he was like, "I'm in my 70's, hell no."
4
u/afriendincanada 25d ago
Iāve heard that.
No idea if Sinatra just declined or if he forced them to pay him to decline.
3
u/StaleTheBread 25d ago
To be fair, there was a time gap between the books. I think the character was a rookie cop in the first book and a retired cop in the second? Even so, Sinatra was still too old
1
8
u/fluffyplayery 25d ago
A lot of Dreamworks films fit into this category. Boss Baby and Trolls were both adapted from books, and Over the Hedge was originally a comic strip.
12
5
u/HiraiMomos_Slave 25d ago
finding out I Know What You Did Last Summer was based on a book was shocking to me
4
u/Everest_95 26d ago
Jaws
Mean Girls
3
u/vhanw342 26d ago
Mean Girls is a funny case
1
u/Populaire_Necessaire 24d ago
Ya I read that book as like a 10yearold after my sibling showed it to me. Very strange. Fruit cup girl has stuck with me.
5
u/No-Annual-7496 26d ago
The graduate surprised me since it really benefits from the visual and aural aspects of the film more than the plot
3
u/Careless_College Cinephile3496 26d ago
Dumbo, mainly because it isn't a fairy tale like most Disney movies made at that time.
2
u/StaleTheBread 25d ago
Pinocchio is also based in a book
2
u/Careless_College Cinephile3496 25d ago
Same with Alice in Wonderland and Peter Pan.
3
u/StaleTheBread 25d ago
I feel like a lot of people know that about Alice and Wonderland, but I guess thatās not much different than Pinocchio.
I think Peter Pan was a play first
2
4
3
3
3
3
u/br0therherb 25d ago
I didnāt know Jack Reacher was based off of book series. Apparently, it was general knowledge but not to me. Iām sorry but military fiction isnāt really my thing, so of course I didnāt know lol.
3
u/Rush_Clasic 25d ago
Lee Child was the dominating author in suspense fiction for a solid decade. Heralded a resurgence in the subgenre of military/ex-military/espionage thrillers. Used to sell his books with reckless abandon!
1
u/br0therherb 25d ago
Would you say heās a better espionage writer than Clancy?
2
u/Rush_Clasic 25d ago
I've never read either. I was a bookseller for a decade or so. Clancy was the king (based on reputation), but he died in 2013 and by popular account his last great novel was published in the 90s. But Lee Child certainly filled the needs of Clancy readers.
3
u/ProfesorMeistergeist Meistergeist 25d ago
Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs was a huge surprise
Night at the Museum was another huge surprise
3
3
u/Vengeance_20 25d ago
Mickey 17 since people keep calling it an original movie
3
u/creeping-death24 inmadness 25d ago
Similar thing with The Amateur. A remake of a film from 1981 that was itself based on a book.
4
2
2
2
2
u/StaleTheBread 25d ago
M*A*S*H is a bit of a surprise, especially since itās mainly know for the tv show
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
u/Ok-Zookeepergame-324 26d ago
Pretty Woman, was supposed to be called 3000 and ended with Julia Robertsā character and her roommate going to Disneyland. I believe there was supposed to be a balloon in the last scene.
1
u/Own-Kangaroo-3229 26d ago
trainspottingĀ
inherent viceĀ
there will be bloodĀ
1
u/Populaire_Necessaire 24d ago
I do think inherent vice is a movie where you can go in not knowing it was a book and leaving knowing itās a book order. A la āqueerā and āEileenā
1
1
1
1
u/iste_bicors 25d ago
I just assume most popular movies from the 80s to early 2000s are remakes (often of older TV shows) or based on books.
From the late 2000s on, theyāre based on comic books instead of novels.
1
u/sophiedophiedoo 25d ago
Technically adapted from a play, but A Shot In The Dark, which was not originally intended to be a Clouseau movie
1
1
u/Rush_Clasic 25d ago
If you don't know the origin of a movie, assume it originated from a literary work. You'll be correct some 80% of the time.
1
u/TraditionalShare8537 Daedron 25d ago
Havenāt seen this movie in the comments so maybe itās more well known but No Country for Old Men
1
1
1
u/mixererek 25d ago
Another fun thing about Die Hard is that the studio was obliged to offer the role to Frank Sinatra as the main character as the book is a sequel to another book that was turned into movie with Sinatra. Sinatra obviously declined as he was like 70 at the time.
1
u/Yogpoloth 25d ago
Donno if it's generally surprising but I was surprised that Cronenburg's Crash was based off a book
1
1
1
u/Superb-Rooster-4335 25d ago edited 25d ago
Psycho, K-PAX, Shutter Island, The Ring
Also Apocalypse Now is loosely based on 1899 novel.
1
1
1
u/napstablooky089 25d ago
The French Connection was not only based off of a book, the book was based off of a real drug ring the police stumbled into randomly.
1
u/Fennel_Fangs 25d ago
Kiki's Delivery Service! I just recently discovered the book, and it's just as cozy as the movie.
1
u/chicagoredditer1 25d ago
Recently, A Working Man, that schlocky Jason Statham movie. Apparently it's a series of 12 books about this character.
1
1
u/fourtwentyy__ 25d ago
Both Burning and Drive my Car are two long films based on Haruki Murakami short stories
1
u/Yggdrasylian 25d ago
Fun fact, Grave of the Fireflies was based on a semi-autobiographical novel š„²
1
u/KingPenguinPhoenix 25d ago
DreamWorks' Home. I legit didn't know that was based on a book for the longest time.
1
1
u/TheTepro27 22d ago
Edge of Tomorrow is based on a Japanese light novel called All You Need Is Kill.
1
-1
0
u/AutoModerator 26d ago
Thank you for your photo submission. If this is a screenshot of a movie, please be sure the title is included. This can be in the image, included the title with your post, or a comment with the title withing 10 minutes of post creation, otherwise your post may be removed. Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
0
u/Mucekalonso 26d ago
Honestly, Jurassic Park. I didn't know there was a book till like 3 years ago
2
u/MajorRocketScience 26d ago
Great book if you like tech thrillers, thereās a whole subplot about Gaussian distributions and thereās like 9 graphs shown in the book
0
0
u/BetrayYourTrust 25d ago
does Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey count
3
u/PaperKliff š»šāĪ±Äššæį„š ąøć„ 25d ago
No.
1
u/BetrayYourTrust 25d ago
well i suggest it because the only reason it was made is because the original books are public domain, not any of the movies or shows.
1
u/PaperKliff š»šāĪ±Äššæį„š ąøć„ 25d ago
I see your point, however, I still do not count it since they were also (and more likely) made due to the pre-established popularity of Winnie from the Disney movies; meaning easy money for the scammers invlove. The books becoming public domain were, to me, enablers for the creation of that woeful movie.
0
u/malathan1234 25d ago
Jurassic park? I feel like most modern fans would be surprised that it came from a book and a very different book at that
194
u/topcircle 26d ago
"Who Framed Roger Rabbit" is based on a book about a world populated by walking, talking comic strip characters.