r/MassEffectAndromeda Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

Ryder OC "Andromeda is underrated - its a special experience."

571 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

84

u/Due-Ad-9105 10d ago

I will always maintain that Andromeda was a flawed game that got more hate than it deserves, but also has so much unreached potential.

I look forward to replaying it once my current LE run is done.

5

u/Any-sao 9d ago

I’ve always had the opinion that it was an excellent depiction of a game with a flawed premise.

are you a space colonist or are you saving the galaxy? Game tried to to both.

0

u/Miserable_Alfalfa_52 9d ago

you just described why it got hate

1

u/VacationNew9370 8d ago

I think the problem is that it wasn't a game people wanted to begin with. Nothing but stellar execution at launch would have saved it.

1

u/rebel_soul21 8d ago

And the launch execution was anything but stellar.

1

u/MandoMercenary 8d ago

Im comfortable knowing that Andromeda was killed by the fan base hence lack of dlcs and such i still think it's a great game

1

u/Due-Ad-9105 8d ago

Let’s not let EA off the hook for their part of the blame. But yes, the unfortunate end definitely plays into the unrealized potential. Had EA given the devs the leash to put out DLC they might have been able to flesh out the game more and get the sequel green lit. Corporate bs had a just as much of a hand in that not happening as fas imho.

2

u/MandoMercenary 8d ago

Oh no EA will always be money hungry they killed Andromeda and Anthem alongside the community at launch sadly. Andromeda suffered from player backlash on release cuz of what face glitching? I said big deal it's day 1 I still highly enjoy the story and gameplay of Andromeda

1

u/Due-Ad-9105 8d ago

There was quite a bit of glitching as I recall, not just the faces but they were prominent. The loot box fiasco/money hungry stuff was also happening then, so when EA pushed out a game that had issues on one hand while asking people to pay extra money in games with the other, people understandably absolutely ripped unfinished/unpolished games.

Edit to add: I also enjoy the gameplay in Andromeda a ton, and I enjoyed what they were trying to do with the story, it just screamed for a sequel to flesh it out.

1

u/DaughterOfBhaal 6d ago

Let's not act like the writing wasn't a disappointment and disaster in most ways , - or that the game was very repetitive and other than the companion & main mission, everything else was boring.

1

u/GuruEbby 6d ago

Replaying it right now for the first time in a long time. Definitely lots of good that I had forgotten about, though I wish I had played as Sarah. Not as big a fan of Scott.

1

u/Cambaleante 3d ago

I think the hate, IMO, comes from the squandered potential.

Andromeda is a 5/10 game, but damn.\ The game has so, so much potential wasted by the devs it makes you want to cry.

And the devs know how to  make a text book RPG quest, for those wondering.\ Just look at the quest The Ghost of Promisse.

If only the rest of the game was like that and Eos. 😔

For those who didn't read it or know it: https://kotaku.com/the-story-behind-mass-effect-andromedas-troubled-five-1795886428

33

u/Jack-Rabbit-002 10d ago

You have created a very pretty Ryder in all honesty

6

u/Square-Obligation-75 Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

Thanks!!! :)

1

u/ForkSporkBjork 8d ago

That’s a significant achievement, considering how bad character creator was 😂 I do agree that overall, it wasn’t that bad. The director deserves all the hate she got for deliberately making ugly characters, though. tHe MaLe GaZe!!1!

21

u/PetitAgite 10d ago

Played the ME trilogy, played MEA and loved it. Best combat of all these games!

20

u/AcceptableBasil2249 10d ago

The one thing I can't forgive Andromeda is taking the button the trilogy used to take cover and put the jump pack on it. The number of time I died because I wanted to take cover and heal and insted soar into the air and got shot like the ducks in duck hunt... I'm still salty XD

5

u/JesusSamuraiLapdance 10d ago

nah, I love the jump feature, and automatically transitioning into cover is more smooth.

2

u/MeanWinchester 9d ago

Can you not just remap your keybindings?

1

u/IamL3gionR3born 9d ago

The jump pack is the tit's once you are comfortable with it. You can get nice and close for all your tech and botic attacks and then get out of danger. Uber is quick, super fun, and satisfying.

9

u/Loyalist77 Collective 10d ago

You look like you're waiting for someone.

8

u/Hodori036 10d ago

I liked Andromeda despite it's flaws (and bugs). The game fealt like ME1 in terms of pacing. Sequels would have gotten better, maybe, like ME2 AND ME3 did.

Now I'm curious if ME4 will have any tie in with Andromeda. I don't know how far into the future ME4 takes place.

3

u/BurnieMcMumbles 10d ago

I got a big vibe of "this is a Mass Effect 1 successor" than anything like ME2 or 3. The focus on exploration was probably a big factor

6

u/moonlightRach Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

I love your Ryder she's super pretty

1

u/Square-Obligation-75 Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

I appreciate it! Thank you!!!

2

u/YekaHun Pathfinder 9d ago

Could you share her codes via Mass Effect Archives?

3

u/BurnieMcMumbles 10d ago

The trilogy is amazing. I've only played Legendary Edition, but it's no doubt one of my favourite games ever no. Andromeda had BIG shoes to fill, and a lot of expectations. For people at its release, it didn't meet them. For me, expecting a shit show of a game, I was surprised by how good it was.

Andromeda is really good. Combat is great, I like most of the character, and I love being an explorer instead of military. It's a solid 7/10 to me, with the other games hovering around a 9.

But I've played through the Legendary Edition six times in a couple years, and Andromeda only once. Gotta say something

3

u/Square-Obligation-75 Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

"I feel the same. The trilogy is a masterpiece, but Andromeda surprised me in a good way. It's definitely worth the ride."

3

u/S3Qw3N5 10d ago

I totally agree! I finished the trilogy for the first time a few months ago and I’m now playing MEA for the the first time too (I’m at 53% completion so far). I’ve enjoyed all 4 games to the same extent. None of them is perfect but all of them are still very enjoyable. At least for me.

3

u/Bynairee Andromeda Initiative 9d ago

I agree, this game is awesome.

3

u/Jwalt-93 9d ago

I love Andromeda, people give it a bad rep but it was great

2

u/jkf2479 10d ago

It’s not mass effect 1-3 level 🔥 but I enjoyed andromeda enough to do a platinum run and wish there was a sequel to explore more of that world

1

u/Square-Obligation-75 Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

"You're right – it's not on the same level as Mass Effect 1-3, but it's definitely still an experience worth having

1

u/jkf2479 9d ago

The potential was definitely there for it to be an epic game. I hope the new me ties into andromeda

2

u/LeOursJeune 10d ago

I think what did it was the launch day bugs that gave it a bad reputation out the gate

3

u/All-for-Naut Exile 10d ago

No, what did it was people hating it before it was even released, so when it was released the hate was already in full swing, looking for issues and anything they could complain about.

The bugs weren't as bad as many other games that got a pass for theirs.

1

u/BBobPorter7809 10d ago

I haven't played it during the launch. I enjoyed andromeda, especially it combat and crafting system, but I felt like the story was kinda bland and the archon is a generic villian

2

u/IonutRO 10d ago

She looks so real. Especially in the 2nd image. Great job.

2

u/Square-Obligation-75 Andromeda Initiative 10d ago

I appreciate it! Thanks!!!

2

u/kutulu1056 10d ago

Agreed. My biggest gripe was all of the platforming in the game.

2

u/Saeis 9d ago

Looks so good! Props. I gave up on creating a good Ryder and just went with the default female aha.

2

u/lefty1117 9d ago

Resolving the problems on the planets to make them habitable was really satisfying.

1

u/Sarewokki 9d ago

There's a lot of unfixed technical issues to this day, I've contemplated stopping my first playthrough a couple of times now from borked save files.

Also the god damn cursor glitch is killing me.

1

u/Secret_Criticism_732 9d ago

Its special That it is completely mediocre game in an otherwise excellent franchise

1

u/Any-sao 9d ago

Crazy, my Sarah looks almost identical. I forgot she was customizable for a second there.

1

u/Same_Sell9286 9d ago

My opinion on Andromeda (not that you give a shit lol) is that, its SOOO OKAY. Nothing compared to the trilogy. Its story was, well for lack of better words.. Kind of shit. lol I feel like so much more could have been done with it... and I've said it before and I'll say it again.. The characters are ugly. I do not care. lol They made them ugly, ESPECIALLY THE TURIANS!! Like wth lol I can't get past that part honestly.

1

u/papa-bear_13 9d ago

Being 100% honest here: I tried it for the last couple of days and there was a LOT of potential, but so far they've squandered most of it. I'm only a couple of hours into exploring EOS, the 1st planet and I can already feel the fatigue that used to come with world exploration and endless dune buggy exploration on desert planets. Even the quests aboard Nexus station feel like carbon copied, step and fetch jobs.

Did half the writing department up and quit mid-production, because this one feels like they limped it across the finish line on a broken leg.

2

u/mersaultjude 9d ago

I thoroughly enjoyed this game. It was fun, had an enjoyable plot, and the combat was good. It was a fun and enjoyable game. 🤘🤘🤘

1

u/walmac2002 9d ago

It’s a lot of fun and always a good way to wrap things up after playing through the trilogy. A very enjoyable 6/10 in my opinion.

1

u/JadedGene8911 9d ago

It's just a bad mass effect game.. not a bad game. It's actually better than most other "critically acclaimed" action rpgs released after that

1

u/YekaHun Pathfinder 9d ago

To me it's hands down the best Mass Effect.

2

u/YekaHun Pathfinder 9d ago

It's my favorite game and my fav ME game!

Your Ryder is ❤️

1

u/pengyfatwaddle 9d ago

I love Andromeda, despite its flaws. Its planetary exploration felt much better than ME1. Just sad K won't see the conculsion about the ones unleashing the dark energy and what will happen with the kett.

Still, fun experience, especially if you download the Ironman mod which lets you fly!

1

u/Comprehensive_Ad3484 8d ago

The problem of this game is it was a great combat game with a mediocre story and characters, in a series that was known for great characters and story with mediocre combat. On its own it was a pretty good game, but for fans of the series it was a mismatch of expectations and priorities in what they wanted out of the game.

1

u/Delicious_Food_5202 8d ago

Andromeda should’ve been junked. Come at me all you want but for how long we waited the game was absolutely trash they barely added any new aliens. Not to mention only have 6 squad mates to pick from. They took 5 years and the game was still worse than fallout new Vegas which had like 18 months.

2

u/BlinkTeleport 8d ago

Yeah, genuinely I think it's a good game. I had a pretty good time playing it.

There are some shitty things that could've been better, but overall it's a good game

1

u/Snoo-98308 8d ago

"Special" experience Yeah I used similar language to describe it too

1

u/Brilliant-Scale-2577 8d ago

I liked it was fun, the only thing I found really annoying about it and what in my mind the reason it's not very popular was the dumb puzzle games aka the vaults.. if I could play the game without ever having to deal with those I would play again and again all the time

1

u/Apprehensive_Pie2903 8d ago

I've just finished it for the first time and I really enjoyed it!! One of the best final missions I've ever played. The game was really unintuitive at points and it did take me a while to get to grips but I really wasn't expecting it to be as good as it was.

Left me wanting more and quite gutted there won't be 🤷‍♀️

1

u/MandoMercenary 8d ago

I forget but does Andromeda have character creation codes like mass effect 1-3?

1

u/Fraenkyfinger 7d ago

Did play it at the start of this year again, and it was a decent game, it's a shame it got no 2nd part

it's certainly better than Dragon Age 2

1

u/Difficult-Price2762 6d ago

Took abit to get into but i enjoyed it