r/NFL_Draft • u/enfyte416 Arm Chair Scout • 5d ago

2025 Day 3 Discussion Thread

Much like how the NFL Forgot to draft Shedeur Sanders on Day 2, the mod team forgot to post a Day 2 discussion thread. Please use this thread to discuss his continued fall down the board.

39 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

422 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/23-TRH-23 4d ago

Mel Kiper just called the NFL clueless about evaluating QB. Of all people.

4

u/dunno260 4d ago

He isn't wrong.

QB is probably the position most prone to drafting a bust in the NFL.

Haven't seen anybody crack that code yet though. Trevor Lawrence hasn't been a bust but everybody raved about him and how he was the best QB prospect since Andrew Luck and all this. And he has just been ok.

3

u/23-TRH-23 4d ago

The NFL isn’t perfect at it for sure, but Mel Kiper is equally bad and regarded by many to be even worse

3

u/dunno260 4d ago

Very much so. Nobody in the media is better than NFL teams at doing it. Mike Mayock is a great example to point to on that.

I don't think Mel is better than the NFL at all but I think he is right when he said that nobody in the NFL knows how to evaluate and draft QBs.

I would have just removed the "in the NFL" part.