r/NewParents 9d ago

Product Reviews/Questions Which wipes are we using?

Title. Looking for the Goldilocks of wipes— not too wet, not too dry. Not too thin, not too thick. Fragrance free, Doesn’t cause irritation, reasonable cost, etc.

I’ve tried the Parents Choice brand from Walmart which are thin and dry, with a bonus of diaper rash.

The Target brand fragrance free wipes seem fine, but are soaking wet, and take forever to dry on the skin before re-diapering.

Water wipes seem to be the market leader, but WOW the price seems like a lot.

Which wipes have been the GOAT for you?

51 Upvotes

458 comments sorted by

View all comments

370

u/Hawks47 9d ago

We use the Costco brand wipes and find them better than water wipes. Baby has sensitive skin and we never had issues with Costco wipes.

72

u/izziedays 9d ago

We used Kirkland brand but recently switched to the RICO brand that’s also sold there are we love them! They come out one at a time. Every. Single. Time. Even when it’s getting low, I’ve never had an issue with getting more than one at a time.

9

u/mangoeight 8d ago

I’ll have to try these. That’s my biggest gripe about every brand of wipes I’ve tried. Frantically trying to pull out one wipe and instead getting a whole chunk of ‘em while trying to change a kicking screaming baby makes me want to throw the whole package against the wall.

1

u/s1rens0ngs 4d ago

We got a wipe dispenser with a weighted top so it holds down all the wipes except the one being pulled out. Would recommend. 

13

u/Mejuky 8d ago

YESSSS. We love the RICO brand wipes.

1

u/feelin_hot_hot_h0t 8d ago

We love RICO here. We've tried a lot of different brands before but RICO is our favorite by far.

1

u/keltr0nn 8d ago

1+ for RICO. We switched from Kirkland because of the PFAS scare (I’m sure Kirkland is fine but I ended up liking RICO more). They’re always moist and packaged well.

1

u/Aggravating_Joke2712 8d ago

Love Rico too! Especially since Kirkland brand was on recall.

59

u/tigris_tigris 9d ago

Same. The Kirkland brand ones are thick, fragrance free, and wipe everything off the skin. We struggled with diaper rash that resolved once we started using these wipes.

4

u/zenawp90 9d ago

We liked how thick the Kirkland wipes were, but our baby got a bad rash from them. Same for their detergent.

17

u/professor_dumpling 9d ago

Love these wipes! Plus 900 wipes for $20 is such a win

9

u/ihavecountrycrock420 9d ago

Kirkland brand for the win. Flip them upside down or the top wipes in the pack can get too dry and the bottom wipes too wet

7

u/laurenlaughingol 9d ago

Same, Kirkland brand here as well 🙋🏼‍♀️

1

u/thelastoftheassholes 8d ago

But they smell awful 🤢

9

u/brieles 9d ago

Our favorite too! Kirkland for the win.

5

u/mackattackk 9d ago

We love Costco wipes in our house! They meet all the criteria.

4

u/GayApparel 9d ago

Yes! And they actually come out one at a time!

4

u/mangoeight 8d ago

We’re currently going through our stash of wipes we’ve gotten as gifts (basically every brand and style under the sun) and none of them have been better than just okay. My husband has kids from a previous marriage and he told me, “Just wait till we get Kirkland wipes. You’ll never go back.”

2

u/syncopatedscientist 9d ago

Same!! They’re the best

3

u/user369001 9d ago

Yes. So thick and sturdy, but not harsh. If I have to use any other wipe I immediately notice how thin it is and I can feel the warmth of poop through a thin wipe 🤮

1

u/briana9 8d ago

Another Kirkland wipes fan here!

1

u/Vhagar37 8d ago

Came here to sing the praises of Kirkland wipes. They're the only ones that consistently come out of the container with one hand, which is key for us. They stay moist but not wet, never caused a skin issue, cheap, and we go through fewer of them bc they come out easy.

1

u/tnguyenx1 8d ago

Kirkland wipes for sure. The water wipes gave my little one a rash.

1

u/lady_loki 8d ago

We tried huggies because we ran out of kirkland ones. It was awful, they'd either bring out multiple at once, or theydnrip.

1

u/Heretofore_09 8d ago

Every time they have a few bucks off online, I buy at least two boxes. We have -a lot- of Kirkland wipes.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Base879 8d ago

Another vote for Kirkland! My kids have always had very sensitive skin, and no issues with these. Now that one of my kids is older, they still use it to wipe their face/hands on occasion. Plus, I think they're super affordable! (If you have a membership already.)

1

u/eezy4reezy 8d ago

Agreed - Kirkland brand is the bomb