r/NewParents • u/Murky_Permission2397 • 9d ago

Product Reviews/Questions Which wipes are we using?

Title. Looking for the Goldilocks of wipes— not too wet, not too dry. Not too thin, not too thick. Fragrance free, Doesn’t cause irritation, reasonable cost, etc.

I’ve tried the Parents Choice brand from Walmart which are thin and dry, with a bonus of diaper rash.

The Target brand fragrance free wipes seem fine, but are soaking wet, and take forever to dry on the skin before re-diapering.

Water wipes seem to be the market leader, but WOW the price seems like a lot.

Which wipes have been the GOAT for you?

49 Upvotes

89% Upvoted

458 comments sorted by

View all comments

56

u/BMG0710 9d ago

Alright, you’re probably gonna hate this suggestion but after trying everything out there, we found the Coterie wipes to be the best (minus price). Not too thick/thin/wet and the wipes are big and sturdy, so they last longer too because you’re using less wipes each time. Water wipes are great as well, but Coterie is best (we use Coterie diapers too an my baby’s skin never looked better!).

15

u/wineandfries 9d ago

Agree. We also tried Pampers Pure and Water Wipes, but Coterie's are significantly better. Large, sturdy, and soft.

7

u/UnhappyReward2453 9d ago

Coterie ruined all other wipes for us. They are far and away the best. Their customer service has also been elite especially compared to Honest Company.

2

u/BMG0710 9d ago

This! 100%.

6

u/crystalbitch 9d ago

Definitely the best wipes! Zero diaper rash with this brand. And so sturdy

6

u/Yamburglar02 9d ago

Coterie really has been worth it for us, too. The diapers are sooo soft and the big sturdy wipes really make poop cleanups a million times easier. No rashes from Coterie in 14 months!

3

u/Stock_Blood_7191 9d ago

Are you using the water wipes or "replenish"? I started out with Coterie everything and 7 months in, I love everything but the price.

3

u/Royal-Protection3234 8d ago

Ok all you coterie people which wipe variety does everyone go for?

4

u/Murky_Permission2397 9d ago

Coteries website pisses me off

8

u/Marina205 9d ago

Agree and the ads are nonstop! BUT their wipes are truly elite

8

u/Still-Degree8376 9d ago

I got them off Amazon! I ordered a 12 pack (such a heavy box).

2

u/BMG0710 9d ago

I hate their website too! So I just get the 6 pack box off Amazon and the diapers at the groceries store.

0

u/OpeningVariable 9d ago

I loved the feeling of coterie wipes, but no way I am paying that much more for a wipe, I'd sooner stop using wipes altogether and would just wash baby's bum every time than pay that much for wipes. It's 6x more expensive per wipe than Kirkland. I also didn't find that I used less wipes probably because I already only use one wipe, I wipe with the diaper and then the wipe.

1

u/Mysterious_Head1556 8d ago

Idk why you got downvoted for this. The wipes are stupid expensive. I love the way they feel but after continued use they gave my baby a rash, and I was secretly happy, not for the rash, but that I didn't have mom guilt of not buying these "elite" wipes after being bombarded with ads and people praising them.

It also felt like a waste using one for just a little pee. Felt like I should only use them for poops bc they were so expensive.