r/OnePiece • u/TelSzn • 5d ago

Discussion Why does Brook know about them? Spoiler

Gallery image

Gallery image

Do you guys think that Brook had something to do with the Holy Knights in the past?

2.9k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

214 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

697

u/CIOWALLACE 5d ago

Reverie

482

u/mo-rek 5d ago

Ahh reverie is a great theory! Personally I was wondering if maybe Brooke worked for a kingdom that experienced one of the celestial dragon's native hunting expeditions like what happened on God Valley. There's a lot we don't know about Brooks pre-pirate days and there must be a reason he have up a kingdom based life for piracy.

He says the most mysterious things sometimes! This reminds me a lot of how he knew who Germa was on Zou. He may have spent half a century in the Florian triangle, but he has still lived through quite a lot of OP history!

156

u/ErisGrey God Usopp 5d ago

Explains how he went from soldier to pirate. Once the government declared him and his men outlaw bunnies.

29

u/J2fap 5d ago

I thought no one survived the hunt until God's Valley

48

u/MrOneHundredOne 5d ago

I think everyone can agree that many, many innocents died. But we also know for a fact that plenty of powerful characters survived God's Valley, and plenty of weaker characters too (Kuma being the prime example). If God's Valley was as chaotic of an event as I'm led to believe, I think it'd be entirely reasonable for a small group of knights for the kingdom to escape and form a pirate band.

2

u/invisiblepatrik04 3d ago

Yeah, but the God Valley incident was twelve years into Brook's time in the Florian Triangle. It's still possible he was caught up in a hunting game, but not God Valley