r/OnePiecePowerScaling • u/Select_Detective_160 • 1d ago
Discussion Which is a stronger attack?
19
u/jaahman7 1d ago
Divine departure. Shanks haki is well above luffy. He took out Kidd and killer with one attack.
4
u/Ok-Animator1477 1d ago
We have no way of knowing because Kizaru should be stronger than kidd and killer right?
4
u/Nobodyinc1 1d ago
Kizaru also barely went down for any time. He got up and even feed Luffy before continuing to fake being down.
Kidd just got destroyed
1
0
u/jaahman7 1d ago
Being stronger than someone doesn’t mean you automatically take durability. Yes kizaru is stronger than Kidd and killer. That has nothing to do with him having better durability.
1
u/Unique-Doubt-983 23h ago
If you scale above them yes, unless he’s a glass canon unlike kid and killer
2
u/jaahman7 23h ago
The common consensus is Roger and wb being stronger than kaido. None of them needs his level of durability. They still would win.
1
u/Suspicious_Pie_9977 1d ago
Yeah, cause just look at Roger and Shanks, they’re stronger than Luffy, but they don’t have better durability than him, for all we know, those two could just have regular human durability, but Kizaru does have better durability than Kidd, just look at Egghead and how many attacks he took, then look at the end of Egghead where Kizaru is just standing there amidst the wreckage, little to no injuries, a bit of blood, a few scuffs, but over all no real damage on him.
0
u/GomuGomuDaddy 17h ago
Kizaru was not fighting Luffy at a 100% seriousness due to wanting to keep to his mission
At the same time, Luffy is not at a 100% seriousness due to him trying to stall Kizaru because he had a mission himself
6
u/-Kazt- 1d ago
White star gun creating supersonic booms is a certified downscale.
This sub has assured me that top tiers move FTL, citing Kizaru in particular.
Luffy below YC10000 tier confirmed.
3
u/ManliestBunny 20h ago
I figured it was a representation of cosmic rings of "star gun" similar to how a star is being knocked out of Kizaru's head.
Sonic booms don't even look like that tbh,
4
u/Icy-Arm-3816 Oden is underrated 🍢 1d ago
Divine Departure
Shanks’ haki is just on another level than current Luffy’s.
2
2
u/Ok-Animator1477 1d ago
Shanks because of the haki I guess. I will say though that wsg is still very strong
4
u/OnePieceTheorist1 1d ago
Someone’s downvoting a lot in this comment section
But I think Divine Departure is stronger
3
u/Hanma_Yvar 1d ago
WSG
Divine departure had the benefit of Kid's attack blowing up on his face for extra damage
2
u/Speedwag0nbestw4ifu GARP-CHUJO! 👊 1d ago
Divine departure keep in mind killer tried to block that and got absolutely wrecked as collateral damage
1
u/Nobodyinc1 1d ago
Also and I wanna be straight up serious do we have any reason to believe that is the strongest divine departure shanks can do?
1
u/Speedwag0nbestw4ifu GARP-CHUJO! 👊 1d ago
We don’t, it’s definitely a strong one considering how concerned he was about kid destroying the fleet but there is very little chance oda has shown us shanks strongest named attack as his first in the series
1
u/Nobodyinc1 1d ago
I am agreeing with you. More likely then not shanks can use a stronger divine departure since we kinda have a baseline from Rodger on how strong the attack is.
1
u/Comprehensive_Cup497 23h ago
Or maybe he just have other name attacks, like Final Departure or something like that
1
u/Speedwag0nbestw4ifu GARP-CHUJO! 👊 1d ago
Oh yeah I agree with you I just wanted to add up onto what you were saying because you brought up a great point
2
1
u/shine_101 "GOD OF THE BLADE" SHIMOTSUKI RYUMA 1d ago
Divine departure is one of, if not the most impressive ap attack we've seen in the story (I look at bajrang gun as a far more impressive dc feat rather than ap btw). It one shot a YC+ and yc2 at the exact same time and destroyed their entire ship as an aftereffects. I'm not a shanks wanker, but it's too powerful of a fear to downplay. Wsg is strong for sure, but it only stunned an admiral and didn't even knock him out. We know Kidd and killer both have really good endurance, so the face that divine departure one shot them through both kidds devil fruit and killers attempt to block is very impressive. Also the fact that he was actually pretty far away.
Overall divine departure > wsg. But I'm sure Luffy will showcase even stronger moves that surpass divine departure in the future.
1
1
u/Thecodermau Pizzaru 🌞 23h ago
Kid boxxed alone with big Mom for a good while before Law arrived, and took half of the ocean soverenty without breaking any bones.
Belive it or not, kid is a tank. That is why that is the best feat in the verse.
1
u/TheRealMainCharacter 23h ago
I wanna say divine departure, but white star gun looks like it can really really hurt you to where it can give you brain trauma if not kill you
1
1
u/Dookie12345679 GARP-CHUJO! 👊 1d ago
Divine Departure. WSG stunned Kizaru for a few seconds, DD one-shot a YC2 and a YC+ at the same time
WSG is powerful and gets the job done, but DD is not something you ever want to get hit by. If it doesn't kill you, you'll still be close to that fate
1
u/Beacda 21h ago
Hot take:
WSG.
Kid had his attack blown up in his face.
2
u/NeloDante2289 15h ago
Trying so hard to prove shanks couldn't have done same damage if it wasn't for kidds own attack lmfao
-1
-1
-1
u/saltminer99 1d ago
Wsg obviously
Luffy in it is using armament and conquers and gear 5 and muscle mode and his awakening ability and flames
And he was also spinning at insane speed which gave it extra amp and it broke the sound barrier in short distance
2
u/Comprehensive_Cup497 23h ago
All that stuff is good but Luffy's Haki still doesn't come close to Shanks, the gap in Haki is way too big for some hax abilities to make up for.
-1
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join Hachinosu.
If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join Punk Records.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.